Pappaceno’s Pizza

Best pizza in orchard park, fast and friendly workers and they delivery as well. Always quick and friendly!

OK, I can PROVE this place is owned by the mafia.
But first let me tell you the slices here are excellent. I was here on a Pizza tour in late 2014 and then again about 3 months ago… fantastic slices. Delicious. Some of the best pizza in the Southtowns. Good service too.
But I need to tell you how I can prove it’s owned by the mafia. Here goes.
Bear with me.
Remember that Rolling Stones song? You play it backwards and you hear some devil worshipping crap? Or was it another band, I forget. Stairway To Heaven? Whatever.
THIS IS WORSE.
I can PROVE the devil wears not Prada, but Pappaceno’s Pizza. In his tummy. As in the mafia runs this place.
As yourself my friends. What is PAPPACENO BACKWARDS?
ONE CAP… PAP.
Obviously, blatantly, this is a description of the preferred means of shooting-​style execution employed by the «Family Men» mafioso head honchos here. They only need one bullet… BANG.
One cap. PAP.
Scary.
All that aside, this is one of the BEST PIZZA SLICES IN THE REGION. It’s absolutely awesome. I love Imperial and Mattina’s, but this one is up there with the best of them. I think it must be all of that secret Mafia seasoning.
What to get: Slices.
It was part of a Pizza tour of the Southtowns, so I was already getting full by the time I got here, and was already sick from one of the other slices (I’m looking at you, Ricota’s.) But thankfully, this pizza was so delicious, that it made me hungry again. It definitely gets full marks with an emphasis on «full». It’s juicy, doughy, luscious, and sexual. OK maybe it’s not sexual, but you know pizza can be romantic. I mean, there’s even a song about it… take another little pizza my heart now baby… and of course Britney Spears once propositioned her fans… «you wanna Pizza me?»
If you’re a fan of Buffalo style pizza, which in my opinion is some of the best pizza in the world, then you need to get your rectum down to Pappaceno’s post haste, and give this slice a try. Also Franco’s on Eggert in Amherst, and Pizza Heist too. But don’t try and heist the Pizza from Pappaceno’s. It would be suicide.
Because if you do.
They will shoot you.
And they only need one bullet.
ONE CAP… PAP.
.

Was back in town and shopping in OP with my wife. Stopped for a quick lunch and had a great chicken finger sub!

can’t stand this place.
somehow its like a local hidden gem and regulars adore this place but I have no idea why. the place is a dump. when you walk in the door you see how dark and dingy the place looks with its sticky and stained tile floor and tacky wall paper and cheap pictures hung on the wall. flies buzz all around the light fixtures and float all around the back where you see your food is being made. walk over to the counter and youll find no one is there to greet you. you will have to call back and bother one of the employees who look like they just absolutely hate their life or just sit silently for a while and hope they notice you. if you pay with a credit or debit card they will watch you as you write in a tip or not on the slip and will roll their eyes if you don’t tip them. the two times Ive been here I didn’t give them a tip cause why would I? I came in to order and pick it up, you didn’t do anything but give me an attitude on the phone. anyway they roll their eyes and kind of groan under their breath if you don’t tip them and just kind of send you on your way after handing you their mediocre pizza. no greetings, no pleasant departure, and terrible phone etiquette.
if you do order pizza from here make sure its a fresh made, DO NOT ORDER A SINGLE SLICE. they make a large pizza in the morning, cut it up and just leave the slices out on a rack. its not put away on a heating tray or anything, it literally just sits out all day and they warm it up as people come in to order. this place gets more flies than customers on a daily basis and I shutter to think whats been crawling on my single slice by the time I order it at lunch time.
theres no uniform, no etiquette, no pleasantries, no pride or any real order to this place. with quality pizza shops like capellis and ricottas literally a mile up the road I don’t know why anyone would go to this place. better yet, ricottas will deliver FOR FREE if you live within like five miles.
I love to support local businesses but this place is simply not worth the support

Flight cancelled.
My first thought after *$%!*# was… now we can get more buffalo wings!!!
And we did. Along with some slices of pizza. Got them to-​go and took them back to our friends’ home for some Superbowl watching.
The wings here were amazing! Better even than Just Pizza. The pizza was just meh… way too thick of a crust, it was more like a meal, with the world’s weirdest tiny thick pepperoni’s. Ate it anyway, I mean it was still tasty. Just not AS tasty.
The wings though… everyone loved ‘em. We got the blend of drumsticks and wings, spicy. And it was spicy! Spicier than Just Pizza. Great bleu cheese for dipping. YUM. My husband loved finishing them off the next day, cold from the fridge.
Great way to end our visit to Buffalo. On the way to the airport the next day to try heading home yet again… I wondered how well wings would travel.