Amadeo’s

Meh. The pizza was only okay.
The service was lackluster. Young kids behind the counter whose priority is not the customers.
On the upside, Great location& fairly clean.

Just an update to the owner’s response: I did NOT say you didn’t have a glass enclosure, but when I visited the pizza was exposed on the counter. I did NOT say I was an expert on pizza or that I spoke for all NYers. I did NOT say your sauce came from a can, but it was sweet LIKE it came from a can. Of course my review is only MY OPINION. We all have different tastes. YOU SHOULDN’T BE SO DEFENSIVE, I did give you a 3 star (A-​OK).

I don’t understand some of the petty reviews people have posted. They must be miserable people who has nothing better to do than try to ruin someone else’s day cause they life is so god awful. I love this place they food is high quality, always consistent and have A1 customer service. They are very polite and make you feel at home. Its hands down the best bakery and restaurant in the poconos. The food is cooked when you ordered so it always hot and delicious. They gyros, wings and pizza is some of the best I’ve eaten an (I’m originally from NY and have had plenty). This place is a jewel to the area and i’ll always will be a customer. Btw about The review of greasy pizza it’s crap they pizza is authentic NY style and if your pizza don’t have some grease on it it’s not real cheese maybe you should order the cheeseless pizza next time. Please don’t change a thing y’all food is great!!!

You have earned one extra star because the breakfast wrap was pretty good.
However, it would’ve been much better if it contained the homefries that I ordered in it (which were an extra dollar, by the way).
Also, you charge for to-​go sauce containers? Really? You could boost revenue so much more by providing friendly customer service instead of nickel-​and-​diming your customers.
Don’t think I’d come here again.

The only reason I came back here was because I had purchased a coupon from
(which they don’t honor, by the way). The chicken parmesan sandwich was decent, but the pizza was mega greasy and not thoroughly cooked, the cheese didn’t stick to it, it just slid off. My kids weren’t pleased.

Nice little pizza place. I don’t know what the other reviewers were expecting, but in several years, I have never been disappointed. People are nice, orders are ready when promised. Very good pizza. Very good sandwiches. And it is the only place in the Poconos that we buy good Italian bread if I’m making a spaghetti dinner.

The pizza is ok in a pinch. I typically order from the delivery place down the street (Primos), but decided to give Amadeos a try. Their pizza was undercooked and underwhelming. The deserts were dry and clearly had been in the case a while. The service wasn’t great or terrible. They do have decent seating and a large menu.

Awesome pizza… I am from NYC and wasn’t expecting much from a local pizza joint in poconos. I was very pleasantly surprised and had to get some more. Good thing I am staying few min away. It’s a simple place but food is excellent.

So I gave it another go. And it was good. So much better than last time.
Less cheese and cooked a little longer must have done the trick.
Happier and happy customers return.

Good hoagies here. They also make a cheesesteak on garlic bread that is a tasty twist on a regular cheesesteak. Very friendly young woman working the register. Loved the Italian supreme hoagie. Convenient location for the Lake Naomi area.