Theatre Three Productions

Always a good time. Productions are very thought out, actors talented, not a bad seat in the house. Saw a few plays here, favorite being Little Shop of Horrors. Recently seen– Beau Jest, Oliver, and Godspell among many others. I’ve also seen comedy shows in this theater, and those are great as well.
Just purchased my tickets to see Shrek the Musical. Very excited for that one. Next year they will have Legally Blonde — what’s not to love?

Must see. Better than Broadway. The actors were incredibly talented, they blew me away. I have never been so moved by a theatrical performance in my life.
The choreography, lighting, effects, and delivery were far better than anything I have ever seen. I can’t believe something like this can be found on Long Island. I’m so glad I went.
I sat a Christmas carol with my girlfriend as part of a group function. The house was packed, and for good reason. I think my ticket was $ 25 but the show we got was worth more than the price.
The ambiance was incredible. There are so few theaters left with this kind of character. It also appeared there is a comedy club and bar in the basement. I walked down there to explore with my girlfriend and it had a great Cozy feeling.
Sometimes you do get more than you pay for and this was one of those times. I will be doing my best to patronize this establishment in the future, and recommend that everyone else does too!

Absolutely charming theatre. I saw «BINGO» there. The ushers were great, the décor absolutely perfect antique, and they show live theatre with real singers doing theatre productions accompanied by live musicians.
Below is a lounge. Only thing is: they only sell beer & wine with candy, no liquor, and they don’t let you bring it in with you to your seats.
They also have a lot of theatre programs for kids to check out if you live nearby.
A great, sweet time to pass a lovely evening.

This was my first time seeing anything at Theartre Three and I was dissappointed.
We Saw A Christmas Carol. The production was excellent, the whole cast was great but the actress who played the Ghost of Christmas Present (I think Renee Santos-​Stewart) was excellent.
We really had a great time here and will definately be back.

I was out of work and thought after 30 years of supporting this theatre they might consider a small discount for tickets so I could take my wife out to forget our problems for a time. They did not have the class to even respond to my email. I know they did not have to discount anything but it was humiliating enough to have to ask but to then be ignored was insulting.
The theatre downstairs is stuffy and uncomfortable and the staff seems snooty when I did go.

This was always my favourite theatre growing up, even though i saw maybe 1 show here. Definitely the best non-​profit, almost-​professional theatre on Long Island. Low ticket prices, great comedy shows, and excellent musicals. The One-​Act festival is a highlight. And, where better to go for a night out than Port Jefferson, where great restaurants abound. Theatre Three caps off an excellent evening, for sure.
As a side note, there is a prolific amount of original children’s theatre as well as well-​known shows like Blues Clues. Bring your little ones!

This is a very nice, intimate theatre. The prices to see their plays is very cheap, compared to Broadway of course. All the plays I’ve ever seen here have been terrific. They have a downstairs «cabaret» theatre where they host their annual festival of one act plays as well as Friday Night Face Off, improv comedy. The theater is also a host to comedians, the Long Island Comedy Festival comes here yearly. That’s always great to catch.