Nottingham Inn

I am a regular here, so I maybe biased, but on the other hand I’m a regular here because the food here is delicious and the staff here is phenomenal.
The meals here all feel home cooked, everything is cooked from scratch. The breakfast is amazing and the lunch and dinner menu will both feel like grandma is cooking. Definitely of the comfort food variety.
I mostly go here for breakfast and get my huge pancakes, or the delicious French toast, but I do like getting dinner here as well. The menu never gets boring, in fact the most interesting meal, is the meal of the day. They always put some wild experimental meal that is always delicious that changes from breakfast to lunch. So I am never bored there. They have hand picked microbrews and delicious desserts which includes the ice cream from their creamery.
Long story short, place may be small, but it is cozy and friendly. The food is terrific and never boring. It is definitely worth a try if you are passing by or if you live in an area and are looking for a new go to spot. Cheers!

Friendly and Helpful Staff — They messed my order up & actually insisted that they pay for my burger; that was very friendly. For that — I have to give them 4 Stars — Burger was really good; fresh ingredients. We were very Happy with the experience!

Opted for this place after we did the Herr’s tour. Apparently Herr’s owns this place. With a name like Nottingham Inn, I was expecting a fancy old place. What we found instead was a confusing parking lot with a large old building up front and the restaurant tucked away in the back right corner. A little confusing.
Anyway, on to the meat and potatoes of the review!!!
I had the open face Angus roast beef with fries. Wife had the chicken salad, son had a burger. They boast that the scraps from the plant are fed to the beef that is used at the Inn. My meal was great, nice big portion and tender as a wet tissue. Fries were fresh cut. Perfect meal for a rainy day. Wife enjoyed hers, said the salad was seasoned good and fresh. I could not see any burger left, so I will assume the young lad enjoyed his burger.
Place is not fancy, looks like an old cabin inside. Seating is crowded, but the food was tasty, place was clean, price was right.
One of the owners of Herr’s sat next to us, my wife recognized him from the tour video. I wanted to get a selfie with him, but she would not let me. :-(
After that meal, she drove home, I was sleeping by the time we hit honeybrook! Zzzzzzzz

We go to the Nottingham in every now and then. Never once have we been disappointed. The food is really good, the service is excellent and the value is totally reasonable. Tonight I had the chicken Oscar which was new to the menu, it was delicious. I would definitely order it again. My husband ordered the shrimp stirfry. He thought it was really good but probably would not order it again. We sat at the counter across from the kitchen and saw so many meals that we would like to try.

Just had the worst meal ever at this restaurant. The food was passable, the service as always was exceptional, but what I was served was insultingly over-​priced and pathetically under-​portioned. I ordered the open-​faced meatloaf sandwich platter. It was supposed to come on Texas toast, with hand-​cut fries on the side. The meatloaf couldn’t even be considered a child’s portion. Three tiny pieces maybe ½ thick at best, and when I put them all together on the plate, it was about the diameter of a baseball. The «Texas toast» wasn’t toasted at all, and as far as I could tell, it was just plain old potato bread. The fries were good, tho. In fact, the cooks must pride themselves on their fries, because they took up over half the platter! No doubt to make up for the sadly lacking meatloaf. What did I pay for this meal? $ 11.95! For fries, bread, and a teeny little piece of meatloaf. What a RIP. OFF. Looking for a nice place to have lunch? Don’t waste your money here.

We tried the restaurant out for breakfast today and I am now going to be a regular. The casual and nicely decorated décor is equally matched by the quality of the food. Server was very nice and you can tell this is a well run family business.

I’ve been here for breakfast and lunch so far in the past few months. Both meals were exceptional and, I think, fairly priced. The staff was friendly and helpful and the restaurant was very clean and well put-​together.
I would have preferred that my meal came with fries rather than Herr’s chips, and would have preferred draft beer over bottles, but these are small complaints. The beer I ordered has actually become a new favorite!
I’ll be back for sure!

Just had a late breakfast at Nottingham Inn with my boyfriend. If you are in the area, I suggest you stop in. The place is very clean and charming. The staff were very sweet and welcoming when we walked in. The food was excellent and served fast. I will definitely be returning! Also the coffee was good, and that’s important! :) 5 stars!

Pork tenderloin was delicious as was the sautéed shrimp special. This place is very charming we will be back again

Friendly and attentive staff. Sunday after 9 usually has 20 min wait. Fast paced. Would like to see more specials with fresh local fruit or vegetables

The Nottingham Inn never disappoints! Today we went in to find a new menu and I finally decided on the Tortellini Salad since I wasn’t exactly starving. The serving portion was large and very reasonably priced! The flavor was fantastic and if you like feta cheese, it’s a must try! I would definitely order this again and my husband also gave it a thumbs up. I was pretty full after the salad but after seeing the dessert menu I couldn’t pass up trying the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cake. (So much for not being that hungry when I walked in) I enjoyed it and didn’t leave a crumb but my husband ordered the warm blueberry pie with ice cream and it was amazing! My husband and I have been here quite a few times now and have always left 100 percent satisfied! The service is always great and the food is always so fresh and flavorful! This is truly one of our favorite spots!
I will also add that their menu selection isn’t huge but they seem excel at everything they make and their prices are very affordable!

Ok, so tonight my wife and I stopped in for dinner. We were sat immediately (just like always) and greeted by a very friendly waitress. I ordered the fish and chips. It came quickly and was delicious. Three big pieces of lightly breaded haddock, coleslaw, and seasoned fries. The tarter sauce and lemon really pulled the meal together. After the meal I knew I should have called it quits because I was full but I didn’t stop there. I ordered the blueberry pie with a scoop of vanilla. It was so good. The pie was served warm but was still firm. I felt like I needed to be wheeled out of there after consuming these delightful vittles. Don’t worry, I managed to make it to my vehicle safely and I’m currently laying in a vegetative state on the couch. I can’t wait to head back there. Check it out.

Stopped for a quick dinner. Food was delicious! I got the meatloaf and mashed potato dinner. My son got the tree cheese tortellini. Both were super good. Loved the gravy on the mashed potatoes. Just sorry we didn’t save room for the homemade blueberry pie, which looked amazing. If you come on a Friday night get there early. The place fills up fast. Plenty of parking.

The Nottingham doesn’t have a very big menu so there isn’t much to choose from. But the burgers are good and the sandwiches are tasty. The service was really good. There is also a separate ice cream shop that is open during the summer. That part has an outdoor area so if you just wanted ice cream you could bring your dog and enjoy.

Great for lunch, all the sandwiches are good loved the hot chicken buffalo sandwich and the sweet potato fries. Quality food, very efficient service!

Excellent food service. We always enjoy this little breakfast spot. A GREAT way to start a sunday.

Our server Raquel was amazing. Kind, attentive and willing to make things up special according to what you like.

Been here many times for breakfast and a few times for dinner. Service is always excellent. Food is always good. Do yourself a favor and have the Fried Chicken Dinner.
It may be a small place but it’s big on taste.

We love it here! Best breakfast, best dinner and best desserts! The service is outstanding! Great atmosphere, very cozy.

I have been a few times now and this is my new favorite spot. Every dish has been delicious snd the staff is awesome! Big shout out to emily she has been my waitress before and I saw her last time and she has such a bright personality shes great. everyone we have met has been great. Food is so good even desserts that r mouth watering