Tiro A Segno of Ny

Sooooo many courses! Great spot though. Old School vibe and good food.

I came here with my boss and co-​workers for our Holiday party and I have to say it was absolutely superb. Real old school which I love, beautifully appointed, and the food is delicious. The shooting range in the basement was awesome and we had a great time. My boss is a member and he frequents it often and now I can see why. We had a blast.

I just got a Timehop notification from my post of this little gem 6 years ago… and I had to search for it by my description of the address because I remember it being Members Only and having no sign/​indication of what’s inside the 3 adjoined brownstones. I was told to dress up and that men had to wear sports coats, so I knew this was going to be an experience.
And, boy, was it ever! The authenticity of this place pours into every dish that leaves the kitchen. I can’t recall what I ate, specifically, (plus, I believe everything was ordered for us by the sponsor of our evening,) but I remember that it was unlike anywhere I had ever eaten before in NYC.
Plus, the New York Rifle Association is in the basement — who doesn’t like to get drunk on the finest Italian cuisine and wine the city has to offer and then go shoot a rifle?! (I did wear the eye patch to either 1) increase my target perception, or 2) minimize seeing-​double. Whatever the reason — this photo prompted me to do my research and I’m so happy that I was able to locate them and review — I don’t even think Unilocal was around in 2009!

I was fortunate enough to come here after a member closed off the top floor of the club for a private party. The room was separated into 3 sections, one had the bar and TV area, the second had a pool table and some sofas for seating and the third had tables with chairs for eating.
The overall ambiance is very similar to a steakhouse, so you can expect some more old-​school features and architecture throughout. I am not sure if it was required for just our party, but all men are required to wear jackets.
The bar had a good assortment of drinks available and the in-​house food was all very good. Here, you have your typical old-​school Italian staples — penne cooked al dente, some eggplant/​chicken parmiggiano, vegetables and potatoes as well as some veal. Although it was sitting in the hot trays, everything was still cooked well and not overdone. I look forward to the next time I am invited to an event here and being sure I make it down to the riffle range in the basement (closes at 11pm).

My dad has been a member for over 50 years-​if you think this place is old school now, you should have seen it before it was renovated a couple decades ago! Anyway, the food is always terrific and reliable (if not cutting edge, or close to it). They will make you just about anything you want. Great value, since they’re not trying to make a profit. Mob jokes aside, it’s quite a classy joint-​everyone dresses to impress (unless a guest isn’t clued ahead by their host) and it’s always civil.
A date I took there didn’t believe me when I told her we could target shoot during the meal-​so when the captain asked if we were going to shoot, and would we like to after the primi or the pasta course, she just about slipped off her chair!
It’s a very, very special part of NYC-​so if you ever have a chance to go, don’t miss it.

From the moment you step into this private members only club, you are taken care of. From the bar which mixes up incredible cocktails. Through the four course dinner which consists of apps, salad, entrée, and dessert. All of which were excellent. To shooting rifles in the professional rifle range in the basement. Everything is incredible and I cant wait to visit again. I am very thankful to my friends for the experience.

This place is unreal. I feel very lucky to have been invited. One part central casting from Goodfellas, one part old school Italian kitchen, one part high class redneck gun range, equals an outstanding night.

Proud to say that I am a member here. Privilege to be a member of the oldest Italian-​American club and gun club in NYC and the country. Very exclusive place consisting of around 450 members at best. One of the best things is the dress code… Jacket and tie at all times for men. Great place to go for a romantic date, guys night or even host a party. I use it quite often for business (clients love it) and pleasure. Everything on the menu is excellent. Meals are served in courses (app, pasta, entrée, cheese/​fruit/​cookies and then the desert cart). All deserts are made in-​house which is hard to come by. Wine list is a binder with endless choices. Beautiful place, great atmosphere, great history, great food and did I mention shooting after dinner? What more can you want. If you appreciate finer things and good food… Try to get an invite to here!

Absolutely beautiful premises: love the architectural detail on both the first floor (dark, wood paneling) and the fourth floor (exposed brick walls and ceiling rafters, wooden shutters).
The staff was friendly: playful by the bar, detailed in the gun range, and professional in overall service.
My favorites:
(1) The meatballs: moist, flavorful;
(2) The cookies (amaretto with pine nuts? a-​ma-​zing);
(3) The gun range: what a fun (and safely run) sidebar to any celebration!

Now I have to admit, I know that New York has everything maybe except Palm trees and warm weather all year round, but if you want some excitement in your life there are a litany of things to do and places you can go.
For a Company Holiday Party I could not have enjoyed myself more, from great catered Italian food to a luxurious 4 story Colonial Brownstone with masseuses and a Shooting range downstairs and cigars for the taking I was in a dynamic Wild Wild West. A Classic Good Girl gone bad scenario and I have no regrets. This place was a ton of fun, although the DJ needed a little work, but besides that I felt like I attended a very grown House Party and would not mind going again!
I took home my target after my shooting range experience, lets just say I have a wicked aim ;-).

Cocktails & guns? I try not to mix the two but made an exception for this swanky club. My first try out, I was able to shoot Osama’s eyes and mustache line, not bad!
The food is amazing and won’t quit.. . literally it feels like there are nine courses. The «desert cart» is like visiting willy wonka’s factory, — neverending.
There’s a cigar floor as well that I’ll have to try next time out. Tiro rocks.

A gun club in the Village?
Rather unique. Was there for a non-​member social event, but I’d invite the opportunity to go back some time for a meal and check out the type of people who frequent the place — maybe even get invited to use some firearms at their shooting range in the basement.
Has the ambiance of a New York steakhouse — pleasantly stuffy.
Next time I’ll… bring my smoking pipe and favorite rifle