Sweet Island Cafe

We came here on a Sunday afternoon and the place was empty, except for the girl that worked there and her friend sitting at one of the tables. I was in the mood for a crêpe with cottage cheese but they were out so I settled for Nutella and strawberries. We also got a zapiekanka with mozzarella, ham and mushrooms. The time it took for our food to be served? Almost 30 MINUTES!!! RI-​DI-​CU-​LO-​US.

Really tasty spinach pierogies, served with a side of sour cream, just like they do in Eastern Europe. As a Polish-​Russian person, I approve! Coffee is really good too, and the service is quick! A great place to sit down, chill, and read a book.

Tiny local place.
Food is great and it is immaculately clean.
Service is also wonderful.
Wifi!
I’ll definitely be back!

This place is so small and cute. I got a frozen yogurt and it was pretty creamy. I could’ve been fooled into thinking it was actual ice cream. They only have one flavor: vanilla. Luckily I’m a fan. The girl behind the counter was so sweet and blond and gorgeous, which was an added bonus. Overall, very good experience. I’ll be back to try the crepes and perogis!!!

Just a quick update — I had the pierogis last week, and they were honestly the best that I have had in all of Ridgewood — seriously — even the fancy Polish restaurant with the knight in front of it couldn’t come close (their piergois were really dry and tasted frozen to me). The staff are seriously so, so sweet and accommodating. As I sat down to wait for my food, the owner brought out a few tabloids and English language newspapers so I wasn’t bored. It seems like they are doing well; every time I pass by, I see people sitting in this cute little space. These are the types of businesses that we need to have in Ridgewood! Pleasant, inexpensive Mom & Pop cafes with affordable prices and food of extraordinary quality. I also got another $ 3.50 turkey sandwich with red peppers, tomatoes, romaine lettuce, onions, and cheddar cheese. I felt absolutely stuffed, and stuffed with healthy, quality food. I wish them the best of luck!