It’s not dirty, it’s not overpriced but it’s The most sub average pizza there is. The pizza is not spectacular, the place is run by a couple of kids who are constantly texting on their iPhones, and there were very few slices to choose from that were ready to serve by the slice. I have a hard time giving ANY place that sells pizza(my favorite food) less than 4 stars but this place just doesn’t tickle me. This is my fourth time eating here and definitely my last. Zero effort to please the people.
Timothy T.
Tu valoración: 5 Putnam Valley, NY
My colleagues and I order from here regularly. It’s always good and they have never messed up my order. I think there Greek salad with grilled chicken is the absolute best deal in town and is delicious for 8 $. I highly recommend
Andrew R.
Tu valoración: 2 Lakewood, WA
I was in town two weeks ago and stumbled upon this eatery as my options were limited. The pizza was not bad. My only grip about this place was the fact that there were four guys working on the date that i visited. Only one guy was motivated to help us. The other three guys did not seem to be working as hard. The individual working the cash register begrudgingly answered my questions as he did not want to be bothered as he was too busy watching television. The pizza was good though.
Rob R.
Tu valoración: 4 Poughkeepsie, NY
Anthony’s is a solid pizzeria it’s not my favorite but when in the area and hungry I come here. One thing I noticed is there slices seem to sit out for a while so they tend to leave them in the oven too long and they get kind of dried out. I can’t speak for the dinners here but you could do worse for pizza.
Renee R.
Tu valoración: 5 Yonkers, NY
I was working in Peekskill last week and had delivery from this place. My order was so small that I didn’t think they would even deliver it but they did! Once the food arrived … YUM! The pizza was sooo delicious and each slice was bigger than expected! I also had a small order of chicken wings and they were very good.
Hop S.
Tu valoración: 4 Croton-on-Hudson, NY
Sooo delicious! I’m completely hooked on the white pizza and the other vegetarian slices. I haven’t experienced the quickest or friendliest service or it’d be 5 stars. Will save the 5 stars for my favorite pizza spot, Ossining Pizzeria.
Drew W.
Tu valoración: 1 Cornwall, NY
I got an Italian sub from here today because my options were very limited. The last time I had done this it was a bad experience and I said I would never again, but figured hey might as well give them another shot, maybe I caught them on an off day. Today’s sandwich was just as bad if not worse. I was tempted to return it, but I was starving so I ate half and through the rest away. Never again. I’ll eat McDonald’s before I give them another dime for food. Oh, and I ordered oil and vinegar and it came smothered in mayo. Seriously?! They should not be able to call themselves an Italian pizzeria. Zero stars.
Margaret O.
Tu valoración: 4 Briarcliff Manor, NY
Great pizza Great deal pizza, wings and 2 liter soda for $ 20.The crew at work really digs this place.
Fell G.
Tu valoración: 4 Dumont, NJ
This review is based on pizza only– I have not tried any pasta dishes… yet. Great regular pizza– crisp bottom crust, perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio and decent sized slices. I prefer their regular pie to the Sicilian. I’ve also tried a meatball parm wedge here, which was good but it needed a little more sauce. The best deal here, in my opinion, is the 12″ personal pie. I think it was called Deluxe Personal? Whatever it was called, you get up to 5 toppings for $ 8.50. I chose meatball, broccoli, spinach, onion and black olive– it was delicious! There is nothing like a good pizza made to your specifications. Pleasant servers, clean, low-key place without all the shouting and noise of other pizzerias in the area.
Natalia M.
Tu valoración: 1 Croton-on-Hudson, NY
The worst pizza and gyros in NYC I order from there twice and the food is garbage they take the left overs and serve it to people. They super rude nasty and dirty pizza place in ny. Really unprofessional.
C L.
Tu valoración: 4 Peekskill, NY
Pretty decent… Ordered from them a couple times, never had an issue. Would like to see a little thinner crust, but pizza tastes good!
Jean w.
Tu valoración: 2 Peekskill, NY
pizza is hit and miss. lousy and arrogant attitude by workers have caused us to buy our weekly pizza elsewhere. prices are no bargain either
Julianna B.
Tu valoración: 3 Peekskill, NY
This has been my favorite pizzeria for years but the people that work there are very rude. I went in the other day and asked for three slices and they only gave me two and I didn’t realize until I got home. So I had to go back down there to get another slice and while I was waiting the person who took my order the first time was talking shit about me in Spanish to the other workers. They clearly must not have know that I speak Spanish and understood what they were saying. I never even got an apology for them for messing up my order and making me go all the way back down there.
Marion J.
Tu valoración: 4 Cortlandt Manor, NY
Nice thinner crust and better than a lot of the other pizza in the area. Unfortunately you aren’t going to get pizza like Arthur Avenue in this neck of the woods but Anthony’s is pretty darn good.