Wanted

I was in the area and really just needed to get something to eat before heading back to my friend’s place where I was staying. This place was near, and seemed cheap and fast enough.
The employees weren’t super attentive. No greeting or anything as I walked in. I wasn’t even sure how to order, or who I should place my order with. Not the most welcoming environment.
The place isn’t very big but there’s seating for about 15 people on bar stools along the walls. There were two TVs playing some kind of America’s Funniest Home Videos show. It’s a quiet, unassuming place.
Eventually I asked for two slices of pepperoni which were $ 2 each (it’s $ 1.50 for a slice of cheese). Unfortunately there’s a $ 5 minimum for cards, so I had to buy a soda to use my debit card.
The pizza itself was fine. It was filling and warm. Not very memorable. The thing is, there are SO many pizza options in the city. There’s no reason to go to this one. Unwelcoming employees, average pizza. You won’t regret going to this place. If you’re in the area and are craving some cheap pizza, go for it. But you could find better pizza that is just as affordable within a couple of minutes.

Wanted
NY Manhattan FiDi
8pm Friday 12^th February 2016
Two Stars
This place is not great. I had a meat lovers and Hawaiian slice ($ 6 total). The crust was soggy and could barley be held under its own weight. The toppings were a bit burnt. The sauce and cheese were okay. The meat lovers had stringy bacon, old pepperoni, and some sausage. The Hawaiian had big chunks of ham and pineapple. Nothing was great but nothing was that bad either.

Ok don’t hate me but I didn’t think the pizza here was that bad!!! For $ 1.50 a slice it was pretty tasty! The pizza was hot and the cheese ooey and gooey and the crust nice and crisp. I as always got the margherita and I loved the flavor of the tomato sauce and the nice sprinkling of basil on top! Even my husband enjoyed it and for the price you couldn’t beat it.
It’s not a fancy place, just a couple of stools in front of a counter facing the wall and the street. My favorite thing was the guy behind the counter, he was so nice and courteous and gave us extra napkins, water and anything else we wanted… customer service win! He really won me over when this guy came in trying to sell candy and he gave him a couple of slices of pizza for free. I will always patronize a business that takes care of people in the community, what a nice gesture!
I love a business with heart! So if you’re in the neighborhood and looking for a bite, stop by Wanted. Its cheap and will fill your tummy up with some good tasting hot pizza. I know I’ll be coming back!

I was here today after attending a meeting in the area, I had decided to hang out by the Seaport and then I wanted to get a snack before my train ride home. I got one of their plain slices. While waiting for that to heat up I placed an order for garlic knots. The slice was ready first so I ate it in the place while waiting for the garlic knots.
The slice was crispy, the sauce had enough flavor of herbs and tomatos, and the cheese was not too thick but sufficient.
When my garlic knots were ready I was asked if i wanted the garlic knots to stay or to go. I took them to go.
When I ate my garlic knots you can taste lots of garlic and some oregano. The shape looked more like mini rolls than knots but the flavor and texture were just the same.
Each was $ 1.50

There reg. slice is ok not the best but what do you want for $ 1.50. But wait willing to shell out $ 3 bucks for a fresh mozzarella slice, we’ll worth it it’s like eating a brick oven pizza trust me give it a shot well worth it. But I doubt you will only have one. Oh none thing though make sure they heat it up all though it’s taste good warm but straight out of the oven it’s amazing.

It’s okay. It’s not the best slice of pizza ever, but it’s pretty fulfilling, good atmosphere and other non pizza options like chicken, bubble tea, and milkshakes. You can watch tv and have some stills to sit down.

not bad. dunno why the hate. looks like the same owners as Roll and go or joey pepperoni’s/
$ 1.50 per slice. not bad at all. My coworkers had it and they enjoyed it and have been back, so it must be okay, right?
I went with the half chicken (all dark meat), rice + beans, and salad. i’d say it’s probably the cheapest and most filling meal you can get in this area for under $ 9.

I came here around 10 pm last night. There were a few other patrons in this mostly empty area which I thought was a good sign. I got a slice of the meat lovers pizza for $ 3. It was served hot, fresh, and quick. However they used maple bacon. The pizza was extremely sweet and tasted heavily of maple syrup, which is not what I was looking for. This should be described on the menu board or by the staff as I think sweet pizza is somewhat of an acquired taste and definitely unexpected on a slice of meat lovers.

Ghetto pizzeria, rude service, didn’t even give me back change, terrible!!!
Pizza is gross as well! Don’t go!

Haven’t had the pizza, but the chicken meal is great! You can get a quarter chicken + rice + beans + salad for $ 5. The chicken is good (though I always add a little bit of salt & ask for it with hot sauce on top). Service is really good too, even when it’s busy.

Was looking for a go-​to dollar slice place near my apartment for late night snacking, and this is definitely not the spot. First of all, the pizza is $ 1.50 and does not have any sauce. And they burn the pizza! The people working there are super unattentive, its not that hard to heat up a piece of pizza in the toaster oven w/​o burning it. Need reccomendations for better $ slices in this neighborhood!

Having pizza, rotisserie chicken and bubble tea under one roof isn’t the sort of setup that would draw me in, but I was in a chicken mood so I checked it out.
The chicken/​rice and beans combo was solid if not groundbreaking. With an eye on the global economy, it’s nice to get this much food for $ 7. The chicken was juicy but unfortunately it wasn’t entirely featherless.
The hours are bar-​friendly, especially on weekends.

cheap, soft crust, friendly service, did I say cheap in the financial district? lol I’m sold! I had a bbq chicken slice and I enjoyed every piece. Definitely a must go!

First off let’s talk about food: I live right around the corner from this place so I was looking for a local spot to get my late night pies. The pizza is nothing to write home about but ok for a quick bite.
However, the customer service was so horrible that I will never go back and will recommend all my friends to go elsewhere. Last night around 10 I ordered two pies, one veggie and one meat. They messed up my order and put meat on my veggie pizza, which I discovered when I got home. Called back and told the guy and he said «come back with the pizza and I’ll give you a new one». So I went back with the wrong pizza, and he exchanged it for the right one. No apology for the inconvenience and he laughed when I complained about having to walk all the way home and back with the wrong pizza-​and I’m assuming he took my old pizza and sold it off as slices.
Bottom line: They will mess your order up, horrible customer service; save your money and hit up a different local pizza spot.

A whole variety of pizza slices, awesome everyone should try it. I strongly recommend it. Buffalo wing pizza, Teriyaki chicken pizza is also good. Prices are not bad at all. Right by the train and not to far from South street seaport. Small location but if you take to go.

This is the first dollar-​pizza joint that is now officially $ 1.50 for a plain slice. The nerve!
The pizza isn’t that great anyway. It’s thick in the crust and light on the sauce/​cheese. If you’re going to skimp on the flavor, and replace it with cheap dough, then you have no right to charge more now. Other dollar-​pizza places do a much better job of having a nice thin crispy crust.
Would only go here if I’m in FiDi late night since it’s one of the few places that’s open late (and «late» for FiDi is like 11pm).

Don’t get 1 slice get two

Just stopped by for a spur of the moment milk shake and it’s pretty good. Not the best I’ve had but far from worst. There are real strawberries in it. Less than $ 2 for a slice so I look forward to coming back for a full lunch.