Cassiano’s Pizzeria

Came by for a slice of pizza around noon on a week day. There was no line, which would normally scare me away, but I needed a quick lunch, the workers were friendly, and the pizza in the glass looked pretty good.
I got a deep dish slice and my lunch partner opted for the the thinner variety. We both agreed that the pizza was not heated enough and was nothing to write home about.
The place was pretty clean, which I appreciate. However, we won’t be coming back.

The pizza’s good. Honestly what more do you need?
I usually grab a slice to go and take it home with me. It’s not exactly the nicest place to sit down and have dinner. But I’m giving it 5 stars because the pizza quality genuinely fits the price.

Their pizza selection is great. Everything I ordered I loved. They’re a little pricey in my opinion but It is Midtown East. The actual restaurant could be fixed up a little, I usually take my food to go.

Meh pizza. I agree with another reviewer. Not bad, but I’ve had better. Semi-​stand-​offish attitude from guy behind the counter, could have just told me there was no bag in the trash disposal and that it was a chute to down below the restaurant rather than telling me there was a sign any idiot could see that read «garbage here». I came in a rush, and I’d come back if the pizza and attitude were good enough, but they’re just not. I don’t like my pizza a sloppy cheesy mess.

Really delicious plain slice – I ate two slices, and the next day, I craved this pizza, it was that yummy good.

I tried stopping at another place earlier that held some odd hours, and this ended up turning out to my benefit since I ended up here. This place has awesome Buffalo Chicken pizza. Nice thing is they are open late too. Bright sign was like a beacon in the night in the crappy weather. This place saved my night and my mood. Thanks fellas.

Absolutely delicious classic NY pizza. They put a great balance of cheese and sauce and I get the regular crust and it’s perfect not too thin. Me and my sisters order from here a lot and it doesn’t disappoint !

I was shocked how hard it was to find a late night pizza place in the city that never sleeps! And honestly it wasn’t even really that late, 11:00 on a Friday night. After a Yankee game, my boyfriend and I returned to the hotel just starving after getting stadium food earlier in the evening that was not that satisfying. Shocking, right? We tried to find a pizza place nearby and came up short since the majority were closed. A lady at our hotel said this would be open and luckily enough it was. Since we had wandered for a bit looking for a place to eat, we called before walking over and then we decided to just order for delivery.
Given that there are so many other options for pizza in the city, if others had been open I don’t know if we would have picked this one. But anyway, we landed on a large sausage pizza. It took a long time for it to be delivered. I think it actually arrived at 12:30. I don’t know how NY pizza is supposed to be but I would just rate this as decent. It had a thin crust that was nice on the outside but in the middle it was not substantial enough to hold the toppings. It had a nice sauce even though there really wasn’t much of it. The sausage was of the delicious, slightly spicy, sliced variety. It was not the sausage crumbles some pizza places use. It was not too greasy and curbed our late night craving.
My boyfriend only had one piece though. Knowing him, if it was fantastic he would make himself uncomfortable and force down two or three pieces. Nonetheless they get points from me for being open when we were hungry.

Really great pizza, fresh and crunchy. I recommend to everyone! Although I was Being generous with giving a tip, and they didn’t give me a refill for free…

Great pizza, expensive price. Has good specials from time to time. Used to have a special for $ 4.50 for any slice of pizza and cup of soup. The location is clean. Nothing special about the location; it meets the standards.

Came here when around this area for work. We had a nice meal here, but nothing special. Average for the area prices. I had a buffalo slice and a stuffed eggplant parm slice. The eggplant was tasty, but the center was luke warm at best. The buffalo was okay, but more like a hotsauce chicken slice.

Mozzarella pizza is good. but how the hell does the delivery mess up a pizza. Half the pizza had cheese the other pizza does not. Surely there is training for this???

The pizza was meh, but what really made this establishment a joke was the guy behind the counter. He was so rude! I ordered the special (2 slices + soda), but didn’t want the soda. I proceeded by rejecting the soda and my cost came out to be higher than the special. He insisted that I either pay more, or take the soda. I paid for the special and threw the drink straight into the dumpster.
I live a block away from this place, but will never come back here again.

Great pizza. Love the «local dive ambiance»!
Service was great as well. Definitely reasonably priced. If I lived here this would be a regular visit.

Everyone needs a dive-​y, no-​frills go-​to pizzeria in their neighborhood and I have found mine in midtown east near my office. Of course, there are nicer, better and more tourist-​attractive places you can go for the «best» pizza in New York but then you keep the real local New York pizza joints for yourself. I was out doing a Duane Reade run and decided to pick up lunch to bring back to my desk. I actually tried 2 other places, one of which was closed and the other one had a funky smell so walked down the block to Cassiano’s, my 3^rd choice. I decided on spaghetti and meatballs, nothing more Italian (or actually Sicilian) than that! I walked past what looked like 10 different kinds of pizza pies on display looking pretty interesting but I was bent on getting my spaghetti. I am usually not a pasta person. I prefer rice as my starch of choice but today I wanted this and glad I did. The spaghetti was already cooked but the guy reheated it vigorously in the pan with the sauce like a pro. He ladled 3 whole meatballs on top of the piping hot pasta and the order was handed over to me in 2 minutes. This kind speediness is very important for those in a hurry which is all of us in New York. The portion is too much for the average eater. I ate half and will have the leftover tomorrow. Not bad for $ 8.50! Admittedly, the pasta is nothing special but i think the meatballs and sauce are homemade and tasty enough. Sometimes old school places like these are called for especially in a neighborhood where it’s hard to get anything under $ 10. For me, it’s even more economical because I split it over 2 meals.

The pizza is amazing, the guys are really nice and the place is kept clean. Making this my new pizza place in the city ! Also had the penne a la vodka, the sauce was great but the pasta not to much. Defiantly will be coming back

If you are into deep-​dish pizza, this is your place in Upper East Side. This is one of few places I’ve found this pizza. The dough isn’t buttery though, or unfortunately, for me. I tried the thin Margherita and it was delicious and you can feel the fresh tomato chunks of the sauce. The deep-​dish Ranch, Chicken Bacon was good, but I’d like it tastier. The Teriyaki and Buffalo look like their specialty. Definetely, the cashier is indeed very handsome and love to talk about baseball. Looks like an Italian pizzamaker taken freshly from the Boot. The place look like any other lunch cafeteria, although it open in 2013.

Yup. This place is divey — but clean. And no, I can just tell that some of the food here is supermarket quality type food — like the salads and fries.
However, I called in while working on a project in a friend’s office and they told me that delivery was 40 mins. But pick up was 20 minutes. I decided to walk there, in the rain and pick up my burger. It was big, medium rare bloody and speckled with a bit of grease. It was delicious. What made it better was that the cashier, a nice tall dude, offered me a free drink because I braved the pouring rain just to pick this food up and I opted for the cappuccino. Again, not the best quality but the thought counts and it was actually good (3 stars).
Apparently what to get is the pizza, so that’s what I’m opting for next time I order from this spot.

Ordered delivery for a bad weather kinda day. 10 wings with BBQ sauce on the side, calamari, garlic knots, 14″ Margarita with spicy chicken and bacon, 2 liter sprite. Feeds up to 4 or 5 people. Everything was delicious! All the side orders had sauces. Prices are fair and food arrived in a timely manner.
Tip: ask them to cut up the pizza into slightly smaller slices.

It was about 1:30 am and we were hungry after 10 hrs of flight delays and cancelations. We stumbled upon this pizza spot and were pleasantly surprised that they were not only open, but had a plethora of pizza options ready for our bellies.
Pizza was really cheesy, service was friendly and prices were fair for midtown. I love that they’re open until 4 am for late night grub. Oh, and they have little bottles of wine, so that was a huge plus! We’ll be back!