Natasha’s Attic

I walked in looking for an eighties costume. I had no idea what I was looking for. The initial sales consultant I worked with was extremely disappointing, pretty much showed me a wall of some costumes and walked away. I almost left when I met the owner Natasha and another consultant, who proceeded to help me visualize an outfit channeling Prince. I stepped outside my box at their urging and played around with a look I would not have dreamed off. She is older and truly a classy, elegant lady. Thank you @natasha.

This place is seriously the best costume shop I’ve ever found — and I’ve been in many. Their product selection has high range and low range, things for kids, costumes to rent, and the amount of props and makeup they carry are second to none. My favorite part is the amazing customer service. Everyone who works there is always so helpful, and also incredibly knowledgeable. I always leave with a great purchase and happy with what I found. I highly recommend and always look forward to my next visit!

Awesome shop. I can’t believe I’ve never been here. Amazing selection. Like ¾ of the store is for purchase and about ¼ for rent. I went in looking for a Rockabilly outfit. I really didn’t even know what rockabilly style was. But the people there totally helped me. They had several outfits for me to pick from for my look. When it came time to try it on, the woman helping me went back and forth and brought me several sizes and gave me suggestions. I found the perfect dress and they even offered free alterations. Then Philip, who was working the front with all the accessories, helped me pick out a head piece and gave me lots of pointers on what would work with the outfit. He was filled with knowledge. He was amazing. I ended up renting a petty coat and let me rent it for a few extra days bc my event is 5 days out. I will come here for all my costume needs going forward!

Wow, this costume shop is AMAZING — they have EVERYTHING! My family all rented costumes for my grandfather’s 90^th birthday party and I actually purchased a dress and just rented the shoes.
They spent the time to help get the dress all tied up and stuff and even altered it right there with no extra charge!
I would highly recommend!

I really enjoyed my experience here. First of all, the second I walked in I was greeted and asked if I needed help. As someone who worked retail, that’s always a sign of good service. Second, I explained I was looking for a wig for a specific costume (I was going for Tina Belcher from Bob’s Burgers). The owner helped me with looking at wigs and looking at the picture of the character found one that matched perfectly. She was highly knowledgeable and very efficient and kind. She explained about the wig cap for trying on, and to me that’s a sign of a high quality shop. If I’m buying a wig that isn’t a cheapy 20.00 deal, I’d like to be sure that it’s sanitary. Yes, the wig was a little more than I had originally intended on paying but the quality was outstanding and it looked absolutely perfect. Mind you, this transaction occurred 20 minutes before they closed and they were not rushing me out the door by any means. For anyone who complains about the no return policy, they seemed to have rectified the notice because 1) they had several very clear signs, 2) they verbally explain the policy and 3) there is a bright pink sticker on the receipt that says it as well. I’m totally fine with a costume shop having such a policy because, hello, everyone would return things all the time if they did not because most people only want to wear a costume once. This is a great place for cosplayers. Thank you so much for being kind and helpful! It’s a little pricey (hence knocking off a star) but I was highly satisfied with my experience. Thanks for helping me be a perfect Tina!

Last minute costume needed for my husband for a 70s party. Looked online and went to Natasha’s Attic. Had a short wait, but when the hubby got in to see Cathy — WOW. She knows her stuff. She knew exactly what to do, what items would work best together and has a crazy, awesome sense of humor and a great laugh! The cost of renting all items for the outfit was VERY reasonable. Would definitely go back and highly recommend the shop. It has everything you can think of!

Thank you Natasha’s Attic for having great service and a fabulous selection of outfits in my size. I needed a corset for a Bohemian-​Moulin Rouge NYE party. The staff promptly found the perfect one and a matching skirt. It’s nice to have the option to purchase each piece of your costume separately, in case you need a different size for a top or bottom. The items are reasonably priced. I know this from experience, since my daughter was a competitive dancer and cheerleader.

Perfect if you are looking for renaissance faire attire!!! Fun & they have a lot of options.

Great little costume shop if you happen to be in the area. I bought my Halloween costume from here this year and found everything I needed and more.
This was my first time visiting this costume shop so I really wasn’t expecting a whole lot. Some of the other costume stores I’ve been to in the past are either catered to kids or ridiculously overpriced. I went in looking for some makeup, fangs, dress clothes, and contact lenses for my vampire costume. They pretty much had everything I needed for my costume, but I didn’t end up buying the contacts because they were a little more expensive that I was willing to pay.
Customer service was awesome, they helped me find the perfect sized dress for my costume and even made some minor adjustments so it would fit me better. I was really pleased with how it turned out in the end. Some of the items and props are a little expensive, but for the most part I got everything I needed at a reasonable price.
This will be my go to store for next Halloween, I already saw some costumes here that gave me ideas for next year.

Buyer beware. Good place for crafts folk who already can do theatre make-​up. Not so good for the rest of us.
1. Over priced
2. Cheap quality/​cheaply made products
3. Mediocre CS
4. No return policy (which @ their prices is messed up)
I may shop again but for limited items.

Came in here the day before Halloween in a rush to get a costume for a party. Ever other place had been just about cleared out but this place still had a huge selection for such a small store, I found something i wanted and they even let me try it on. The staff was also extremely friendly cant wait until next Halloween!

Costumes are the best thing, and this place is the best costume shop.
So I love a good costume. Halloween, random theme event, an adventurous Tuesday night… there’s always an occasion for a costume. And if you’re in need then Natasha has got your back. Take a trip to her closet and you’ll find just about anything your imagination can come up with.
They have costumes for sale and rent. Also lots of high end masks and wigs.
Best part: they’re open year round for all of your costume needs!
Only drawback is no returns. But just know what you want and you’re good!

They don’t ever answer their phone and the store is a mess. Way too many customers, not enough employees to help. Small store doesn’t accommodate much.

Score! Came here two years in a row and found exactly what I needed and things I didn’t even need. I’d rather skip out on going to spirit and coming straight here instead.
The store is super small but they have so many selections, I could understand why everyone is shoulder to shoulder.
The whole staff does an excellent job with service. From the dressing room to the registers. They also offer alterations FOR FREE!
Happy Halloween everyone!

Just went in for a Halloween costume, and I knew I wanted some sort of awesome corset …
Came out with an amazing steam punk-​esque corset that is seriously from my dreams. Made my day and my Halloween ! Can’t wait to use this for many years to come
Definately a place to come and find any costume you’d ever need. Wigs, masks, outfits, everything is here!

I spent more than an hour here today but I couldn’t find anything.
They have lots of options and very helpful staff but very expensive.

Natasha’s Attic is the BEST!!! My husband and I knew for 2 weeks we were going to the Renaissance Faire today. But we didn’t decide to get costumes till 6:45 PM Friday night. No problem! The staff was absolutely amazing. Showing us the options of buying vs. renting. We decided to rent. Rosa took us to the back and hooked us up! It was Celtic weekend my husband had the whole outfit. Kilt, Sash, puffy shirt, hat. Being a happily married couple we’ve gained weight together. I was worried they wouldn’t have anything nice that was plus size. But Rosa said not to worry. Assuring us they do alterations right there. The staff worked great as a team one worked on the Kilt. I went as a Renaissance Gypsy. The skirt, petty coat, belts and scarfs that jingle. Head scarf with beaded head dress and the perfect necklace. Totally accessorized us from top to bottom! The choices for any event were unbelievable! Since mid-​October a lot of people were there to get Halloween out fits! They have every era, every decade not one thing I could think of they didn’t have. Another thing I thought was awesome was that even if we decided to go with a purchase costume, they offered to alter those too! The customer service is amazing. We posted our pictures to Facebook page. The website is awesome too if you want to plan ahead. All this and we walked out at 7:56 PM 4 minutes before closing! We had a great time with our friends at the Faire and all thanks to the staff at Natasha’s Attic!!!

I go here every Halloween for my costumes. THIS is where you go for high quality and unique threads. Wonderful selection of makeup, authentic Venetian Masks straight from Italy, and a variety of accessories. As a matter of fact I’m dropping in this weekend before all the good costumes are gone!

I never knew this place was even here until a few months ago when my uncle announced his engagement and that they wanted a Renaissance wedding. Then also asked me to be his photographer. Oh what to wear!
It looks a bit like a hole in the wall when you drive up but as soon as you walk in the place looks huge and full to the brim with all kinds of costumes and accessories! There are 2 different options here. 1: you can chose to put together your own costume make it exactly the way you want and buy to keep. 2: you can rent a costume that is pretty much already put together in the back. Renting is actually the less expensive of the options and since this was a one time event I chose to go with that.
I explained my situation them how it was Renaissance themed and I was going to be taking pictures so I needed to be able to move around no problem. I also didn’t want to stick out or capture attention as the attention is supposed to be on the wedding and guests.
The lady Natasha (owner) took on my task with enthusiasm asking if it was ok if I trusted her instincts, rushed off and came back with the perfect garments.
I was iffy at first having never tried on actual Renaissance attire but after trying it on I was sold!
The whole experience only took about 30 mins and when I went to pay I was actually taken back at how affordable it was. They do however put a hold of $ 300 on a credit or debit card so make sure you bring one with you.
I will absolutely come back, I’m even thinking about coming back for a Halloween costume! :D

FYI — Not the place to get kids costumes as there are none to select from. But if you are searching for adult costumes, then this is definitely the place to go. There’s quite alot of choices to choose from and a large variety. You can definitely take in the time and search through everything as you won’t find them in most places like the Spirit Halloween stores, Party City, Spencers and other costume places.

Great costume store compared to others I’ve been to! I highly recommend this store if you’re going to a themed party, dressing up for Halloween, or dressing up for FUN! the staff here was very welcoming and helpful! You have the choice of buying costumes or renting! For me, I love options and different alternatives so that worked great for me.

This is a great place, the staff is very helpful, and the selection of items they carry is constantly evolving and growing. They always seem to have just what I am looking for.

Great selection of costumes to rent or buy.
I got a good quality Caesar’s costume for $ 49.
The rentals are around $ 105 and they are better and heavier material, but they were not nice enough to justify the price for me.
Staff was friendly and helpful.

Pretty much every kind of costume you can image, they’ve got it here for sale or rental… if you’re a dude.
If you’re of the non-​dude persuasion, they’ve got any kind of sexy costume you could ever want. Good luck going neutral, is all I’m saying.
I needed a costume for a work event and would’ve liked to get something a little more modest than they had here, but their selection of products and prices really was probably the best I’d seen given all the shops I visited after with the same costumes for much, much more money and in a lesser condition.
The staff here were very helpful, albeit a bit hover-​y, though I think they have to be when trying on their sometimes delicate rental wares. The dressing rooms don’t have mirrors in them but they are blocked off in the back of the store facing the rather large rental costume collection. While you change, whomever your attendant is will wait outside the door and you’ll have to walk out to see what you look like in the costume. I, personally, like to try things on in a more private manor and overall I’m not a super big fan of other people’s opinions, so I wasn’t thrilled with having to walk out in front of people in what turned out to be less of the skirt suit that I thought it was and more of super short cheerleader-​looking skirt and midriff-​baring half jacket.
The attendant was a great cheerleader and insisted I looked great in it though it was clear she sensed my uncomfortableness and suggested that I could make the outfit more work appropriate my adding my own slacks (of which I own none) to the jacket, instead of the skirt.
Even thought they veer toward the sexy side for ladies costumes, I’d for sure come back for costume accessories and ideas as they, again, were one of the better costume shops I visited.

I was on the hunt for a last minute 1920s outfit for a friend’s Flapper/​1920s themed birthday party to celebrate her 30^th and the ‘Farewell to the 20s’ fiesta. I had been to Natasha’s a few years ago but it was a different location so I was familiar with their selection.
Originally I had been looking at the ‘buy’ options. I was on the left side of the store and when I was trying on some things in the dressing room I could hear voices on the other side of the wall. I remembered they had a rental area so after giving up on buying something I decided to see what options they had.
The costume selection for rentals is crazy good. They had old fashioned mickey mouse costumes with full ‘mascot’ style head, easter bunny costumes, elaborate headpieces with feathers and jewels, and countless others in the back.
I was greeted promptly by Katie but they had 3 people in front of me so I said I wouldn’t mind waiting. I understand that this is a rental service and people want the best options for their look. While I waited I browsed the other costumes for sale. They have a selection of really good quality costumes that are legitimately costumes instead of the polyester/​vinyl stuff you would see at other pop stores around Halloween. Though many of the costumes were for women that I saw. I guess they like playing dress up more than men? Anyhow, I skimmed through the rental photo albums they had available and was impressed with all the pictures I saw.
When it was my turn I was taken to the back area and shown a series of zoot suit style outfits. I mentioned the girls would be wearing flapper dresses and she immediately had a suggestion to pair with their look. I was impressed on the honest recommendation since the outfit likely rented for less than a suit may have. I ended up with a hat, suspenders, shirt, armbands (one with a mini flask!), shoes, and tie. The colors were black and white and it looked perfect since the girls were wearing black dresses.
The rental cost $ 70 and I picked it up the same day. Compared to other options I saw, I saved money from having to purchase a full outfit I would likely not wear again. Also, the quality of the rental was better than the items available for purchase.
Big thanks to Katie and the rest of the staff for all their help during my last minute costume crisis!