Kilwins Patchogue Village

My girlfriend was pumped for this location to be opening in our big, little, revitalized town as she fell in love with them somewhere in the Carolinas, we stopped in when we were in Asheville recently as well and it seems it’s always friendly, but I cannot in good, penny-​pinching conscience give Kilwins any more stars than 3 – 3.5. the ice cream was great, creamy, wonderful… all that sweet stuff; but $ 35/​lb for crappy chocolate covered strawberries is a joke, they aren’t even that expensive at my girlfriends restaurant and those are huge long-​stem strawberries that melt in your mouth with the most delicious chocolate and pretty designs… so Kilwins needs to step their game up if they are charging that much for hard crumbly chocolate and mealy strawberries.
The fudge is good but super sweet and again, expensive as ever.
I would like to mention though that the staff was nice, friendly and willing to help however they could which is always nice to see and sometimes a bit rare to find on this island.
If only they’d bring the Savannah candy company up here… really just their praline, nothing in the world like it, Kilwins would be better if they outsourced their pralines from Savannah haha.
I’m not incredibly gaga for sweets to begin with though so take this review with a grain of salt… or a scoop of Kilwins homemade ice cream! (it is very good)

The staff is so friendly and helpful. The confections are very good and so is the ice cream. It’s a great place to stop in for a tiny desert after a good meal on Main Street.

Delicious! Went in for some fudge, went home with 3 slices of fudge, Kilwins own Destiny Roll, a smores popsicle, hand made peanut butter cup (mind blowingly good!) and the biggest, most delicious chocolate covered strawberries I have ever seen. Special Valentine’s/Birthday treats for my wife … & ok me too!

Fresh ice cream, fudge and desserts… What more could you ask for? I’ve been waiting for a premium ice cream shop in Patchogue for a while. Most people will complain about prices however milk, butter and electricity are at an all time high…
That’s what drives the prices naturally they reflect that. However Carvel is equally priced and half the quality!
I love the attentive young help that educates customers on what the store offers. They also I believe go the extra mile offering up free samples and devoting more time then the standard do you know what you want?
I love this place and will continue to support.

Great place, friendly service, and delicious chocolate and caramel apples! Welcome to the neighborhood!

Went to Kilwins the other night. The owner is great and so into it. But of course personality isn’t the reason you are there!!! The chocolate and treats surpass all you would expect. Try the fudge (incredible) the caramel apples (incredible) the assorted chocolates are great too. I like the whole look. The staff are friendly and make you feel like you are In a quaint chocolate shop. We enjoyed everything we bought. Of course it’s more expensive than chocolate you would buy in CVS but to me chocolate is like wine. You can get a box o wine or a Loire Valley Chardonnay. So if your going for the calories enjoy it. GOOD JOB Kilwins.

Found out that Kilwin’s opened up near me on the Island. Was excited to go and relive my Kilwin’s experience in Naples Florida (best ice cream and service). I was disappointed in the portion the Patchogue location served. The same serving in Naples was at least double. The staff was friendly but could use some more training. I’d expect more from a high end store, it felt like I was in Friendly’s.

I would like to give them at least three stars, but the truth is I will likely not be back to Kilwins. Seeing other reviews I was so exited to try the place I ran down to fix an ice cream urge that had come over me.
For me it breaks down like this. The place is OK, just OK, Not really A-​OK, I would return to an A-​OK place.
I don’t have an issue with the service received or the food in terms of quality, both were fine. As a matter of fact late on a Sunday night when it looked like they were already in the process of cleaning up for the night, the «Hello» was offered without and begrudging and truly sounded sincere. I ordered a two two-​scoop sundaes one with strawberry chunk ice cream and the other with Mint chocolate chip. The strawberry had chocolate sauce over top, while the mint had caramel and rainbow sprinkles. Looking in the candy counter I found a few delectable treats to add onto he order a milk chocolate peanut butter cup and chocolate covered graham crackers.
Graham crackers were business card sized but covered with plenty of chocolate and maintained their crunch. at $ 2 a pop, these were a little pricey but an indulgence I wouldn’t hesitate to take. The Peanut butter cup was about double the size of the ones you get in the orange package. I expected a «fresh from the factory» taste, but not so much on these. They tasted like a mass produced large peanut butter cup. Nothing wrong with that at all, except if they are $ 5 each. When I saw the price I was a little taken aback, but I rationalized for the size and assumed freshness they were worth a try. Given the forgoing they are not worth a retry. I’ll take a four pack of the king Size cups in the orange package instead and pocket at least a buck. Looking at the rest of the chocolate it seemed all prices were higher than other chocolatiers on the island. I verified this after stopping into another of my haunts a few days later.
The Ice creams were OK as well, just nothing to write home about. My Sundae losses some point because the chocolate sauce was so poor. The sauce on top of the ice cream looked like it had separated leaving chocolate «water» on top and the thicker sauce had run down to the bottom of the cup. All this for the low price of a little more than $ 3 per scoop of ice cream.
My total bill $ 25. I just don’t see me making this trip again to get what was, besides the Graham crackers, just an OK treat.

Came in here for the first time last week and everything was great! They have amazing icecream flavors! The worker was great. Second time I came in I had the same worker and I was very disappointed. Had a very bad attitude and was super rude. I got my icecream and left right after. Wonderful place, terrible workers.

What a great location on Main St in Patchogue!
I’m a fan of this ice cream chain, they use fresh ingredients most particularly Michigan cherries (my favorite)
I walked into a nice looking store and was greeted by cheery counter folks (calling them soda jerks is just wrong in this day and age)
I’m asked, would you like a sample? Yes please, of everything!
The Kilwins cherry ice cream is soo good, they use big Bing cherries and it’s now a love fest on Main St. Fresh ice cream choices, fudge, chocolates and candy apples, all for me. I’m like a kid in a candy store looking around, I decided on bringing a box of sea salt chocolates home as well.
I’m sure this place is going to be a mad house during the summer time on busy Main st.
Valentine’s Day is coming, consider Kilwins for a box of chocolate love
Kilwins, welcome to Patchogue!

Kilwins you dirty little shop you. Oh for the love of Fudge!
Be still my heart they have Salted Caramel Fudge ooooh yes. I have an affinity slash obsession with anything Salted Caramel. Like the Froyo I get from Yogurtini in Smithtown. It’s Salted Caramel Pretzel then usually I add chopped Heath Bars and a little Salted Caramel drizzle. Yep. I love Salted Caramel. I can’t deny it. Ok anyway enough about that I gotta get back and focused and write an epic review of Kilwins.
So this Kilwins is kinda cuter than the one in H-​ton Village. It’s brighter it’s cheerier. Maybe I was just hankering for something sweet and my eyes lit up when I saw the Kilwins sign across the street from Del Fiore while I was eating my slice of Brooklyn pizza with extra crushed red pepper today. Hangover?! What hangover? Oh yeah… that left late yesterday.
The only thing I had on my mind was a piece of fudge although those apples, the s’mores on a stick and this toffee almond crunch thing got me feeling some type of way. So fudge and toffee almond crunch. Out the door and I break a piece of the toffee almond crunch. Yep. I’m in my happy place now.
I will say this… No disrespect Kilwins but you will NEVER ever take the place of my Sayville Chocolatier. Oh no no no. But will you woo me when I’m down in Patchogue and don’t feel like going to Sayville? You bet your bottom dollar that I’ll be back.