I’ve been here several times. For the most part, the pizza has been satisfying, although not exceptional by any stretch. Still looking for that spectacular Staten Island pizza that Staten islanders are continuously bragging about.
Tamara G.
Tu valoración: 5 Charleston, Staten Island, NY
I always pick up from the place, they have the best Alfredo pizza and the best garlic knots! The staff is always nice and very attentive!
Clarita R.
Tu valoración: 1 Staten Island, NY
My stuff shells were not cook. They were so hard I could knock someone out with it. The Buffalo Pizza is great, but not enough to order from them again.
Yelp U.
Tu valoración: 5 Staten Island, NY
I like their pizza very much and also the chicken Caesar salad. Even better is the awesome, friendly girl that works the counter. They are super friendly people.
Ryan G.
Tu valoración: 1 Staten Island, NY
So inconsistent. I used to be a loyal customer of almost 10 years. Their product has Ben slipping recently and then all of a sudden BAM they would knock it out of the park. Then crap again. And sometimes it’s take an hour and half for delivery. But tonight was a new low. They messed up our order(after taking almost an hour to get to us) we ordered two different wraps. They made the same wrap twice. We decided rather than wait another our– we would deal and just eat them. When we called for a partial refund we were told they would only do it the driver came back and picked up the old wrap… no more baris for us. Too many other consistent quality equally priced options to deal with this.
Asia L.
Tu valoración: 3 Bronx, NY
Ordered takeout. food took a lil over an hr when I only live a few blocks away. ordered a xtra cheese pizza half pepperoni with buffalo hot chicken fingers and a 2 liter Hawaiian punch. I didnt try the pizza cause ive odeed on pizza as of late but it was extremely cheesy and my 2 kids(girls) devoured the entire medium by themselves. I enjoyed the chicken fingers. they were crispy and all white meat with a yummie buffalo sauce on them. only negative is that I asked for bleu cheese for my chicken but, they gave me ranch. I also asked for garlic powder and herbs for my pizza and received neither. As is the same for the 3 cups/plates and napkins I asked for. food was good tho so I will be ordering again. perhaps try one of their salads Unilocalers have been raving about!
DeeJay M.
Tu valoración: 5 Paterson, NJ
Try the Pepperoni-Broccoli-Onion slice, so delicious everything on the menu is good Try the shrimp salad out of this world
Karen A.
Tu valoración: 1 Staten Island, NY
I work in an office alone about 3 blocks from them, I cannot leave as I am alone in the office. I order everyday because there is nothing else to eat around here and their pizza is pretty good. Our location has been here for about 3 months, 5 days a week, 4.00 a day, so thats been $ 240.00 I have spent so far on their pizza and we are NOT moving so there would have been a lot more money spent on them and now they decide they cannot deliver for less than 10.00 — ok BYEBARI’S I guess Ill find somewhere else to give my money!
Val D.
Tu valoración: 2 Staten Island, NY
Sadly, over the past few years, my experience with this place has changed, which stinks because it was one of my favorite places. The pizza isn’t as good as it used to be. The last few times I’ve ordered anything with chicken(chicken caesar salad, chicken alfredo, and chicken francese), the chicken was undercooked and chewy/gummy. Yuck! Undercooked chicken is dangerous. Plus, the girls who pick up the phones have an attitude problem.
Sean L.
Tu valoración: 3 Staten Island, NY
Delivery was a terrible idea considering it took over an hour. The pizza is surprisingly good, nice amount of cheese sauce and crisp crust… Your standard New York pie. The chicken parm sandwich came soggy, almost as if the sandwich had been microwaved instead of toasted in the oven. Garlic knots were definitely out on the counter for some time and had arrived cold. The cold antipasta was decent. Definitely loaded with ham, but that was the only meat. I would order pickup again, but only for the pie and only if Tonys is closed.
Nid H.
Tu valoración: 4 Edison, NJ
Really liked the pizza! I just had the plain and some garlic knots. It felt like the right level of crunch and spice. I really enjoyed my pizza and would definitely go back again.
Alresch J.
Tu valoración: 4 Newburgh, NY
Call in ahead for quicker service. great food! def a nice little spot to sit in or take out.
Samantha N.
Tu valoración: 2 Brooklyn, NY
I used to love this place but the last few times I ordered food from here it was horrible. I received pizza that was burned, half cooked, and old looking! Also, my company didn’t enjoy the food which was quite embarrassing. Bottom line: this place is a hit or miss, hopefully these guys can step it up with the consistency.
Malia P.
Tu valoración: 5 San Diego, CA
Best local pizza.
Thomas S.
Tu valoración: 4 Staten Island, NY
The food is good. A typical pizzeria. I swing by every now and then on my way home from work to pick up 5 garlic bread balls for $ 1. I like it.
Dwight D.
Tu valoración: 4 Staten Island, NY
I have ordered take-out from this pizza place and I think the service is great. The owners work really hard(like 12 hour days) and still manage to remain really friendly — which is impressive. I tend to stick to more of the non-pizza items on their menu like the salads and sandwiches; and they have always done a good jop with the favorites I used them for. Plus they deal with little requests well. Ex. American cheese and exta garlic on my garlic knots. I even did a large group/catering order with them before and they delivered on-time to my close-by location.
Jerome Espinosa B.
Tu valoración: 4 Manhattan, NY
me & my roommates would order-for-delivery every now and then from them. i’ve had their pizzas many times, including pepperoni, meat lover’s, sausage, olives, sicilian house special — all tasting great, just done perfectly right! fast & prompt service!