Cookie Jar Bakery

LOVE LOVE LOVE the cookies at the Cookie Jar Bakery. My personal favorites: chocolate chip and frosted sugar cookies. I go in for 2 cookies and I always end up buying a dozen!

This place is TERRIBLE! I went there to get cookies for my party and when I got home I ate one and they were ROCK hard! The lady said they were right out of the oven! Nope! They tasted like they were from the side of the road! The next day I had food poisoning! I was puking for so long! I also had severe diarrhea! It was terrible! I am never eating there again ever! It was the worst experience ever! This place should go out of business! AND IT WILL

First time I went tere the chocolate chip cookie was awesome… nice abundance of chocolate chips. The second time I went there I went to bite into the chocolate chip cookie and it was still partially frozen! Not what I was expecting! Once the cookie thawed it was still really good. That experience just soured me a bit. The counter girl should have mentioned something or offered to heat it up.

This place deserves 5 star status. Little small bakery. You walk in and can see all sorts of interesting things. Cookies are the headliner here. Coconut macaroons,
lemon bars, brownies, muffins of various flavors, sandwich cookies, plenty of CHOCOLATE. All are served with plenty of smiles and welcoming attitudes! Ive been here twice recently. I think the cookies have a special «addictive» added to them like crack, cause the first time I was here, I forgot to check in & I NEVER forget to check in anywhere! While your here, you can see over the ½ wall and watch them putting together dough & baking in their oven, obviously with some great love! They sell various cookie jars to take home. Nice little seating area as well. Prices are very reasonable! My problem is, I show up in the late afternoon or early evening when the spectacular items are gone but thats ok, the so called lesser items arent like finishing 3^rd in a race where you receive a consolation prize. Ill gladly take the consolation cookie items! They are that good. Made fresh everyday.
Do treat yourself to a cookie or little «goodie». You are worth it!

Stopped today for a cookie and they are yummy! Not a lot of places like this outside of chain stores, so I am so glad it’s good. Good variety too. Worth the trip!

Was excited to try this place. Bought chocolate chip cookie. On a good note, they’re not cheap with the chocolate chips. But I was really disappointed because there was such an over abundance of chips, it was like eating a small bar of chocolate rather than a cookie.

Selection is great and everyone there is helpful. Nothing to elaborate. Just simple cookies, cook books and cookie jars. Every cookie I’ve had and brownie, macaroon, and layer bars are made perfectly. Simple, great taste and priced for anyone.

Cute, Quaint, Yummy, Sugary, Sweet, Friendly, Love, Happiness. All things you’ll find a the Coolie Jar. There is something for everyone’s tastes.

Very nice Bakery. Fresh cookies and they sell cookie jars. Cookies and coffee were fresh I would go back.

Yes Gawd.
Cookie Jar Bakery is going to be a problem for me…
Anywho thanks to the trusty Unilocal app for letting me know this place even exists! The map is currently wrong though. You will be led a half a mile down the street if you don’t notice the bakery from the street. I adjusted it so hopefully Unilocal updates this!
Walking inside I have to say my initial reaction was blah. The Cookie Jar bakery had about 5 shelves of different cookies available. I was disappointed at first because I was wanting to see cookies all over the F*cking place! I have a tremendous sweet tooth. You don’t even understand. I will turn turn tricks for cookies. Especially good ones! #Whore
My boyfriend and I ordered a mix of cookies (1 dozen) The flavors we chose were:
–Oatmeal
–ChocChip
— a LemonBar
–Iced Sugar cookie w/​peppermint icing
–Snickerdoodle
–PeanutButter
–ChocolateCoveredCherry
The lemon bar I liked. It was different. I think there was maybe coconut in it? not sure. I ate that sh*t so fast that I really need to go back and get another one so I can guess the flavor combo again. The oatmeal was AWESOMESAUCE. I loved it so much. Way better than the chocolate chip. The chocolate chip was good, but I think I am bored with EVERYONES chocolate chip cookie so nothing against The Cookie Jar bakery! The Snickerdoodle & Peanut butter were good.
The sugar cookie with Peppermint icing. I wanted to reach out and touch someone when I bit into that damn cookie. I could’ve slapped the sh*t out of Jesus. I swear I had an out of body experience. That cookie handed me my life on a platter! The chocolate covered cherry cookie was pretty good as well.
I noticed that there were more flavors that weren’t available. This just gives me all the more reason to return. I think what I enjoyed the most is the made from scratch taste these cookies have! I get let down by bakery’s that sell cookies made from frozen dough. There is a HUGE DIFFERENCE in taste.
Cookie jar I’ll be back…

Who doesn’t like cookies!!! This place is cool, I like the idea of a cookie shop. They have freshly baked cookies every day with a couple specialty cookies/​bars that rotate. I really enjoyed the sugar cookies, chocolate chips and the macadamia nut. The peanut butter was okay.
My only negative are the hours. I have been planning to try this place for a couple weeks now and I was going to pick them up in the morning and take them to work. Well they open at 9, and that is too late to bring them into the office so I got them on the way home and tried them for an after dinner snack.

I am from Chicago and found myself in the area visiting family and happened upon this place — what a pleasant surprise. I believe the owner or manager took care of my niece and myself and was a sheer delight. The atmosphere is quaint and friendly but down to the business of this review — the baked goods. The cookies are just so good and buttery and wonderfully rich and homemade. This bakery is as close to what I make at home than anything I have bought. I am a wonderful baker but there are times when you want something good without the work it takes to achieve a delicious product — -THIS IS THE PLACE TO GO. I bought white chocolate Macadamia nut, chocolate chip, buck-​eyed Susan, peanut butter, snickerdoodle and my favorite frosted sugar cookies. I wanted to taste the coffee cake muffins but they were accidentally left out of my bag but when I tasted the other goodies I couldn’t be upset about anything left out everything was soooo good — you won’t be disappointed!!!

I visited the cookie jar for the first time yesterday… i found it to be so charming with its collection of cookie jars, and the cozy, decorated interior. A great place to meet up with my girlfriends for coffee n a brownie. I bought a dozen cookies n half dozen brownies Wow! The brownies are soooo good. Didnt get a chance to even try the cookies before the hubby n kids scarfed them down. The cookie jar is a hidden gem, open til 7PM for a quick stop for dessert on the way home or on the way to see a friend. Will be returning for more cookies n definitely brownies soon.