Miss Moffett’s Mystical Cupcakes

They have great customer service! After calling ahead with a Gluten free cupcake order for a coworkers bday party, when I got there, there was a mix up. The lady behind the counter was very apologetic and called the manager, then proceeded to give me a really big gift certificate for my troubles!!! Amazing customer care that you just don’t see enough of anymore! So then I bought the only few gluten free cupcakes which were also vegan.
They might not have been GF cupcakes that made my shorts drop, but realistically how many people can make my shorts drop with gluten free?! Delicious gluten free vegan cupcakes, well let’s just say that’s like trying to make all the people in the world happy at the same time. It’s a daring feat to attempt and Miss Moffett’s GF vegan CCs are a good attempt and the frosting was actually really good. I’ll make sure I go back and try the real cupcakes!

Ordered cupcakes for my son’s birthday, pretty simple ones my only request was white frosting with silver sprinkles and they gave me chocolate frosting with PINK HEARTS! For a boys birthday! The gal at the Capital Mall location even helped me place the order — she tried to fix it, this was not her fault, the only thing she could do was try to find cupcakes without pink on the frosting. I called the managers number that was given to me, I called a few times, not one return call! Yep I made the mistake of prepaying for these cupcakes almost $ 70! Just a horrible horrible experience, I will never go back to this place and if you have a special occasion, please think twice before using them

These cupcakes are the worst I’ve ever had. Dry and flavorless. Never wasting my money here again.

Eww no! Made a mistake of ordering a cake along with cupcakes for a birthday party from
Miss Moffett’s Mystical Cupcakes. There is a reason they didn’t win cupcake wars, which they actually even brag about lol. Worst ever! Almost nothing more unappetizing then biting into loose flour. They didn’t even bother to properly mix the batter before baking. Yuck! Also their kiosk/​store in Olympia mall does not serve fresh cupcakes, they tend to be hard and taste like they were sitting out in the open for days.

Delicious! This is the only location I have been to so far, but holy cow… their cupcakes are very tasty and not expensive at all.
The first time I stopped in I went ahead and grabbed a reward card as I figured I would be back. I’m glad I did! I have already received a free cupcake and 2 $ off. I highly recommend jumping on that whenever you come in.
Back to the cupcakes… so every day they have at least 3 or 4 different cupcakes with some of their regulars and a little case of gluten free cupcakes (that look soooo tasty as well). I recommend following them on Facebook so you can see what cupcakes they have!
So far my all time favorite has been the Mocha cupcake. All of their cupcakes have delicious frosting and the cake is always super tasty whatever flavor it may be.
Every time I have visited it has been the same women working the counter and she’s very nice. I want to visit the downtown location but this location is super convenient and the customer service is always great. I do look forward soon to checking out their other locations though!

These cupcakes are THE best! The cake is always soft and Moist! And oh my, their frostings are everything! I’ve tried the majority of the flavors they have and not one has disappointed. The staff is always friendly too!

The chocolate salted carmel cupcake was the best. My son loved the lemon lavender cupcake.

Best cupcakes I’ve ever had, I’m not even a cupcake person, and I would get these again and again, oh and did I mention the one’s I ate were GLUTEN FREE! They were seriously better than any regular cupcake, the frosting was heavenly. You will not regret trying these!

Amazing croissants! I just discovered they are offering croissants at this bakery too. They have chocolate ones and breakfast ones too. I ordered the ham and cheese one. It turns out they make them from scratch using real butter! Super flaky and soft, this is easily the best croissant I’ve had in the Olympia area.
Oh yeah, their cupcakes are amazing too. Frosting is super light and fluffy and not too sugary. The cupcake itself is super fluffy and moist.

Not the best, not the worst. I hate when they look better than they taste. I had the lemon cupcake. The color is a little too bright, they are very sweet and have a high frosting to cake ratio. The cake was moist and the filling was good. Definitely spendy as it was a specialty flavor. The mall location is cute, but the shelves could use more merchandise. It seems a little empty. Staff was polite.

The best gluten Free cupcakes I’ve ever had! People often complain about the price but honestly I’d pay an extra dollar to have good quality ingredients over a lard covered cupcake any day, these cupcakes are of such great quality, I used to live in Seattle and Trophy and Cupcake Royale have nothing on these guys. The cupcakes were DELICIOUS and the woman behind the counter was just as amazing, sweet and genuine just like the food they serve. Worth the drive!

To be honest, I was quite disappointed in these cupcakes due to the fact that I watched their episode of cupcake wars and saw that they won. This was the initial reason as to why my mom and I wanted to try their cupcakes and I’m all about cupcake wars and finding shops that were on the show
I got 4 cupcakes — specialty ones I believe, and the total came out to 12 bucks. Didn’t bother me considering the cupcake industry is kinda expensive as is, so automatically it’s a take or leave. I got a chocolate salted caramel, a Nutella, a banana nut and one they call twix. I will say this, their frostings are really good. The one on the banana nut was absolutely to die for! Light, airy, not overly sweet and lovely. The cakes however, weren’t impressing at all. My son ate the banana one so I didn’t get to try much of it but the frosting but you could see that it was kind of dry in the middle. I ate the Nutella thinking it was going to be a Nutella overload bc I literally eat Nutella from the container, and it tasted nothing like Nutella. I was like a plain chocolate cake with one really small bite of hazelnut and chocolate ganache frosting. The twix tasted nothing like twix the candy bar either. The chocolate salted caramel was good. Nothing spectacular.
I’d pass on the cupcakes next time. They might as well sell their frosting seperately bc id buy that to eat plain!

My kids and I went to the mall to pick up some items and stumbled pass this shop. We saw that they had gluten free cupcakes so we were in! :) My son and I both had a pumpkin spice GF and my daughter got a cookie dough regular cupcake. We were all in heaven! GF leaves a lot to be desired and trust me, we’ve been all around Olympia checking out GF cupcakes. This was hands down our favorite and we were super happy we weren’t just stuck with a chocolate or vanilla option. Thanks for a sweet treat! We will be sure to visit again!

Boyfriend surprised me with a pumpkin spice cupcake. The frosting was soo creamy and the cupcake itself was really fluffy and moist. Altho I would have liked a little more cupcake, it sorta of seemed like there was a little too much frosting, but at least it was good frosting.

I bought a few cupcakes today for my children and although I wasn’t impressed with their cupcakes when I tried them once before, I settled for convenience and thought to give them a second chance. Their red velvet cupcake was just OK— actually prefer the box kind over the taste of this one and even my kids passed on the frosting and said the actual cupcake didn’t have any taste at all. I feel bad about throwing my $ 12 down the drain but gotta appreciate a kid’s brutal honesty. The only one left to eat is blueberry cheesecake. Hope that tastes better than the chocolate and red velvet.

I had a birthday cupcake and was really disappointed, I don’t know if it was an off day or what but the cake part of the cupcake was borderline terrible. I tossed half of my $ 4 cupcake. I’ll probably try them one more time when I’m in the area but for a business that boasts being on Food Network, this was a miss :/
Update: I appreciate the offer to come back and try the cupcakes again. The staff and owner seem friendly. Unfortunately for me the cupcakes are just kind of crumbly and tasteless. I had a traditional vanilla and a salted caramel. The salted caramel was better, I like the filling and the icing had more flavor but still just okay. I think the cake recipe needs a re-​work.

Mystical Cupcakes has terrific gluten free choices. The cupcakes are moist and taste like regular cupcakes! Even my non GF friends like the GF versions. I like that the shop rotates the flavors and has several to choose from each day. Some of my favorites are triple chocolate, German chocolate, red velvet and carrot cake, of course. Their Seahawks inspired cupcakes during the playoffs last year were great fun for my viewing parties.
Rachel, Victoria and the crew are always friendly and helpful. It’s nice to see them expanding. I’ve been a customer since they were online only. And I usually shop at the downtown location, across from the Olympia Farmers Market.

Stopped in today to check out the new location and enjoy our favorite cupcakes, and it was as wonderful as we have come to expect from Mystical Cupcakes!!!
We look forward to them getting settled into the new location and hopefully getting some playdates setup there during the rainy season. Cupcakes and the play area in the mall is a perfect combo and I’m so happy to see this local business as the malls newest addition! Thank you for being our favorite spot for wonderful sweets!!!