Sugarcreek Restaurant

This was a nice affordable family restaurant with great service and they give you tons of food! I will definitely be back.

Awesome food and price. Just had my sons 16^th birthday party here. They were very accommodating.

The waitress was rudely pointing out the bandage on my mothers nose from surgery (she had recently been diagnosed with skin cancer) the waitress kept gasping and commenting on it like if it was the most horrifying thing she has ever seen, not only was this unprofessional but very rude and made my mother feel very bad. the food here was horrible. mashed potatoes tasted like it came from a box. agree with the person who said i felt like i was eating at a retirement home. pretty much sum’s it up.

Sugarcreek missed the mark today with their Easter buffet. Rude wait staff, the tasteless food was unappealing. We love the place but for 15.99 I expect more than desserts bought at Aldi’s

Was in Elyria for a dance competition and decided to try this place out for brunch. They’ve got some great menu items and the prices are very reasonable. Would recommend going there to anyone passing through looking for a non-​chain place to eat.

Kinda nasty and over priced. Ordered a chicken philly got a philly cheese steak. Onions and peppers were over cooked and gross and meat looked like a steakum. My son got a rock hard grilled cheese. I’ve had better food at the hospital. Won’t be back!

I’ve been searching for a diner that isn’t fast food or a chain and found it! A slice of heaven with good servers and good food. They have a breakfast buffet that is priced very reasonably, will try that the next time I go! Good biscuits and sausage gravy!

Very good home-​cooked food! The portions were larger than we expected, and we didn’t have to wait long for the food on a Saturday evening. Prompt and courteous service. Plenty of space, does not have that crowded feeling. We will definitely be coming back!

One of my favorite places in Lorain county to eat. I love the breakfast bar on Sundays and the variety the menu has. I’ve been eating at this place for a long time. The portions are very good and you will have to take some of your meal home. Great family restaurant!

What a gem! Came here based on the reviews and the desire for something other than the usual. We ordered:
Open faced meatloaf sandwich
Fettuccini Alfredo
French Dip
Open faced roast beef
Salads were fresh, bean soup was very good.
Everything was fresh and delicious!!! Real mashed potatoes!
This is a must try!!!

Fresh every time I order. Fast friendly service. Here’s another first for me Cajun chicken

Maybe breakfast isn’t the best time to come…
Highlights of our visit: dirty coffee cups, hygiene issues amongst the staff, food that tasted like it was out of a can, and the spider hanging over our table that we had to kill ourselves.
Well, at least the service was friendly, and my pepsi was okay. Suffice it to say, we will not be back.

We were on a cross country road trip and stopped in here because it wasn’t a chain restaurant. That said, when we saw the menu we were scared because usually a menu that is 5 pages long means nothing is fresh, but we were wrong. The wings were made super fresh and were delicious. Everything was super tasty!

Delicious food at a great price! Atmosphere could be refreshed but the value can’t be beat! I love the comfort food (Amish roast turkey) but really can’t wait for the French onion soup!

They have brought back the lost art of good service and great potato skins. I’ve driven past this place most likely 1000 times in my life and never once thought to stop. So glad I did. My belly is full and my wallet didn’t take a dent. The other thing that impressed me, everyone here was talking… to each other. Great family restaurant

We really enjoyed this mom and pop establishment. We had breakfast here everyday while on vacation and we always left stuffed and happy. The skillets, omelettes, and specials were great. Very reasonably priced with quick friendly service.

I love this place. Great food reasonable price. Great customer service. highly recommend.

There isn’t a great deal we can add to the other reviews here. Good, home-​made comfort food. Large servings. Friendly service. It was all there during our visit last night.
My wife had a Mediterranean wrap and I had the beef tips and noodles. Everything was very good with the home-​made potato chips worthy of note.
It’s right off of I-​90 about 20 miles west of Cleveland so it would be a good stop for hungry cross country travelers.

I was really bummed when I realized that for the last 8 years I had been driving past this place without even giving it a second glance, not knowing what treasures were inside.
The little lady and I stopped in one day after reading some good reviews about this place on Unilocal.I was surprised. I had always thought this place was one of those smelly diners that reheated canned vegetables for you and charged you 10 times what it would cost you if you would have just stayed home and made it yourself. It was the exact opposite. You can go in there and get a massive meal for under 10 bucks, and that’s even after leaving a 25% tip. The waitresses make you feel like they actually want you there and really care about the quality of your dining experience. The cooks treat every dish like Michelangelo would treat a piece of marble. The food always comes out in under 15 minutes. I can’t recommend this place enough.

The wife and I like to try local flavor as we travel cross country, and she found this gem as we were transiting through Ohio, and in desperate need of some non-​franchise sustenance.
As other reviews have noted, the décor can be a bit unusual seeming, with a very large fountain in the main floor of the restaurant and a lot of dolls about … but on to the food !
The Sugarcreek Restaurant has a large, varied and extensive menu, including amish inspired recipes. The wife and I ordered the Meatloaf and Amish Turkey dinners, and were frankly blown away by the portion sizes.
The $ 9 Amish Turkey Dinner came with a roll, a salad, a soup and on the entrée plate itself, a larger portion of turkey than I ate on Thanksgiving, about two cups of their unique breaded-​and-​fried-​mashed potatoes, and mixed vegetables. There was plenty of food !
The food was hot, fresh and tasty and left us both positive and satisfied. If we were locals, we’d definitely be back again.