Five Brother’s Pizza, Pasta & Grill

Decent Pizza, Decent prices. Run of the mill pizza place, close to my work so im stuck with it.

Probably the best pizza i’ve had in awhile. I have L&B Spumoni gardens by my house but they can be very expensive. One day decided to try Five Brothers because of their family specials. My hungry family agree that this is really great pizza. We’ve ordered from them several times already and its great every single time. We’ve tried the other family specials also and they’re all good. Love their sweet potato fries! yummmm!!!

Ordered at least 50 pizzas from this place. Always fast and delicious. Don’t listen to those Unilocalers who say service was bad. U not ordering room service at Bellagio. It’s gonna take some time. And how do you call any food crappy? I don’t know what crap taste like…
But seriously, this pizzeria is on point.
Some people like it some people don’t, but it doesn’t give u excuse to trash someone’s business. Take money from their pocket cuz u couldn’t keep your mouth shut

Might be one of the all time worst pizza spots in sheepshead. — chewy cheese — cold squares just not good at all

Honestly, I don’t know how anyone is complaining. I love this place.
Their Grandma slice is to die for and I always try to stop in an grab a slice.
Aside from that, their salmon salad is absolutely delicious, the calzones are always fresh when I order and taste delicious.
Deliveries are always on time, and the guys there are really nice.
I would recommend it definitely.

In this neighborhood it is hard to find good affordable food. And this place just adds to the crappy food options. I received the menu and thought it seemed like a good option. I ordered the large square pie and it was worse than if I bought frozen pizza from the supermarket. The sauce was lacking and the cheese was cheap. But there was plenty of bread! Soooo disappointed! The Garlic knots (actually bread with minced garlic poured on top-​no oil, no flavor) was equally disappointing. I won’t be ordering from here again. The delivery guy seemed nice but the guy on the phone had no decency at all when I told him our order was wrong. He just said «oh yea? Wow» I just had to laugh! Smh

First time ordering last time ordering!!! I came across their menu and decided to give it a try. I ordered a large Sicilian pie and some garlic knots. The order came fairly quick but that’s where anything good stops. Upon opening the pizza box I found all the cheese of the pizza stuck to the top of the box and when I called them to say so I was told «well what are you gonna do?»
What??? Is this how you speak to a customer? Especially a new customer that is not what your supposed to say. No sorry no nothing. The pizza that is there does no look at all edible even with the cheese it looks dry and nasty and it’s a rather small pie at that. The garlic knots are nothing more than dinner rolls with garlic and oil on them, they are horrible not even my son who would eat any bread in front of him cared to finish even one. Well lesson learned I am sorry to have even given this place a chance to begin with. I just hope anyone who decides to please read the reviews like I SHOULD have and hopefully read this review and stay clear of this place. Thanks

The absolute worst service I’ve ever had! I ordered fried calamari and Greek salad through Grubhub.
The order was delivered over an hour late. The «fried» calamari was cold and inedible. The Greek salad had avocados was close to rotten. When I called Five Brothers to complain about the order, their only excuse was that they were busy and cannot do anything about my order. I filed a complaint to GrubHub. The service rep at GrubHub called back to tell me that they have spoken with the owner and the owner refused to issue a refund and does not want to do anything about the order.
Beware of this place!!!

I really like their pizza. Good crust, great sauce anda good amount of cheese.
Their square is also delicious!
Other items from their menu worth a try are the hot hero subs. They are big decent portions on good bread with quality ingredients.
Their burgers, for a pizza place are also delicious.
I think it’s pretty obvious that I like this place.
The other big plus is that the guys working are always welcoming, no matter of they are on the phone or talking to you in person.
Try them. I’m surprised they don’t have more stars.

Decent neighborhood place. The guys that work here are nice. Not as much toppings variety as I would like, but I always come Sunday night so maybe there are more things earlier in the weekend. Would love buffalo or bbq chicken… Nice place to sit down eat pizza and watch soccer.

Every time i went in, it was always empty no matter what time of day it was. Even when I walk by I rarely see a customer. This should be a warning sign.
I eat here from time to time since it is close to me. Usually it is alright for its price. Recently I went in and had an order of omelets and pizza which was not worth it’s price anymore. The food quality had declined and so is their health regulations. I had a skimpy portion of potatoes and the toppings on the pizza was very little and died as if it was sitting their for a while. After the consumption of their «food» I had a stomach ache and felt unwell for a couple of days. I dont think i will be eating here for a while

I called this place for the 1^st time today. It’s so close to me, but I never heard of it til I went on MenuPages. I ordered the split pea soup, which was so good and filling that the Chicken Ceasar Salad I ordered will be my lunch for tomorrow. They sent these garlic ball thingies. I guess complimentary. They looked to bready for me… But the most exciting thing was it all came to $ 11.50… I felt like I stepped back into another decade LOL. Will try Italian dish next time and let U guys know how it goes
Debbie B.

I was extremely hungry and wanted a quick slice– I got a slice and 2 of their cheesy bread sticks (omg) yum!!!
I loved their pizza slice it was nice and simple and wasn’t overwhelming with sauce and what not!!!
There cheesy bread was my fav with the sauce on the side
I would deff come here again!!!

Sauce — My biggest complaint. A side order of sauce came with the garlic knots I ordered, and it smelled straight sour. Rancid. Tasted the same. Like sauce that was left to sit out for a few days, unrefrigerated.
Garlic knots — not garlicky. Bland dough with no flavor. The dough was soft — that’s the best I have to say about it. But otherwise, they were just mini bites of dough.
Regular slice — smelled like burnt plastic/​paint. Tasted the same. So much so that I spit out the one bite I took. Couldn’t eat more. Tried the crust alone, which tasted fine, so I’m pretty sure it’s either that rancid tasting sauce they use, or a combination of that and the cheese.
White slice — smelled just as bad as the plain slice, but tasted slightly better. The ricotta was actually quite tasty, and the mozzarella was of ok quality — I’ve certainly had worse. I threw some Tabasco on it, and was glad, because it helped me to actually enjoy it, by masking the awful smell.
BBQ chicken slice — The bottom of it was completely burnt. And I usually enjoy a slightly charred crust, but this was so blackened that it was inedible (see picture I took). That pizza shouldn’t have been sold to customers — it was completely ruined. I cut the bottom off to redeem what was left of the slice. The chicken was overpoweringly sweet, and everything else was bland. The dough was far too thick. I wouldn’t recommend it.
Beef patty — wasn’t as filled as I would’ve liked, and the crust was a bit on the mushy side — not flaky, but otherwise tasted quite good. One of the better items I purchased.
Spinach roll — like both pizza slices, had that burnt plastic/​paint smell. Also, they sprinkle the dough with sesame seeds, and though I’m normally a fan of them, I found that the flavor didn’t pair well with the sauteed spinach and cheese for some reason. But once I scraped the sesame seeds off, I must say, the spinach roll was *quite* good.
If I was starving, I’d go here for the spinach rolls and beef patties, but little else. I wouldn’t recommend getting anything here involving tomato sauce.
*Update* — It’s the morning after I ordered take-​out from Five Brother’s and I woke up with excruciating stomach pain. Can’t say if it was due to the food here, or not, (which is why I’m sticking with 2 stars instead of 1), but I can’t help but be reminded of the rancid smelling sauce from yesterday. I think it’s safe to say that I will most likely not be returning here, and certainly wouldn’t recommend this place.

They have a great menu selection, decided to give this pizza place a try for home delivery. After waiting for 40 minutes, I called and was told that my order was delivered (and accepted) by someone else. «Listen, I don’t know what to tell you…» they told me.
The thing is, they never even asked for my phone number when placing the order. I live five minutes away from this place. I’m guessing they didn’t have anyone to make the delivery or simply just forgot about the order.
In any case, I am never placing another order with this place again. Unreliable and unprofessional. What a joke!