Sky’s Pizza Pie

The slices are BIG and really good! We got the Sunday special ((24″ plus 1 topping)) it was delicious, we will defiantly return on our next trip!

Huge New York style pizza slices. I came in starving, ate two slices, and was stuffed. I’m not a small guy either. The staff was also very friendly. Can’t wait to visit this place again next Sunday.

Visiting from Montgomery, ate here last night. Enjoyed a 24″ pie with the family. Not any pizza joints in Montgomery offering pie like theirs. Hands down one of best places to visit when in Pensacola.

Their pizza is delicious!
We are from out of town and tried the pizza last time and there were definitely no left overs. It also took me longer to find a current menu than it took to cook and pick it up, but no big deal.
We are now back in town and craving more pie but the updated menu seems to be more elusive than the first time I tried to look. I decided to write this review after I looked up and realized I had been searching for over 20 minutes. Yes there are old menus up, but I want to read those like I want to go pick up an old left over pizza. The website supposedly has one but I’ve never been able to have it load on my phone or computer.
It’s just frustrating and time wasting.

OMG this pizza. Their pizza is as close to real NYC pizza as you’re going to get in Pensacola. The slices are HUGE (I’m doing my best Trump voice) and the service is great. If you order their gigantic extra large pizza, you may have trouble fitting it in your car. No, really.

Hands down the best pizza in Pensacola. As you’ve already read in the other reviews, the pizzas are really big.
The staff is friendly and the restaurant itself is clean and approachable since they’ve moved to their new location.
This is normally my go-​to pizza place here in PCola. The Man City Pie is a winner. Lots of flavor.

Atmosphere is simple and plain, but who cares — the pizza is bomb.

Ok, you guys got me. Usually the local reviews are close to the truth, but you guys have no idea of what good pizza is and absolutely no clue what new york pizza is.
I ordered a pie with ground beef, bacon and black olives. It took for ever for it to be brought to my table, and it was warm, not hot. That tells me it sat there waiting 15 minutes before making its way to my table.
The crust is thin, yes, but so limp even folding it new york style cannot make it stiff. The crust has an off taste of chlorine bleach. The ground beef was just funky. There was so little bacon i could not taste it, so i dug through the cheese and finally found a morsel, tiny morsel.
No sauce to speak of. Which was strange, considering how soggy it was. The cheese it not chewy, it is rubber. Once you get past the off flavors, the pizza is tasteless.
They take your order at the counter before you sit down. You have to pay and tip up front. Smart move. If you had to pay after you tasted the food and suffered the service, you would never pay or tip.
$ 25 for a pizza that could not be eaten, i confess my stupidity.

The best in town. I usually get the 24″ pepperoni which seems comically massive when you first see it, but because it is a thinner NY style it’s not quite as much as you would think. What is impressive is that there is very little grease left in the box from a 24″ pizza, which should be amazing to anyone who has ever ordered a large from a corporate chain.

Sky’s Pizza gets a five not simply because it’s good pizza but because it seems to be the only pizza place around that A. Sells by the slice and B. Makes pizza the way a pizza should taste. As a New York area pizza connoisseur, I naturally get a little snobby with what is good pizza and what is just a copy of one of the big chains and let me tell you Sky is good. Also, you can get 24″ pizza pies! If it were located up north it would be a four star joint. Oh yeah, there is local beer on tap.

Great pizza but the calzones leave much to be desired. I literally had to peel of burnt pieces and there was little flavor. However, again, pizzas are great which is why I am giving four stars

Pizza is delicious! Sometimes when you get whatever the special is that day, the cashier rings you up separately at full price for each thing. Totally doesn’t get it. Fix that. Other than that, no complaints.

I admit to being a bit of a pizza snob, having grown up in an area with some of the best NY style pizza. I have to say the service was fine and the place seemed clean, etc… However, I have to agree with a number of other reviews here and say that the pizza is really quite bland. It is also VERY thin. So much so that it really isn’t very filling at all. I can see how they can sell such huge pies (in circumference only — not the actual amount of food). I would probably skip this place, although I haven’t found much in terms of real pizza parlor type pizza in Pensacola. Again — nothing really wrong with Sky’s — just very bland and not very much of it. Sounds like the line from the end of Annie Hall — «the food is terrible… and such small portions.»

Had high hopes for this place based on reviews. Had the calzone. It was well below average. Others had the pizza which looked good. Others did not complain but they did not rave about it either.
Staff was friendly.

Our family loves pizza and every road trip we will about out pizza hotspots and if it’s a late night trip, we will order it to go and take it to our hotel. Sometimes just chilling at the hotel with our pizza is the way to go. Knowing we were around this area we Unilocaled n TripAdvisored every pizza spot for the best ratings n this popped up! So excited esp bc they sell the large sized pizza that would feed our fam! Couldn’t wait. We found it, took pics outside, there was a cute structure in front of their establishment, ordered ahead of time n voila picked the Sky’s and Moon 24″ up along with their garlic cheese knots which we heard was the bomb so gotta try those! Kids squeaked when they saw the huge box n lol it looked pretty good. Took it back and wow we were satisfied! Was it the best pizza ever, no. Was it pretty good? Yup. It’s thin enough for my taste. Greasier side but huge enough for a fam of 7 to still have leftovers. And wow loved the garlic knots too! Not bad Sky’s, not bad at all! Craving a huge slice right now ;)

Excellent food and great service! The slices are HUGE! Calzones have an awesome garlic butter on the outside with lots of toppings and cheese stuffed inside. YUM!

Being a NY nothing compares to ny pizza, but this is darn close.

3^rd time visiting the new location, still the same great taste. I have noticed that it seems more people are ordering at the counter for take away. I always call my orders in advance, and never have to wait.
If you are new to the area and looking for a good pizza place. This is the one!

The cashier was great the pizza was good but it was the house specialty supposed to be layered with salami and pepperoni it was not layered it was topped with alternating slices of each.

The search is finally over! Being from the north, I searched and tried many pizza places trying to find that taste from home. I found a few places that were close, but not quite right. Best pizza around, hands down, and it only took 7 years! Will be returning as much as possible, considering I sadly live 1 hour away. Keep up the amazing work, and the customer service is great!

Best pie in P’cola… if you prefer NY style. Prices are great and the pizza has never disappointed. New location is a HUGE upgrade of the previous one. Plenty of room to sit, and talk without feeling cramped.

Best NY pizza I have had in year. they have 24″ pizza I was soooo good. nice small very friendly place. sign on building is small a hard to locate but we’ll worth the search.

Love this ny style pizzeria. I ordered the 12 in, half cheese and half ground beef. The pizza was nice and hot. Cheesy and thin crust. Leftovers tasted good too

I love the pizza here! HUGE NY STYLE! Very close to NY style, almost authentic. As good as it gets outside of NYC!
Good job Sky!

If you’re looking for a truly delicious, New York style type pie here in town, Sky’s is the jam!
The pizza comes out hot and delicious every time, with the perfect crispy thin crust and toppings always on point. The slices are as long as your forearm, where you have to fold the pizza in half just to scarf it down.
The staff is always friendly. There’s a good little selection of decent craft beers, and the lunch specials per slice really can’t be topped. There’s nothing overally fancy about this joint. It’s just good pizza, done the right way.

I love me some sky’s pizza. The thin big slices are so damn delicious. My mouth waters thinking about this place. Whenever I go to Pensacola I stop here to grab a pie with my family. Please, Please open a Sky’s Pizza place here in Fort Walton Beach Florida !!!

Best pizza in Pensacola! Huge, NY style slices and good prices.