Mulberry Street Cigars

Owner of the business writes:
«Sorry to hear that we were closed we had a family emergency no need to give us a 1 star review on Unilocal.Next time your planning to come call 212−941−7400 to make sure we are their .We will give you a free handrolled cigars for your inconvenience offer is only valid if you remove your 1 star review Thanks !»
As I was away for my honeymoon with my wife, I didn’t exactly think about his shop, but just 6 days later, the gentleman, who also wrote a 5-​star review of his own business (that’s a no no, buddy) decided to send me a compliment Calling me a jerk off. You’re a disgrace. As a grown man you should be ashamed of yourself. Maybe learn how to use your Unilocal account instead of pulling the tough guy act and you wouldn’t have had a 1 star review. Good luck getting the review removed and if you try harassing me again I’ll have your account flagged.

Just hours from a trip from Italy where my first taste of Cubans was nothing to write home about, and on my way home to the 50^th state, I stopped in the NYC to enjoy the Christmas lights. I found this shop conveniently located couple blocks from my hotel in SOHO. Located in the heart of Little Italy they had a curbside display of their local blend of Dominicans being rolled before your eyes. I enjoyed their recommended mild flavor and lightly dipped churchill. Their prices are typical for NYC and you can also choose from a selection of major brands. Coming from a state with strict smoking laws I was able to enjoy my stick on the bench exclusively for smoking.

What a great spot to pick up an extra special hand rolled cigar for dad (and my uncles, coworkers and in laws!). The selection of cigars will overwhelm you but no worries, they have you covered. Even with my minuscule knowledge of cigars, I really sound like I know what I’m talking about now thanks to all they taught me. What a great shop in Little Italy, I’m glad we dropped by.

Ya can’t do Little Italy without a cigar stop — here’s why:
Fresh-​rolled cigars
Different body
Nothing too pricey
Open late!

Great selection, great service. Stop by on you next trip to NYC. Have gotten some cigars in the past for friends and have never gotten complaints! The last time I was in NYC was for San Gennaro 2 years ago, they put a booth out on the street and have special guests in the store.

I wish I could give this place 2.5 stars, as I have been here on occasion when in the area and even though the selection is ok, the overall experience is a bit lacking. Staff is not too knowledgeable when it comes to the cigars on hand, and sometimes the humidors do not seem set right as I have noticed some cigars to be on the dry side.
Still, location is smack dab in the heart of Little Italy. Prices area bit high there because of the touristy location. Nice bench to sit on right outside the front door and enjoy a smoke and people watch. Only go here if you are in the area for convenience.

Their premium and hand rolled cigars are over priced, bcz of the tourist location. At least the sticks are not dry.

Big selection, but sub par cigars.

This place is not the real deal. Sales people know very little about cigars, and the humidification & storage are questionable.
It’s alright if you know exactly what you want and they carry it.

One (Star) for location. Simply smack right in the middle of Little Italy with close proximity for transportation is a plus point.
One (Star) for the varieties of cigars and cigarettes they carry.
That’s the highest I would rate them based on convenience and varieties.
I went over after work last week to check out some cigars. Apparently, the person behind the counter couldn’t care at all. I call that lousy customer service. I ask for recommendation of cigar that’s not sweet tasting and mild. The answer «It’s all there. Read the label».
I would definitely not recommend this shop if you need advice on purchases but if you already know what you want. By all means, the selection is pretty good.

After a few subway rides and some walking around we ended up in litte italy. Sure, very touristy area for sure but at least we saw it. we had a few smokers in our group that day so we stopped in here for refills. cigars and cigarettes galore!
Someone in our group smokes these really gross vanilla cigarettes (hahaha!) that are hard to find, and oh guess what! They carried them here.
I don’t smoke, but was amused by this place. They have about a million pictures of the famous people who have stopped in here. All over the walls are pictures.(apparently they must have a camera sitting behind the counter poised and ready to go.). So I was slightly dismayed they didn’t want MY photograph, but whatever… their loss.
So there ya go. You’re in the area and need something to smoke or just want to look at famous people in awkward poses, come here.

This place is pretty handy for picking up whatever assorted cigars you wish, however it certainly doesn’t have that upscale /​woodsy feel that most cigar stores possess.
The atmosphere is more of the corner store, neon lit type of convenience store than anything else. Which I find takes away slightly from the kindred spirit feel of perusing and purchasing cigars and talking shop.