Atlantic Bay Insurance

DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THESE PEOPLE!!! Their customer service and follow through is ATROCIOUS! I have my auto and home owner’s insurance with them and have had nothing but problems. They are negligent and irresponsible and occasionally downright rude. I’ll be taking my business elsewhere and suggest anyone else who is unfortunate enough to be involved with them do the same.

Run as fast as you can!
Horrible service and follow up. Unprofessional, and just plain stupid people work here.
After having them for almost 2 years, they have not provided my car loan lender, with my insurance information. I just found this out today!!! I called in 2013 said they would do that for me.
George and Gina. Fire them. They never do anything they said they will.

After searching several insurance companies, Atlantic bay offered me the most affordable policy and provided awesome service.
The staff was was very friendly and greeted me with enthusiasm. They took the time to go over several policy options and helped me choose the best one for me.
I highly, without any reservation, recommend this insurance agency for anyone who is looking for great insurance shopping experience.

DO NOT GET CAR INSURANCE HERE!!! I was referred here through a car dealership when I bought my car. BIG MISTAKE!!!
The original policy he quoted me was different from the bill I received… and not just a little different– like $ 40 more then what he said it would cost. He got me insurance from Commerce West (A MapFre Company). They are way overpriced for the lowest insurance! I was with them for 6 months and could not stop counting down the days to leave their ass! I needed an SR-​22 and they said they filed one and never did. I got a notice in the mail for a notice of suspended license. George is who I dealt with… He didn’t do anything for me over the phone. I had to take the time out and go to the office off Howe. Total waste of time. Then I had to go to the DMV for 5 hours to show proof of insurance/​SR-​22. My renewal just came in the mail and went from $ 165/​month to $ 216.92!!! Are you effin kidding me!!! This is the worst insurance broker and the worst insurance I have ever had. I hope they shut their doors asap so no one else gets screwed!