Coney Island

Simple concept and a staple in Stillwater. My neighbor told me to try this place out and it wasn’t anything fancy. A hot dog is a hot dog. But here, it is done well. Kinda wish the wieners were a little bigger but, it is what it is. I had a coney which had a sweet tangy slaw and chili on it, and a kraut dog. chops and nice cold beer to wash it all down.

Only good after a late night of drinking nothing is well seasoned and almost everything is cooked too long.

I wish this was my building. I was disappointed after taking my family here. I don’t think we will be going back.

Visited on: August 3 2012, July 3 2013
Like most places on The Strip, this place feels old, run-​down, and dirty inside. I’ve had the Fries, Chili Fries, and the Chili Coney (no cheese, no mustard). The fries are good, but the chili is pretty weak, and the coney was whatever.

Went to my old favorite this past weekend after the OSU Super Regionals. The coneys were great and the place was packed! What a great OSU tradition!

Smells amazing every night abd the food is quick but pretty much what you would expect from a «college town» late night munchies, straight from the bar kind of place. Pretty cheap too which definitely helps

This place is fantastic and well placed. They have amazing hot dogs and chili dogs. I haven’t found a place that can beat this. Two guys with weiners on the strip still isn’t as good.

Hmmm, not sure where to start! I guess with how we were greeted… how about not at all! The girl behind counter didn’t say hello or anything, just stood there and looked at us. I finally said, «sorry, never been here. Not sure what to order». This was her cue to let us know what she recommended but maybe 9 of us standing there overwhelmed her. Anyway, we ordered chili dogs, Fritos pies, cheese tots and corn dogs. The hot dog was a weird color and the cheese was the kind from the grocery store. I was reluctant to have my husband eat it for fear of getting sick but he ate it and said it was good. Fritos pie was good, chili had good flavor. Cheese tots looked like they were previously frozen and thawed and re-​frozen. Not good. I’m sure, because of its location, it’s perfect for college students on a budget or for late night, beer drinking, munchies. I, however, will not recommend it. It wasn’t even near a real Coney dog… the name is misleading!

You want coneys? This is the place to get them. Something many don’t appreciate or take for granted… surprisingly, it’s a rare find to be able to get FRIES at a coney shop! Always good, always friendly, hilarious t-​shirts for sale, clean, and very convenient location. I do miss the pool table though, but that was almost 20 years ago.

Been here twice after a night at Outlaws and Murphy’s. It hasn’t disappointed yet. Highly recommend the Heaters!

This place is great for a coney place! Is it a 5 star restaurant? No, but it’s a pretty great place to grab a cheese coney! So if you’re craving a coney, then come chow down!

I have always remembered this place as the absolute best coneys anywhere. Whenever I return to Stillwater, I always get my fix of 2 coneys, fries and a cold beer.

This is a must have when in Stillwater. They have delicious coneys. Try happy hour Monday through Thursday from 2−4pm. They have Coneys, friend onion cheeseburgers, and beers for $ 1.50 each.

There is nothing I enjoy more than having a greasy, fried cheeseburger after a long night out on the strip. The CI is where it’s at when it comes to drunk food. My boy and I love this place.

Good cheap greasy food. They also have some really old arcade games.