Eric’s Hand Tossed Pizza & Subs

Eric’s is one of the best pizza places in the Lake Country area.
For starters, they have the best mozzarella marinara ever. Like a good mozzarella stick should be, theirs is wonton-​wrapped, not breaded. Paired with their excellent marinara sauce, and you’ve got a real winner of an appetizer!
Another good appetizer is their calamari sticks. They’re great, but after a few it gets to be a little much and they lose their appeal a bit. I’m still a fan though, don’t get me wrong.
Most importantly, of course, their pizzas are great. However, they can occasionally get a little greasy, especially if you order thin crust. My only real gripe with the pizzas is the sausage. It’s probably my very favorite pizza topping, and unfortunately Eric’s is LOADED with fennel, which I’m not too fond of. If you’re not sure what fennel tastes like, think black licorice. It’s common in sausage, but here they just use way too much. All the other toppings are always excellent and fresh, and they use really good cheese and delicious pizza sauce.
Eric’s also does a Pizza of the Month. However, it’s not always updated, and sometimes the same pizza might be the featured one for two months in a row if they haven’t yet thought of a new one. Sometimes they are delicious and sometimes the featured one just sounds uninspired or weird.
At any rate, the food here is really good, and overall their pizzas are authentic and tasty. Also, their delivery is fast and all the employees are very friendly.

We were looking for a good pizza place to try something different and decided to go here. We have eaten here a long time ago, but thought it was under new management or owners? So we tried again. I don’t think we will be coming back. The pizza is so salty! I know it got great reviews, but to me and my fiancé we couldn’t stop chugging the water afterwards due to the pizza being so salty. Some people may like this, but just not for us!

Great pizza done well! ingredients are fresh, pizzas are seasoned perfectly. Super friendly owner and staff supports community 120%
Delivery by boat on the lake is genius! I see the delivery boat all over the lake bringing gray pizza direct to your boat.

The Pizza here is awesome. Opened a couple years ago. My wife and I partially selected our place because it was close, when we moved. I haven’t been dissapointed by the food at all. Granted I occasionally have better, but it is few and far between.
— There are only 2 crust types, which I wish they had others, like a deep dish.
— The topping coverage is not always consistent, but never disappointing.

Ordered for the first time last night. Order was delayed because another person with the same name got my pizza instead. It doesn’t really matter, because this place makes the BEST pizza in the area! Can’t believe there isn’t a line down the street waiting for a pie.
Presentation is perfect, packaging is better than most. But you have to try this place. Definitely A+

Brilliant delivery by boat! We noticed the delivery boat on the lake (Okauchee) and gave it a shot. We timed it from the time we called… only 38 minutes!
So the pizza itself: decent overall. Slightly greasy but nothing that I was put off by. Crust was good, as we do enjoy a good hand tossed. I would order from here again.

Best pizza in Oconomowoc. Great pizza, sandwiches, and apps. Delivery is great, and worth the cost.