Wings Plus

With such mixed reviews I was curious to try this place, but I won’t be returning. Got the boneless wings with honey mustard sauce and the Yukon potato wedges. The wings were dry, varied greatly in size and had an unpleasant texture, and were unevenly covered with sauce. The potato wedges were ok but lacked ANY seasoning.

In response to your comment, I did a survey of several local wing establishments and it seems that yours was the only one that raised the prices during super bowl sunday. In fact one of the establishments I called not only had the same price for their wings on any day they were offering a couple of free appetizers as a special for Super Bowl Sunday at the same price. If what you state about your suppliers raising their prices during this time is true then I would suggest shopping around for a different supplier. I also checked local supermarkets in the area and their wing prices did not inflate at all like you are stating happened to you. As far as the price of $ 96.00 that is what your girl on the phone said.
I do agree with you about paying $ 70.00 for a dozen of roses this weekend is price gouging.
If you would like me to recant or revise my comments then maybe you could provide some invoices from December till February showing the 40% increase in your cost of wings and the 300% increase in celery. I would be glad to state my mis-​information.

If you like amazing burgers this place is a must! Although there wings are a little pricey, they are very good, I wouldn’t say the best, but pretty close! My favorite is their burger! They make the best burger around!!! So fresh! Everything on their menu is very fresh. Like I said it’s pricey so we don’t order often, but when we do my husband and I always get the burgers!!! They also have great jalapeño poppers! As a restaurant manager myself, I don’t mind spending the extra money if the quality of food is good. And this place definitely is fresh hands down! Refreshing to see, since most places offer frozen apps ie fridays!

Wings were only OK and at $ 10.99 for 10 wings at a takeout place, the price is absurd! Mozzarella sticks were really good though.

Ordered takeout last night. The girl in the store was very sweet but I still have to be honest their wings are expensive and the taste does not live up to the charges. Only the onion rings won my taste buds. The wings were dry and the meat is kinda plain except the outside portion smeared with watery sauce. And so was the half rack ribs.

I just cannot get enough of this place. I’ve been ordering from here since 2009, and I’ve never been disappointed. Solid service, delicious food, speedy delivery and pick up times… what more could you want? There’s always something new to try, but our favorite menu item has to be the traditional medium wings. The coconut shrimp is also excellent. The spinach and artichoke rangoons are also fun if you’re up for something different. They also surprisingly have many healthy options. Grilled chicken, roasted chicken, salads, grilled shrimp… you name it.

I’ve tried this place several times thinking ok maybe they’re just having a bad day… HORRIBLE EVERY TIME I can’;t believe they got worse as time went on. Its like taken the cheapest chicken they can buy and dumping grease on it. Even the celery was bad… really how much can celery cost. I would never ever recommend this dump it has to be the worse food establishment anywhere. these guys should’ve learned about the business before practicing on the people of Port Washington. It doesn’t deserve the one star. There should be a negative star rating here.

About five of us ordered delivery for lunch at work one day. More often then not, when it’s that many people and that big of a delivery order, there is an incredibly long wait and something gets forgotten. Unless you order from Wings Plus! They showed up a little more than half an hour, our entire order was perfect and they even included an extra slice of pie on the house! The food was absolutely delicious! We got Chicken Quesadillas and Medium Chicken Tenders with ranch on the side and an order of curly fries. The hot sauce was perfect, definitely hot enough, and it was good, thick ranch dressing (not runny like it can be). The portions were out of this world! The quesadilla had high quality cheese and the spices were so tasty. A colleague ordered jalapeño poppers which were outstanding! Someone else ordered the chilli and he said it was very tasty. We also ordered a salad with oil and vinegar. The ingredients were fresh and presentation was very good. Last but not least was the complimentary apple pie. It was so good!!! We will DEFINITELY be ordering from them again!

I just don’t get some of the negative reviews written here. I have ordered from Wings Plus several times and my family and I were never disappointed.
The «Boneless Chicken Wings» reviewed previously are tasty and frankly have never stunk up my garbage can because there were none left. The fact the owner is responding to reviews establishes a commitment to quality and the overall customer experience.

You know what I do love about this place. The owner is a great guy. That is the world to a company. Keep it up!!!

Rick R.: it’s a serious review. The fact that I have no other reviews doesn’t make it any less credible. And I’m not hiding behind anything; if you’d like contact info, I’d be happy to provide. I don’t frequent this site and, obviously, I don’t review food much, so that should say something about my experience.
Everything stated in my review represented my feelings on your food. Nothing more, nothing less. The wings I ordered were indeed boneless, and they were, as I previously stated, hard to eat. Saying something has «texture» doesn’t excuse the meal I received. Check some of the other reviews on here. I’m not the only one who thinks the boneless wings were overdone and the sauce resembled nothing close to honey barbecue, so why are you so surprised to hear it?
I couldn’t care less about your «track record». Tell me that your wings are rated #1 in the world. They weren’t good.
It’s glaringly obvious now that you actually don’t like to hear all feedback. I gave you an honest review of your food, and if you can’t take it, then you shouldn’t be in business. It’s laughable to see a restaurant owner get so overly-​defensive about his food and to go as far as assuming that I’m being deceptive. If THAT’S the food you stand behind, you’d be better off standing somewhere else.
And I’ll pass on your free wings offer; even if you were paying me, I’d prefer not to stink up my garbage can.

Ok, I have to admit, I have given this place a few chances. I have yet to be blown away. Things I have tried:
Parmesan Garlic boneless– these come to you in chowder-​like sauce (not like typical wing places which serve them in a dry rub) They are awkward tasting and I never ordered them again.
Honey BBQ boneless– I’m from Texas and whatever they think they are using for honey BBQ, they clearly have it mislabeled! Its not at all sweet and I couldn’t even detect BBQ sauce. Strange.
Honey Mustard boneless– ok but not great
After giving up on the wings, I thought I couldn’t go wrong with a cheese quesadillas. I specified it being made with red onions (which I know they have because they have put them on my baked potato before) and it arrived with just cheese. Just 4 little triangles for $ 6.99. WTF?! I wanted to cry.
Game over. Never again. Sorry guys.

Ehhh. It’s not great, it’s not terrible. I do agree with one of the other reviewers everything is super saucey. Like drenched in sauce. I had their honey mustard (not stellar, not bad) my friend had their hot wings (good-​ish) and it was served reasonably warm.
It’s not a bad spot it’s just kind of blah. Not great, not bad, just somewhere in between.
If you get it to stay the space is super small (doesn’t affect my rating — you obviously know it will be a little cramped if you sit in a small store). The staff is super friendly though, and the location is very easy to get to.

I’m still happy as a clam with the Kids at Wings Plus. The keep delivering the same good food: my delivery is always well packed, complete, hot and quick. Sometimes I get free pie or salad. Free always tastes better. I’ve started to like the meatloaf and potatoes here big time.
Don’t know what to eat for dinner? Need a change from Chinese or pizza?
Your answer is Wings Plus.
You’re welcome.

Good wings but they don’t pay attention to detail. This is the second time we have ordered and key items are not delivered with the order. A wings place but should be sure to bring the blue cheese and celery.

Great wings! Atomic wasn’t as spicy as the other atomics i’ve had, but still great wings! The staff was very friendly. I’ll def go back!

Too salty or too saucy. I ordered from this place twice so far and both times I thought there was too much sauce on the wings. One time I called for the delivery and ordered boneless wings with chilli sauce and the wings were literally swimming in the chilli sauce, meaning it wasn’t crispy at all. My friend and I also got a piece of fried chicken and her piece wasn’t even cooked well. Inside was kinda bloody. Disappointing. Next time we ordered wings with parmesan and garlic sauce. This time the wings were covered with thick parmesan sauce which was too heavy. If they cook fried chicken perfectly and put enough but not too much sauce on it, it would taste amazing but they don’t do either one well. Their fries were also too salty and chili that comes on the side is too mild (or not that good).
Sadly, I don’t think I would eat here or order from here ever again.

I’ve definitely had better wings before. I’ve heard a few people rave about the wings here and when I actually ate there, I was so disappointed. They had no flavor! Maybe I’m a wing snob because I think Croxley’s makes the best wings on Long Island, but how can you mess up a recipe if you only make wings? Seriously…

4÷18÷2013
I found this place out recently. And I’ve been here pretty often ever since. I loveeee chicken so this is a great place for me :).
I read that this place is the winner of 2011 and 2012 for best chicken. And I can understand why. The chicken is really delicious.
The place itself is pretty small. But there are still a few places to sit and eat. I usually take the food to go. But sometimes I do eat here and it’s not bad.
The location is pretty good too considering its right next to the lirr station.
I usually always get the combo deal with the wings, sides and drink. The atomic flavor is the best! But today I decided to get the buffalo chicken pizza and it was better then i expected it to be.

It took me a while to find this place, but definitely glad I did… The place is a decent wings place, perhaps one of the better ones on the island… I guess i am spoiled from the one i got accustomed to in Maine.
Anyhow, the place is clean and primarily a take-​out joint. We’ve been to the place twice and tried various type of wings, along with some of the appetizers.
The wings are definitely worth coming back for… We gave thai chili, fiery garlic parmesan, atomic, and medium wings a chance, and boy we were not disappointed. The Atomic flavor is definitely not for the average person, but it was tolerable by our group.
Overall, a great place if it is wings, you crave…