Milk & Cookies

If you have a sweet tooth, this place is for you! The cookies are displayed on trays behind the register so if you’re waiting in line, you can’t really decide until you get closer to the front. They have a wide variety of different types of cookies. Price wise, for two cookies it was about 5.50~ and for a dollar more you can make an ice cream sandwich!!! Which was the dessert path I decided to take. In between the delicious chocolate chip mint gelato, I picked the sprinkle sugar cookies and the toffee chocolate chip cookie. Noticed that the sugar cookie was a bit tough and the toffee one was definitely on the harder side. Overall it was okay. Way too much sugar for me that I couldn’t finish it even though I tried to power through!!! Would I come back? Probably not, unless I’m in the area. Probably would try a cookie alone. I hope they can warm them up to make them softer!

BEST COOKIES by far!
Great neighborhood cookie shop!
Friends who use to live in NYC recommended this place. It’s adorable and great variety of cookies!

We went here for dessert after dinner on date night. When you walk in the place smells amazing. It looks cute with a couple of tables and then the counter.
We got an ice cream sandwich with dark chocolate ice cream sandwiches between and peanut butter chocolate cookie and a chocolate chip cookie. It was delicious. Only would have been better if they warmed up the cookies to make them more gooey. Would come back!

I have been to NYC at least once a year for the past 5 years and this is ALWAYS on my must-​stop list. I’m absolutely obsessed with cookies and this spot has been baking some top-​notch cookies for a long time. Nestled off a little side street in the West Village, this was absolutely going to be a stop on my wife and mine’s DIY food tour.
As soon as you walk into the door of this cookie specialty shop you get hit with aroma of fresh baked cookies. A little pricey for a cookie but definitely worth it. The cookies are fresh baked and hit the spot every single time! The reason why I didn’t give one of my favorite cookie shops in NYC 5 stars was because the clerk was a little rude when I asked her to heat up my cookies. I love my cookies warm and gooey and on previous occasions the baker has been able to comply with my request. However, this time I was rudely told that the oven would take too long to heat up and the cookies were baked this morning.
Luckily for me the cookies were very fresh and I definitely was not disappointed. Milk & Cookies has several different flavors, but the classic chocolate chip and the peanut-​butter cup get me every time. I love this cookie shop and despite the clerk it will always be a stop for me when I come to the city. I just can’t get enough of cookies.

You can never go wrong with M&C! Small place, but the best cookies in town!!! the owner is a hard working person who has great recipes for dessert. You must visit

Just overpriced, tasteless cookies for people that do not know better. There are a French & Italian bakeries within 2 blocks of this place with quality products.
I live in the neighborhood & it was my first visit… I tried 3 cookies (one would of been enough because they weigh a ton) a chocolate chip, a sprinkle cookie & one I did not even know. After one bite of each I tossed them.

I finally got around to going here after seeing pictures of their ice cream cookie sandwiches on Instagram but unfortunately they weren’t the best. I got mocha chip ice cream between two sugar cookies. The cookies weren’t very fresh and they cracked and fell apart pretty easily. The ice cream was a rather hard texture and it just wasn’t what I was expecting. Although, my friend got mint ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies and said it was all delicious so maybe I didn’t pick the best flavors. Just a side note, the woman working there at the time wasn’t the friendliest but that’s not a big deal. The store was cozy though!

We used to go here all the time but now it is a disaster. The storefront in rundown and they didn’t have whipped cream or hot fudge for the brownie sundae. Those are very easy gets. We also got two cookies which were stale.
I told my wife I should have paid with my credit card so I could dispute the bill which was shockingly high. We’ll never go back and I implore you to do the same.

I stopped by Milk and Cookies Bakery on Christmas Eve to pick up some last minute holiday party desserts as well as the freshly baked dog treats that I had read about on a blog. I picked out a variety of cookies and a bag of doggy treats at the counter. Service was good.
I went home and wrapped them all in layers of plastic wrap (airtight) and put them in the refrigerator to keep everything fresh for the next day.
The next day, after unwrapping everything at the party, I noticed one of the doggy treats had some green mold on the surface while it was still in the wrapper, so I couldn’t feed them to the drooling dog at my feet. That was an unfortunate waste of $ 3.50.
The cookies (for the humans) were very enjoyable, except one chocolate chip cookie that had two small sharp splinters of wood inside. Initially, I thought it was a hard grain, seed, or nut shell that found its way into the cookie, but it was too dense; it had sharp enough edges to get lodged in someone’s throat. I sincerely hope nobody has had a similar appetite-​eliminating experience.

I been here a couple of times with Lapin. The treats are a bit expensive but really delicious. He loves the blueberry crumble (around $ 5) and I love the cookies. They make most of the stuff in store and there is a small eating section in front of the shop. The customer service is a bit of a hit or a miss though.

I came to this bakery years ago and I loved it so naturally I was super excited to go back on a recent trip to New York City. This time around, I thought the bakery was underwhelming. We went in the evening and it was completely empty. We ordered two cookies and a coffee. The chocolate chip cookie was nice but the other one was just ok. Coffee was ok too.

I have been there many times nice little place many flavors of cookies which are all good and a few other sweets available. The groupon is a good deal
i will return
Food-​good
service — order at counter not really a service place
atmosphere –good

Solid bakery with great cookie and pastry selection. There was one cookie which was made out of about 7 different kinds of cereal, including fruit loops, apple jacks, lucky charms, etc. I had the S’mores cookie which was great. Right next door to Sushi Nakazawa, so come here for a fun dessert after.

Very cool small bakery with amazing cookies. The mint chocolate are crazy. If you go to cherry lane theater, it on same block just off of 7^th Ave. show your ticket for a discount. Few Tables and bar stools to chill out

Cool spot tucked away on a quiet West Village street. I went for an ice cream sandwich at $ 6.50 which was both the largest and most expensive ice cream sandwich experience of my life. They make everything fresh there, but for that cost I prefer an ice cream from a Washington Square Park vendor. The cookies smelled delicious and I would give this place another chance based on that possibilty alone.

Everyone loves cookies (people, I love cookies) and this place serves them up fresh everyday. There are a long list of cookie flavors and are readily available throughout the day. Some cookie rankings…
Milk Chocolate Caramel — The combination of sweet and Salty is not too overpowering — the caramel adds a a smooth flavor as well
Chocolate Mint — More Chocolate with a hint of mint
Chocolate Chip — Nice ratio of chocolate chips, great original recipe
Snicker Doodle — A lot of cinnamon for sure, but the flavor is still enjoyable
Sugar — The way it should be done! Light and flavorful — the sugar ratio is on point.
S’Mores — Woah, graham flavor with marshmallow pieces/​chocolate chips. Yes.

The service was great. The guy knew a lot about the products and was very patient with us on picking what we wanted.
The place is cute. It’s small. It’s cozy. It was nice because no one was there when we went but I could only imagine how annoying it would be if it gets crowded.
The cookies amazing! We ordered six including the bacon cookie. I didn’t really get to eat the bacon but it sure smelled like it. There were more chocolate chips. It was good. The cookies are a good size.
The brownies are amazing! It’s soft and delicious. Would definitely recommend this place.

The Quick: Walk in, gain 10lbs. Sorry, I don’t make the rules. Fantastic cookies when warm, very good if not right out of the oven. The chocolate caramel seems to be the winner, although maple bacon was different and delicious as well.
The Details: I don’t know how someone could have self-​control when walking into the store… This tiny little shop smells of delicious homemade goods which always remind me of home and of my childhood… I was a chubby kid.
There is nothing pretentious about the shop, there just a few tables where you can sit and enjoy your cookies (or different types of the desserts) and milk.
As mentioned above, chocolate caramel is an obvious winner, I’ve never been disappointed with this cookie. Some of the other ones I think are less impressive, when the caramel and chocolate are warm and gooey it just taste like happiness.
The Damage: The cookies are pretty big and are about $ 2.50 each (possibly $ 2.75 each, but I bought 8 cookies for $ 20)
*There was a $ 10 for $ 20 groupon, make sure to check.

Why not take a cookie break in the middle of the day? Nestled on a quiet little nook off the chaos of 7^th Ave in West Village, milk and cookies is exactly what it sounds like. A petite counter with a few tables allowing for guests to order and eat cookies, milk, ice cream or any combination thereof.
Cookies are a hefty size, so one is a reasonably generous treat. In addition to standard chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin they also offer more exotic flavors like salted oatmeal white chocolate, and some sort of candied bacon.
Ice cream is also served which you can combine with cookies to have them make your own ice cream sandwich. I haven’t tried this out yet, and it could add a star if done right. Cold organic skim or whole milk available for purchase. I was told its Horizon’s Organic. Either way, goes well with a day of cupcake/​chocolate touring as I was.
I’m more a devotee of classic bakeries and ice cream shops for sweets. Once I try the ice cream here, maybe they’ll gain another star. For now, it’s a good place to stop when you’re having a cookie craving attack.

What the hell is the hype? I tried like 6 cookies and couldn’t find a single redeeming quality. Most disappointing was the chocolate chip cookie… like not even close to a good chocolate chip cookie.
The only thing I will say in the defense of M&C is that we came in right as it was closing and the cookies were probably not fresh. The girl working that night was also awesome and I feel bad saying these cookies sucked (but they did).

Freshly baked cookies in a huge variety — the perfect spot to warm up after an afternoon stroll through the neighborhood! We tried the salted oat cookie today as part of the cupcake tour — this wouldn’t have been my first choice but it tasted great and I’m glad that we had the chance to try something new!
We will definitely try the bacon cookie next time!

J’ai mangé dans cette petite boutique les meilleurs cookies de ma vie! Je n’ai pas eu assez faim pour tester leur fameux ice-​cream sandwiches (sandwich de cookie avec de la glacé au milieux). 3 énormes et délicieux cookies pour 12 dollar croyez moi ils en valent le coup… Deux jours plus tard ils étaient toujours aussi fondants et excellents!
Petit bug-​up personnel pour le cookie avec des bouts de caramel…