Fifth Avenue New York Pizza

ABSOLUTLEY LOVE THIS PLACE ! The pizza is so fresh and the service is great. Very cute little restaurant in the Gaslamp district!

Came here for lunch yesterday and it was SOOO delicious! My server, Koksal was really nice and the service was amazing! I got the supreme pizza and it was honestly one of the best pizza i have ever tried! Prices are reasonable compared to other pizzerias around the area!
Very cute interior decorations and i definitely recommend this place!

To give this place 1 and a half stars is being generous. We ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni and mushroom after Mardi Gras. Since this was the most convenient spot across the street from where we stayed, we decided to give it a shot. By the time we got back to our room 5 minutes later, the pizza was luke warm. To describe the taste would be comparing it to 1980’s school cafeteria pizza at best. After eating here I wanted to make a run for some gourmet DiGiornos from Ralph’s. Since I was lazy, I ended up eating the pizza after all which I later found out was the box it came in. Oh well, it tasted the same.

Had to grab a quick bite before House of Blues. Cheap, tasty, efficient. Not a bad place to grab a slice. I like a more of a refined crust, but not bad for what I wanted.

I was hungry and they fed me. I am not too hard to please.
The main goal for this place is to serve pizza to (mostly) disgruntled drunk people that forget how to walk by themselves. So don’t expect some gourmet meal. It’s just a quick fix of greasy food to soak up your alcohol and/​or help your munchies go away. If you come in shit-​faced you might throw it up anyway and then the meal won’t even matter.
They offer what is expected.

THE GOOD: Open Late in a place where late night snacks are a must. Located in a perfect spot downtown San Diego. They have plenty of pizza hot and ready almost always.
THE BAD: Not that good. It’s first cousin to 7-​Eleven ‘s pizzas taste. The prices are outrageous. Way too expensive!!! The service REALLY SUCKS!!! I’ve been here more than a few times. The service sucks!!!
ALL IN ALL: If you can, skip it. I gave it more than one star because its open late and its in a pretty good location if you can’t drive for needed late night food.

Horrible customer service and terrible pizza, it was way overdone and not worth my time or money.

This seems to be the place to go for San Diego’s 5^th Avenue party goers. We stopped in at around 10:30pm on a Friday night after hitting a few bars in the area and the man told me they would be open until 3am! Crazy hours. We each got different slices – cheese, pepperoni and jalapeño and the veggie. They were all fine and the service is, of course, fast since they just heat up your preferred slice of the pre-​made pie. This place isn’t anything to write home about, but if you are craving some pizza after a night out in Gaslamp this is a quick and easy spot.

The worst pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life! There was a group of 5 us that ate here on Saturday night and ALL of us hated it. It was like eating cardboard. It’s not that hard to mess up pizza either but they managed to do it. Most of our group took a few bites and then threw it away, it was that bad, About an hour after I ate I felt sick and had to go go back to my hotel to vomit! That bad pizza taste is now permanently burned in my brain. It was hard, tasted old, no flavor and the sauce was dry and transparent. Next time if I’m in desperate need of pizza and nothing else around… I’m going to 711 I’m pretty sure it’s way Better than this place. Save your energy and your acid reflux on a place that’s more deserving! (Ps, they charge $ 1 for an ounce of ranch dressing)

After another rambunctious night in gaslamp we were disappointed that Brians 24 was closed for remodeling. We randomly saw this place and stopped in for some late night fuel. We had the garlic cheese pizza and hot wings. I’m not a huge pizza person but the thin crust pie was pretty legit in the early morning. The wings were really good. Food came out fast and piping hot.

Only place that was opened late, not very good pizza. Regretted it after first slice. Toppings were alright but crust was toasted. My buddies who were drunk enjoyed it. Crust is pre-​made, they just add toppings and run through oven. Prices are good though.

We came in here to grab a pizza before we walked back to our hotel and my friend got two slices and accidentally dropped one. The lady at the counter said she would give him another slice and then when we ordered a whole pizza to go and asked for that slice she promised for our friend she said, «that’s not my problem.» She started to act like an asshole and we left before it escalated. The pizza sucked when we got to our hotel. I’ve had such better pizza downtown. It was hard and rubbery by the time we ate it back at the hotel. Don’t go here they’re rude and their pizza sucks!

Get the meatball lasagna. Feeds 2 people. Comes with garlic bread. Pretty filling

Late night pizza run!
Decided we’d check out the closest pizza place to us (also they had a free drink if you check in offer… SCORE!).
Unfortunately, this was not the best pizza we’ve ever had. My boyfriend got a mushroom calzone which was, and I quote: «okay, but not the best. Overloaded with cheese, very little mushrooms, lack of marinara. The bread tasted burnt and was soggy from the cheese.»
My cheese pizza was over done on the bottom, which made it very hard to bite into and chew. It was almost rubbery. /​:
Our total was $ 12 for the slice of cheese and the mushroom calzone.

Probably the worst pizza I’ve ever eaten. Ordered a medium BBQ chicken. The crust was thin as cardboard and I needed a magnifying glass to find the chicken. Never again. I’ll find a Domino’s first.

Bought a slice because they were 1 of 4 food places open after the bars closed down. Service was really nice and fast so that’s where the 3 stars come from. The pizza is meh-​not that fresh nor flavorful and the cheese was plasticky, but I was happy to at least have something to eat at that hour after drinks.

Best pizza in San Diego. Slide just $ 3 and very clean. People very friendly and nice. Salad is amazing too the Greek salad. Fresh and good.

The pizza is average and the experience was poor — one of the people in our group ordered a salad and after serving the rest of us our food informed us that they had no lettuce to make the salad, really?

Great place to go if you’re in a rush downtown San Diego and you want a quick bite. Everytime i’ve walked by, never busy so the service shouldn’t have a reason to be bad which it wasn’t. I was starving and wanted a bite to eat before a concert since i hadn’t eaten all day and didn’t want to be schwasted with an empty stomach. I just got 2 slices of pizza and asked if they had any other and they were nice enough to offer to make another type if it was what I wanted.
The pizza wasn’t out of this world, but it wasn’t bad either, for the price it’s a good deal and a good size. :)

Slice of cheese pizza.
Slice of pepperoni/​sausage pizza.
Both were tasteless.