Justino’s Pizzeria

Great New York Pizza! We order from Justino’s all the time and the have great pies! They are always quick and the pizza is straight out of the oven. Can’t beat it

Thank you for putting up with a huge order of 7 pizza pies last minute. Pizza was yummy and did not take too long. Thanks again!

0 stars. They fruadently charged my card $ 3.50 when its clear the pizza is 2.50.
They just try to hustle you. Dont recommend it. Shady business. Not a good way to treat customers.

Growing up in New York City, I have had a LOT of pizza in my life. I cannot, however, say that I’ve tasted a better white slice than the one crafted at Justino’s. I can’t even describe how good it is because no words I have will do it justice. You simply have to go for yourself. It’s out of this world

I have only tried the regular slice, but I can say it is a great slice. Slices are 2.50 but they are big enough to be two slices (yum). Recommended

Would be 5 stars but 50% of the time they over cook the grandma pizza. When not burnt the grandma is «special».

My fav pizza in NY. So many amazing specialty slices. Order the penne alla vodka pie it will change your life

I tried again. Nope, still can’t get dough right and its like I’m eating a cracker like dough. On top of that there was a hair on my slice! Gross! Done forever!

Solid pizza and open late. It comes through in the clutch for a Riverside South neighborhood lacking in late night food options.

Ordered pizza, was told 20min. I called back 2hrs later & was told pizza was out for delivery, waited another hour, STILL NO PIZZA!!!

Justino’s was recommended to us by our hotel’s front desk staff because it was some of the best New York-​style pizza you can get– and they were right!
We walked the couple of blocks to the front of the pizza place, and it is literally a hole in the wall, but hey, some of the best food comes from places like that, and this pizza joint was no exception!
We walked in and ordered our pizzas by the slice. They all looked awesome to try, but in order to prevent my pants size from going up a couple sizes, I just ordered two slices– the buffalo chicken and the chicken bacon ranch. The guy working the counter threw the slices in the oven, cooked them for about 7 minutes, then handed them over to me in a mini pizza box. At this point, the line was out the door, so that’s always a pretty good sign.
The CBR slice was savory and the chicken even had a nice crust on it– certainly a cool surprise. The creamy white sauce on it was also an interesting touch. With the buffalo chicken pizza, that one had some pretty epic sauce– again, super tangy and everything that you think buffalo sauce should be.
Overall, this place was pretty sweet! The prices were good and pizza was great!

Quick note, be careful of fake reviews or mistaken reviews. This spot has no seating, inside or out, so those reviews complaining about the dirty tables or seating are off the mark.
That said, this is «New York» pizza at its most New York and affordable.
You’ll pay 2.50 a slice for the basic cheese, which is great for a large slice. You’ll pay 4.50 for a buffalo chicken slice which is might seem expensive but the amount of chicken they give you is more than worth it. You’ll be full with 3 cheese slices (7.50) or 2 buffalo chicken pieces (9.00), which is great.
It’s quick, it’s affordable, it’s New York pizza.

Great location in the middle of Manhattan! Close to everything in Manhattan like Central Park, Fordham University, hotels, residences.

4 stars for being a hunger-​saver in the wee hours of the morning (i.e. 2am, 3am).
Justino’s is pretty much the only thing open that’s fast and edible around this time in that area that isn’t a bar or a diner. I wouldn’t choose to eat this as a regular meal, but it’s sure tasty when you’ve got the munchies late night on the weekends.
They have various types of pizza available depending on when you go in and what they have made at that time. I got the mushroom and pepperoni pizza, which they throw back in the oven so it’s extra hot and crispy when it comes out. I wouldn’t say it’s the best pizza (definitely not a Juliana’s) in the world, but it hits the spot at 3 in the morning. 2 slices around or under 5 bucks.

Was looking for a fast pizza spot in my neighborhood and I’ve found it! The pizza is nothing special but it’s decently priced ($ 2.50 for a cheese slice) and the place is open late. I’ve ordered from a couple of times in the past 3 months and would recommend for a quick slice.

Get: mushroom pizza, buffalo chicken pizza. But share, because the flavors might be too overpowering to eat an entire slice on your own :)
I tried the broccoli/​chicken pizza, and it was kind of dry. The margherita is always a safe choice, too!
Fast service, convenient take-​out location, perfect for a quick and filling bite. About $ 4 per slice.

I ordered the stuffed chicken roll and a fried chicken hero and if I wasn’t absolutely starving I would have thrown it straight out. The bread was burnt and hard, the chicken was Burt and tasteless and the whole meal tasted like it was cooked yesterday and warmed up today. Maybe I shouldn’t expect good food at 12:30am, but I shouldn’t have to eat burnt food…

Two weekends ago, after a long night at 1– Oak, my friends and myself decided that we wanted some late night pizza. A friend of ours recommended Justino’s (at 4:00 a.m.). Granted it was the only place open until 4:30, the pizza was very good. I had a chicken and tomato slice which was delicious, and my friend inhaled her vodka slice! I will definitely come back after my next night of debauchery.

I am back in Florida and still dreaming about the vodka pizza we had twice during our visit.
FYI: NO SEATING INSIDE OR OUTSIDE. TAKE OUT OR DELIVERY ONLY
We ordered from Seamless (a sight to use to order food that delivers in your area) the first night we were there. We ordered the Vodka pizza and the sauce was creamy, sweet, savory and delicious. It came fresh and we were quite satisfied.
The last night of our stay we decided that it would be quite sentimental to order from the same restaurant as our first night. My only complaint would be that they do not offer seating/​tables inside/​outside. This place is a take out/​delivery pizza joint only. This was our first time coming inside. The area inside where you order is small but no problem. The have a case to the right of the cash register that displays several ready made pizzas that you can order by the slice or by the whole. If you order from this case they will pop your pizza in the oven so it’s nice and fresh for you. We ordered a whole pie so ours was super fresh. They have several large ovens inside and quite a few men working behind the counter. All gentlemen were nice and the wait wasn’t long at all. Pizza was sooooooooo gooooooooood! Can’t wait to return when we’re NYC again!

What a joke. This place is around the corner from my house and I Called at 11:44pm and pizza was delivered 1 hour and 40 minutes later.
When I called to ask status on the pizza ninety minutes into it «Zane or Zack» whatever manager name was he was a total asshole. Had one slice of the cold pizza and threw it in the trash where it belonged. Justinos turned out to be fifty bucks in the trash. Don’t waste your time or money.