Mario’s Pizza

We order pizza from here almost once a week. Sometimes we get hot heros instead but every time it’s awesome. The people on the phone are always friendly and courteous. The drivers aren’t creepy like at some pizzerias. We even ordered on Halloween this year and were delighted by the drivers costume.
Every experience has been a positive one. Not to mention the food is always superb. I have lived in 6 states and even down in the city and this is definitely in my top 5 favorite pizzerias in the US. If you are driving through Port Ewen, it’s worth any wait time to grab a slice here. Though I’ve yet to experience an unreasonable wait time for my meals. Pick up or delivery. Fantastic all the way around!
Don’t go changin. :)

Wonderful food and service! We order pizza and dinners at least once a month and get it delivered. Every order is delivered hot and with a smile. There have been a few times that something has been forgotten and within 20 min they were back at my door with the correct thing (things happen). I would highly recommend Mario’s for the food and service!

Good prices and good pizza.
We order quite a bit of pizza from this restaurant. They have 14, 16, and 18 inch pies all at great prices. A 16 inch cheese goes for a little over $ 10.
The cheese they use on their pizza is very thick. I’m a fan of the thick cheese myself. The only other meal we’ve ordered was the meatball parm sub. It was a hit and miss. The first time it was good, but the second time it was a little dry. Cheese fries are just fries with sandwich slice cheese laying on top… Not a fan. I’d stick to no cheese on the fries. The pizza has been consistently good though.
When placing an order, expect to wait a while. They’re orders run slower than the normal pizza place for some reason. The average wait time I’ve gotten for one cheese pizza can be up around 30 minutes. Also, don’t be concerned if you’re going to be a little late to pick up. You’ll still wait an additional 10 – 15 minutes when you get there.
Plenty of indoor seating is available for those who would rather eat in. Credit cards are accepted with no minimum that I’m aware of.