Classic Pizza

The smallest large pie I’ve ever seen the pizza was delivered burns or cold rice ball with no meat in it last time I will ever eat there

well ordered delivery and got the Fried Calzone which was soggy but the thing that drove me away was there was NO napkins or a fork you give me a soggy Calzone at least do one thing right with this order and get me a fork smh lol

ordered from them recently pizaa was very soggy and the pepperoni pie was rediculously oily. way to much sauce on the pies. Its sad the old owners made a pretty good pie. Will not be ordering from them again.

So I think this place is actually called Pizza Mia, and I purposely sought them out here on Unilocal to give them the great review that they deserve. After living away from Staten Island for 6 years and then returning, I wanted to find a new go-​to pizza place that delivered to Coast Guard Housing. After trying a few mediocre places, we came across Pizza Mia, and it has been a great experience every time. The prices are reasonable, the services if fast and friendly, and most importantly, the Pizza is INCREDIBLE. We love the square Sicilian Marghareta pie; it’s DELICIOUS!

Not sure if they’re under new ownership but, I just got an incredible calzone from here. Really top notch.
They are under new ownership: Pizza Mia.
I think they are great. Their # is 718−720−1212…

got food poisoning!!!
i won’t eat here if i was starving to death. we ordered some garlic knots and large pizza. it looks like it was a left over. then the guy over charge us, told us the menu changed. we didn’t see any customers so we figure he was overcharging because they are about to go out of business. never again. would definitely go to pronto pizza on bay street, chicken alfredo pizza is the best.

the pizza here is not fantastic. especially the Buffalo Chicken slice. i got delivery from here because all the other pizzerias in the area wouldn’t come to my crib. for years, i tried basically everything on their menu. from salads to sandwiches, it was all a very mediocre experience.
here’s one thing, though. the staff there are AWESOME. the guy who takes delivery orders always recognized my voice (or my roommate’s). they arrived within 15 minutes. well, they were only a block away from us– but still!
i’m a huge Fried Calamari fan and Classic Pizza does it BEST in the whole ‘hood. i lived in Staten Island for a while to have tried many fried calamaris and this joint is on point. of course, the marinara they serve with it adds to the final seal of approval for me. i don’t know why this pizzeria doesn’t use the same sauce for their pizzas, too. i love that damned marinara!
the Hero sandwiches are OK. the Chicken Cutlet was my favorite. they doused the lettuce with lots of mayo and that made me smile. you know, because i love me some mayo.