Michelangelo Pizza

Manager is rude and argued about the situation. I just wasted 28 dollars on ONE PIZZA–
Just save yourself and go somewhere else

This place is the best. I came here on a tip from a buddy who hails from NYC, where there are a few more pizza shops run by the same family. The Grandma’s Sicilian is hands down the best slice of pizza I’ve ever eaten. So much flavor in those crushed tomatoes. The meat stuffed pizza was good too. Definitely recommend this place for a piping hot slice of New York pizza down south.

While waiting for my wife’s car to be finished at the Tires Plus next door we decided to stop in for a quick slice and a soda. When we walked in there was only one other couple in there, but I thought «Hey it’s still early for lunch». So we sat down and we ordered a few slices of pizza. Our pizza slices were reheated in the pizza oven, which I don’t mind since it gives it a nice crunchy texture. However, when it was brought to us, the young man dropped out plates on the floor right before handing it to us. Hey things happen, no problem. When we got out replacement slices, the actual taste of the sauce and cheese was just bad. Not only that but there were gnats flying around the entire place and that was absolutely disgusting! That is the main reason that I will not be returning here… ever!

I have tried many of the items on the menu and have thoroughly enjoyed them all. The amount of food you get for the price is somewhat overwhelming as you will always have more than enough to eat.
The only reason it didn’t get five stars is because the young cashier lady has a tendency to be a little bit short and abrupt and can come off rude.
The quality of food is very good.

Loved the pizza and the atmosphere here. I didn’t like the square pizza, but the round was really good and the service was fantastic

Terrible! Ordered food to be delivered, it took forever, and the food was just awful! Called to complain and they were so rude it was ridiculous

Delivery, just down the street 1 hr no big deal, but pizza was cold and appetizers were cold. Coupon not deducted and it was act of Congress to correct and got extra attitude with no up charge for the topping, after eating we called to let someone know food was cold and all I got was a lotta attitude. 1^st time customer. Good pizza but why do I have a bad taste in my mouth?

Words cannot describe the superior service I received here. I started calling to place an order around 9:30 pm, but with no luck for 15 minutes I decided to drive over and see if they could still whip up a pizza before closing. The manager apologized and informed me that she’d sent everyone home already. (I later realized that phones were down in the area, so I suspect that had something to do with why I couldn’t get through and why the staff had gone home early.) To make up for it, she gave me a free extra large pizza they had intended to cut up for walk-​ins — free of charge. I have never experienced anything like this in my life and was utterly stunned. I’d heard great things about this place, so I was eager to try it and I was definitely not disappointed. That is the type of exemplary customer service that sets businesses apart and keeps customers loyal. I will be going back again, and will never forget that kind of kindness. Thank you! The pizza was amazing, and it was that much more delicious because it came with love!

I had a meal catered for 15 people and everyone was delighted with Michelangelo’s entrees. The chicken parm was cooked perfectly: tender and flavorful… as were the meatballs in marinara. The sauce was delicious and the kids very much liked the chicken tenders with fries. What a pleasure it was to serve great food and enjoy my company. Thank you, Michelangelos!

The cashier lady rang up four slices for 25 dollars, an obvious over charge. Then she couldn’t figure out how to fix the mistake and was also extremely rude about it. Pizza is mediocre and this is not the first time the service has screwed up.

Great salad, nice and fresh. Fried calamari appetizer was cooked properly and tasty. Wife had linguini and white clam sauce. Generous portions and she said it was the best in town. I had Calamari Fra Diavalo over spaghetti. Also best in town. The new server was good and thus the service. We will definitely be back. I would have said 5 stars, but I reserve that for best in the country. This place isn’t that, but it is the best in town.

The only thing I can say is, there were more attitudes than flies. Back door wide open to trash bins. Ordered a slice and a beer…“no beer my brother is working on that”. My first time in I had no problem getting a beer and a slice. seems to me someone is asleep at the switch.

Thieves– we ordered a pizza and the bill was to be split– well they charged both cards, and when we called to get it fixed they said we had to drive to get the refund. So we rush to get there– as our pizza is getting cold; we didn’t make it in time before they closed so we are having a 45.00 pizza.

The pizza here is good, but the customer service is terrible. Manager has no customer service skills either. They don’t care if the customers are satisfied or not.

I had the chicken Parmesan pizza and wasn’t a big fan of the sauce. The pizzas are large and most definitely not shy on the amount of toppings that they give you. The flavor of the crust could use some work. The music is fun, upbeat and the service staff is exceptional. All in all it was a pleasant experience.

Not bad, not great. Heard that the pizza was phenomenal so I had to see for myself. It was ok.

It’s hard to find good pizza in Florida. I was very happy when Michael Angelo opened their location near where I live on University Parkway, since I use to go to their location in Lakewood Ranch. I love their Sicilian Pizza 16×16 thick crust. It taste even better the next day. I’ve had it with toppings and just plain I am never disappointed. My mother is a soup lover and she loves their Pasta Fagioli. It smells delicious and she always has a bowl. The Stromboli for (2) is truly for (2). It’s huge. I have also had their white pizza and it’s really yummy. Last but not least Tortellini Della Nonna is my favorite pasta dish. I have it frequently when I order from them. To end the meal on the sweet side, you must have a cannoli. I love them. You can dine in, take out and they deliver.

A great place to frequent, authentic Italian food and reasonable price. The pizza is thin crusted and cooked to perfection. You can also try Grandma’s Pie, an old favorite just like Mom used to make.

Great sandwich/​soup lunch combo, dangerously yummy Stromboli, bowl-​licking good tiramisu, all for a great price.

Gorgonzola salad… ahhhhmazing! Mamas Sicilian pizza… pretty good. I’ve only ordered those 2 items the three times I’ve eaten here. Delivery is crazy slow. like an hour every time. and the pizza does arrive on the colder side. I’d suggest takeout fo sho!