Neighbors Pizza

This place is awesome! Great local shop with a good variety, and they deliver! They have the standard pizzas, plus you can customize your own, and they have some damn interesting specialty ones as well. Love the crust, the ingredients are always good, the prices are decent, and they have some good combo deals. Plus, you can get various appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and pastas. Delivery time can vary, and sometimes takes about 45 minutes, but the pizza is always hot and still good when we get it.

We like Neighbors pizza. With the choices around here it’s nice to have better pizza than the chain restaurants and the price is good too. Their sandwiches are also very good. The only gripe I might have would be the ranch is not very good (to us) probably out of a bottle? It’s easy to make from scratch and I think it would bring a little more business to them? Not a big deal at all, just saying! :)

They just keep dropping down a star. Tonight they took an hour and a half to deliver a pizza on a Thursday night! We had to call to see if the driver got lost! The owner needs to step it up! The pizza is always soggy, so we started ordering it well done. Nope, it was still soggy. We are done with this half assed pizza place.

Neigbhors is a great local pizzeria. Though to call them a pizzeria is a little bit of an understatement, as they have a variety of food available to order.
The pizzas themselves come on a foundation of flavorful, slightly chewy crust. Their red sauce is tomato forward and compliments my usual toppings (just pepperoni!) super well. There is also a huge variety in their specialty pizzas– my wife loves the Pennsylvania– the combination of a tasty white sauce and oodles of toppings make it her favorite.
The pizzas aren’t Little Ceasar’s cheap– but you get what you pay for in this case. Our go to meal is their 1 medium specialty and 1 medium 1 topping pizza. It’s more than enough for my family of 3 to eat our fill, and have plenty of leftovers. Their customer loyalty program is nice too– ten orders nets you ten poker chips that you can turn in for a pizza!
Service has always been friendly, professional, and prompt. Delivery is usually how I get my pizzas– they always arrive in a timely fashion and my pizza is always piping hot.
None of this is to mention that Neighbor’s is a valued asset in our community, with their support of many local sports and charitable organizations. I’m super glad to have a business that decided to invest in our community, and provide jobs to local folks. Even better, their pizza is really good.

So I’ll start off by saying Neighbors has always been a great locally owned place to get a pizza. I’ve never minded paying the extra few bucks to help keep my money local. Tonight was one of the most disappointing experiences I’ve ever had.
I called the pizza in for pick up around 5:30pm, one large pizza and a salad… not a huge order… one pizza. I was told over the phone it would be ready in 25 minutes. So I get there around 5:55pm and was greated by a young woman that swiped my card and told me it would be up shortly.
As I sat and sat… and sat some more I had the misfortune of listening to two employees (a male and a female) argue in the back for twenty minutes.
During this time not a single person came out to apologize or explain what the problem was, I patiently waited chatting with a woman that had just came in explaining she was also told a 25 minute wait. Which seemed correct considering there was absolutely no one eating inside.
After chatting with the other customer with a «25 minute wait» for another 10 minutes we had finally gotten the pizza! Only took a little over an hour at this point but whatever… things happen. I try not to complain unless absolutely necessary, so once I received my pizza not once did they offer to compensate for the mess up, the girl at the counter said sorry for the wait only because she probably heard me complaining.
So I get the pizza home, as expected my wife asks me what took so long. I explain the situation, open the pizza to expect a freshly cooked pizza only to find out the pizza is COLD. It tasted like it had been sitting for well over 30 minutes, which makes me wonder why it took so long for me to get the pizza in the first place. Was my pizza sitting in the back getting cold the entire time while two unprofessional employees agrued for 20+ minutes?
Never the less. I’ll chalk it up to a learning experience and do business else where. Not only that, I will encourage others to do the same. If this business wants to stay in business they need to coach their employees and atleast explain whats going on when an expectation isn’t being met. Give much better customer service (since there was none here) and provide a good product.
I will no longer recommend Neighbors Pizza to any friends, family members or locals I meet in the area.

Great pizza. Delivery a bit slow but worth the wait.

Bonus points for delivering to Edgewater, but it did take over an hour which was kind of frustrating. When we ordered it would have been nice for a heads up it would take awhile. Pizza was just ok, nothing too spectacular. I do like all the state specific special pizzas they have. The philly one is delish!

My fiancé and I really love this spot. We are new to the area and while we were moving we saw this place and decided to try. We tried the bbq chicken pizza and the combination pizza. I LOVED the combo one. Super tasty and great flavor. the bbq was my fiancé’s favorite. He said the sauce had great flavor. I wonder if they make it themselves… But anyways not badly priced. It’s a mom and pop shop so I would expect to pay $ 20 for a large pizza. They also give you a chip for every pizza you order and after 10 (I think) you get a free pizza! We will be back!!!

The New York Pizza is Awesome!!! My husband & I love it. Sorry no other pizza place is better then this

WORST pizza ever. Paid $ 26 for a pizza whose crust was thinner than the toilet paper I use. I almost thought they might’ve forgotten the crust and just sent me the toppings! Not only that. We waited one and a half hours for this slimy mess only to chuck it in the garbage. Got in the car and picked up a DRIVE THRU PIZZA FROM LITTLE CEASERS which was a million and one times better than the sorry excuse.

I wrote a review on 4÷13÷15 about the wings I ordered for pick-​up. Needless to say, the review that I wrote was not a very nice review… SURPRISINGLY I received a call this evening from the manager! She addressed my concerns and my review. I was shocked that she took the time to read my review, and look up my number, and apologize to me! My concern genuinely seemed to be her concern as well. I am now rating NEIGHBORS PIZZA 5 STARS– for redeeming themselves, and the customer service shown through the redemption! Thank You Neighbors Pizza for addressing my concern, contacting me, and letting me know that your customers happiness matters. I’m willing to give you guys a 2^nd chance. It’s gonna be a long hot summer-​nobody wants to be stuck in the kitchen lol — SEE YA SOON :)

Bomb pizza! I’m from NY and this is one of the better places we have found and it’s close to our home! Try their buffet too it’s awesome and children under 2 eat free!

I can’t really say all the pizza are awesome here but the New York specialty pizza is the bomb. We always get the usual. Service is good and delivery great.

I was so impressed with our meal today. The food was delicious. came out exactly the way we ordered it and the staff was so pleasant. They came by our table twice to ask how things were and brought my daughter the gummy pizza at the end of her meal. places like this are a rare find.

Awesome pizza! Best in the area. My wife and I enjoy the «Montana» with blue cheese. The kids LOVE it as well. I almost never have any left overs! My mom and brother tried the gluenten free pizza they gave it a A+!!! They said it has hard to find a good gluenten free pizza. The staff is always friendly and the owner is a great guy if you ever have any problems he takes action and gets it taken care of.

Honestly the worst pizza I’ve had probably ever. I was hesitant to leave a bad review and thought I’d eat here again and try something different. Still horrible. 4 times and still horrible. I won’t come back. Their artichoke hearts are chopped up and still have spikes in it. Their sauce is not good and the dough is not good either. I am not sure how from toppings to sauce to crust, you could have such a nasty pizza. My 4 year old son wouldn’t even eat a second bite and he loves pizza. I promised myself I would not come back. I wish there was a good place to eat around Plumas lake. Honestly, the towermart 1 mile west from here serves better food.
The best pizza place I have found around here is in Wheatland, called Primetime pizza.

Very good and unique pizzas that you can get here. I like how they deliver very fast and the pizza stays hot and fresh. Also they don’t take much time prepping the pizza from scratch. So far I’m at 2 tokens so I need 8 more for a free pizza, which means I’m going to order more.

I have worked at 3 different pizza places in my day, in every facet of the industry, from delivery to prep to cooking to cashier to inventory, and this place is pretty decent.
I always pick up a pizza to go, and they are usually very close in terms of quoted time. Ive waited a little, at times, but been surprised at times. The quality is usually very decent, with ingredients being on the fresh side, and requests for «well done» being heeded most times. For not much more than the fast places, this is a much better pizza.
The staff here has been exceptionally friendly in literally every interaction I’ve had, even offering my kid some ice cream on the house, once. The location is pretty convenient, as well.
In my opinion, this place does a fine job of offering a pretty good pizza for a fair price with minimal hiccups. What more can you really ask for from a local place?
We will keep coming back, no question about it.

Good pizza with fresh quality ingredients. The sauce is really good also, don’t forget to stop in and try one of their bagels they are good also.

Love this local place… Routinely good service and product. Their Mediterranean salad is yum and it is not unusual that sometimes during the work week it is about the salad… When it’s time to go on a fest, the pizza is better than the franchises and the potato skins are a fave… Why go anywhere else? «Shop local»