Gencarelli Brothers

$ 6 pizza that is delicious, what more could you ask for? They usually have pizzas ready to go, so I don’t bother calling ahead of time as a cheese pie is always ready.

The pizza is delicious! And it’s $ 6 a pie. A large pie, not a dinky pie or a piece of cardboard with ketchup from dominos. It is delivered hot and fresh and the crust is awesome. Two pies delivered for $ 14 cash? Tell me where you can find that around here or anywhere. This is a home run. A no brainer. To the people who complain about getting through: yes, the phones are busy, duh! It’s $ 14 for two pizzas in Nutley! Common people! That’s the cost of one pie everywhere else and it’s nowhere near as good!

In a world where the pizza competition is steep and prices are often outrageous, I have to be generous and give the 4^th star even though my true feelings put this place at a 3.5. Despite a lot of the hate being spewed in some of the reviews below, I have to stick up for Gencarelli Bro’s pizza. How can you beat $ 6 for a pie?! Not to mention, it is NOT bad pizza. Sorry to all the haters but anytime I’ve gotten a pizza from here, there is sufficient sauce and cheese, and the crust is just how I like it. No muss, no fuss, you get ur pizza and are on your way. Also have never had an issues with any of the phone girls being incompetent. My order was just fine which I picked up on time for Superbowl Sunday. The only thing I can say is that yes, the phone lines are generally pretty busy. But, doesn’t that reflect a booming business? So I guess if you want to call on the first try around dinner time and get through you might be a little flustered since you most likely won’t at this place. My advice, however, would be to get over it, dial a few more times, and enjoy ur pizza as well as the fact that you only had to cough up $ 6 for it ;)

Discount pizza.
You get what you pay for. Do yourself a favor and pay a couple of dollars more for a properly cooked pizza.
The girls taking the orders are completely inattentive and are more interested in music videos on TV. No wonder that have issues getting the orders correct.
Don’t waste your time

Good pizza, nice cheese. Great price. Regular pizza is $ 6, $ 10 with extra chesse. Nice people, too. Ready when promised. Best pizza we have had in Nutley so far

Delivery is absolutely horrible. Called to order dialed simultaneously on cell and land line for over 20 min. Cell showed 132 dials
Finally got through waited 10 min with horrible hold music with a couple of false starts where I could hear them connect and then put me back on hold. Then I got cut off.
If you can’t drive there and wait for your pizza don’t bother! !!!

I have officially found my go-​to pizza spot in Nutley. Great pizza, and their large plain is only $ 6. The crust is thinner than usual as well (without being an actual thin crust pie), so you get more cheese and sauce flavor. Our order was ready quickly and they had it right away when we went for pickup.
Staff were super friendly. Definitely happy that I found this place.

The pizza is disgusting and the people are assholes… Not worth the cheap price of $ 6 when the people are not helpful and unfriendly. Plus the guy who owns it has 0 respect for customers. And his girls that work there sit there and look at you.
So overall cheap crap pizza with a girl who doesnt help just looks at you behind the counter with an owner who has 0 respect and not a clue how to run a business yeah… Not a good location to go for pizza try Ralph’s on Franklin Ave Nutley.

I’ve ordered pizza from here a few times. They’re known for their $ 6 large plain pies and what can I say other than you get what you pay for. The pizza lacks sauce and flavor and the crust doesn’t deliver. If you’re in Nutley theirs plenty of other pizzerias you can get pizza from that are much better. I’m giving 2 stars because of the cheap cost that can’t be matched, and the service isn’t bad.

This was my first time ordering from Gencarelli’s, the pizza was okay, it was ready right away & $ 6 isn’t bad, but the slices were so small & skinny, each pie was probably cut into 15 slices. Unfortunately i’m giving it two stars because i ordered 5 pies, 3 Cheese Pies & 2 Pepperoni Pies, i spent $ 38 but when i got my pies I soon realized they gave me 2 Sausage Pies instead of Pepperoni but I noticed it too late. Overall I think this will be my first & last time ordering from this Pizzeria.

I am not sure what I expected for $ 6 large pie. If you like cardboard with ketchup on it and low grade cheese, this is place to stop at. If you want good pizza there are numerous places in Nutley you can go. You would be better off stopping at shop rite and pickup a frozen pizza.

The pizza here is delicious, and for $ 6 for a plain pie it makes it a good choice, especially when you have an occasion that you have to buy a bunch of pies for. Great place and the people that own and run it are very friendly.

The only thing I have ever ordered from this place is pizza and it is good! Nothing special but the best thing about it is that it is cheap only $ 6! The first time I ordered it took 1 hour for delivery. The next time it came within in 20 minutes the third time it toke 1 and a half hours !!! This will be the last time I order. I rather get pizza and pay a little more than wait over an hour for pizza. If I must I’ll pick it up just for the price.

Ordered a Taylor ham egg and cheese pizza and nuggets and it was absolutely delicious. Good delivery. Quick also. Cheap food and it is not bad quality.

The pizza Gods have spoken!
Their words: «Let there be a Gencarelli Brothers pizza closer to Neal N.!!»
Oh Gencarelli Brothers — how I miss thee! I absolutely loved the Caldwell location, Genc’s. Not only the best $ 5 – 6 large pie, but one of the best pizzas period. As a bonus, this location even has a private parking lot! It’s mainly a grab and go type of place, but if it’s not busy, feel free to talk to Henry, the owner.
So after testing to make sure the pizza has remained the same, the verdict is in:
Thin crust. Great crunch on the outer crust, foldable otherwise. Good balance of sauce and cheese. Exactly the same as I remember!
I can devour an entire pizza in one sitting. I have done so before at the other location — numerous times.
They’ll continue to see me a lot on Mondays and Tuesdays when they have $ 7 one-​topping pizzas.