Anthony’s Pizza Cafe

There is so much positive I can say about Anthony’s. Not just excellent food but the service and the patrons are always very friendly. I do enjoy going there as often as possible. I highly recommend you visiting this particular restaurant either at the bar, outside or inside dining. The atmosphere is exactly what you need. Not Just excellent pizza… you must try their homemade soups and more! Thanks Anthony’s in Thornton Park!

Ever since I moved down to Florida this has been my go to spot for Italian food. The food is always awesome and the service is on point. I suggest trying some of their excellent soups.

Been going to Anthony’s for years and every time has been wonderful! Service is friendly and always timely. Food is consistently delicious. All around a warm, neighborhood spot!

I really love this place! Food is both good and reasonably priced. Kitchen is a little slow but great service. Pizza is AMAZING!

Great spot for lunch. The Italian is great but we come for the pizza. They have cheap lunch specials. Located in Thornton Park and has great outside seating.

Love the pizza here! Second time having it and it’s so good! Great service, and great ambience in the city!

Amazing pizza and service. Bianca pizza comes with HUGE ricotta dollops. So delicious. Best in Orlando!

I love Anthony’s ! We come here at least once a week for pizza or calzones. The pesto pizza is my absolute favorite ! I love that they have an outdoor patio to enjoy the weather while it’s still nice. The service is always excellent and so is the food.

The food is amazing!
I’ve ordered one slice of margarita pizza, a meatball pasta and a caesar salad. I highly recommend the margarita pizza. It was simple but delicious! If I visit Orlando again, I will definitely visit Anthony’s Pizza again.

Tried them for the first time. worst pizza i ever had. I got fooled by all the good reviews or may be i got a bad one prepared by someone who is angry with the boss or being underpaid haha. Not trying again paying high dollar for this piece of pizza.
To the owners here are my issues if you can fix.
— pizza felt very very dry and a bit burnt underneath (well done i guess).
— loaded with toppings. Big no no for me. I really mean it. the toppings could be used for 2 same size pizzas may b. No one needs those many (volume) lumps of toppings in one pizza if they really want they will order a SALAD with them in it and not a pizza. This made me feel like someone who was angry just threw a bowl of toppings and did not care to spread them up
— SUN-​DRIED TOMATOES: these are my usual fav ingredients most of the time but not here. they felt like dehydrated pieces of hard veggies. Like Hard to chew beef jerky.
Now I am not sure if I got the worst piece of pizza of the lot made by a new trainee or it is the usual here so i gave 2 stars. Thanks to the delivery which was pretty quick for a friday evening.

I lived in Italy for a year, and Anthony’s pizza is pretty dang close to the real deal! I’ve had a few of their pizzas — the pesto and meat pizzas are my two favorites! The crust is just right — not too thick, not too thin! The medium is a good size to split between two people. We normally order a salad to go with it just to add some greenery.
You can also just get a slice of pizza which is nice for those late night cravings.
I love being able to sit out on the patio and enjoy the weather and people watching. They can easily accommodate groups — we’ve had our church group meet here on several occasions. They were able to sit and serve us all quickly!
Their happy hour is pretty good — go for the sangria! It’s delicious.
I will be back for sure :)

Tatiana just made my night, after hangrily leaving my last dinning experience, she wanted to make my night. So happy I came here to get some pizza after a disappointing night. Thank you for the service and food, will definitely be back soon!

I really want to like Anthony’s more than I do.
Food here is pretty good. I’ve ordered pizza, baked ziti, salad, and breadsticks here. Nothing spectacular, but it tasty enough to want more, and for a reasonable enough price.
The first problem here is parking, which is always near impossible since their lot holds about 6 cars, so I usually end up having to park down some side street and walk. The other problem, which they actually have some sway over, is inattentiveness. While the service is always very friendly, my order is almost always wrong, and I’m not asking for anything weird or special. They’ll bring me one slice instead of two. They’ll bring me the wrong drink. They’ll bring me the wrong toppings…
It’s never anything major, but it gets pretty annoying that I have to have something corrected every time.

Great consistent pizza every time. My friends and I have eaten at Anthony’s more than 10 times and we’ve never had a complaint which as you know is rare in today’s dining scene.
When you go, sit in the bar area, order a large pizza and some wings. Mmm!

This place is fine for post-​work pizza in a pinch. Can you get better pizza elsewhere in Orlando? Yes, you can. (Armando’s in Winter Park; Antonio’s downstairs in Maitland, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza at multiple locations). However, when I am in the downtown area, and feel like a quick pizza after happy hour, I can go here and leave satisfied. Their Bianca pizza is a deliciously salty mix of mainly mozzarella and ricotta cheese, and really not super healthy for you. For example, their margherita pizza has canned diced tomatoes on it and is pretty garlicky. Pepperoni pizza is unremarkable but not bad. The small green salad is meh, featuring a sad slice of semi-​frozen tomato, green peppers, and some white onions. I get their house vinaigrette and just pile on grated parm and s&p to make it palatable. You can order most of the pizzas by the slice.
The property has a kind of L-​shape. The bar is kinda gross and has a depressing energy, with a few high-​top rounds off to one side, and bar seating on the other. Real basic beer selection. The covered outdoor seating area is nice, and lots of people bring their dogs or children, both of which rarely behave. I don’t know what it is about this place, but almost every time, there have been kids screaming and running around in the patio area, while their parents ignore them, or people who let their dogs bark aggressively at other patron’s dogs. Staff is hit or miss. Some of the servers are really on top of their game and do a good job dealing with large groups or drunk a-​holes. Other times, we have wondered if our server had just popped some roxies, and it has taken a long time to get food before.
That being said, I keep coming back because it’s reasonably priced, and it gets the job done in a centrally located area and has nice outdoor seating, when people are being respectful to other patrons.

Hats off to this Anthony’s location. I came here one evening with a group of about 20 people. We had two waitresses working the group. These gals were amazing. They were able to get the food out to us. Kept the water and drinks coming. Even with a computer system hiccup they got the job done that evening.
One of the kudos that I’d like to give them is,…my wife and I ordered an antipasto salad. They must have overheard us saying that we would share it. So they had the kitchen split it. We never asked them to. That is what you call exceeding your customers expectations. Had a great night with the Knights of Columbus that evening. Overheard several of the people in the group saying that they enjoyed it, and were planning on returning.
I’ll say it again, good customer service is where it is at! There are so many places to go eat, but the way you treat your customers, will set you apart.
Good job Anthony’s.

Great pizza, great spaghetti with meatballs, great antipasto salad, great outdoor seating. Yup. This place is pretty great!

The pizza is very very good but one step below great. That’s because the owners are Yankees fans and I’m tired of them winning. :)

Always tasty, never disappointed. Friendly staff.
Especially moved the last time I was here when I saw a staff member helping a severely disabled woman who was here siding alone. He made sure she was neat and tidy when she was done, helped her with her payment and put her change in her bag and secured it, gave her a drink to go as she left in her electric wheelchair.
Then she came back right away, needing some additional assistance and he was happy to oblige. It was nice to see such compassion. I figure she’s a regular here.

I love pizza of all varieties and go here when I want a big slice. Their pizza is nothing crazy so don’t expect a fried egg or jelly on your pie. Traditional flavors all the way at Anthony’s.
This is my go to when I want a good ol’ slice of peperoni. Either dining on the patio or getting it to go, I enjoy it all the same with a side or ranch and a cold cola. You can buy it by the slice or go all in for a Large pizza to have some perfect leftovers.
Service can be so so and the wait times can get hairy on a busy night, but I am patient when I know that I will consistently get a good pizza and a decent price.