Tu valoración: 5 Town of Hempstead, Long Island, NY
Love the tri-color cookies. I never liked them until I ate them here. Also love love love the jelly filled croissants rolled in sugar — to die for. A bit pricey but worth every penny.
Sarah H.
Tu valoración: 5 Staten Island, NY
Amazing!!! The artistry, the culinary skill all rolled into one! His cake creation was a surprise as a part of a party we held this summer — I sent in the artwork and we discussed the different options. We communicated mostly via email or on the phone — but everything was flawless! The cake was delicious and the surprise was well received ! Ps, I highly recommend Oreo cookie filling!
Afia A.
Tu valoración: 5 Bellmore, NY
Had two cakes made for my sister’s and my birthdays and they were just perfect, it was the highlight of the party and tasted even better! Plus their service and pricing are a great bonus
Theresa M.
Tu valoración: 5 Merrick, NY
Had a cake made for my husband’s birthday. Absolutely delicious and decorated just as I asked.
Gail G.
Tu valoración: 5 Wantagh, NY
This place is AMAZING!!! The cupcakes, brownies and cookies are like the old time baked goods. Like a pro grandma would make. Incredible! But that magic cookie is ridiculously good. Love this place.
Elyse Y.
Tu valoración: 5 Malverne, NY
We asked, and Cake Gallery delivered! Absolutely gorgeous cake that well exceeded our expectations in appearance and taste! We had a rather elaborate cake in mind. It was executed beautifully. It was the centerpiece of our daughter’s first birthday party(after our daughter of course). Highly recommend Cake Gallery for the specialty cakes.
Norma C.
Tu valoración: 5 Islip, NY
Best cookies and cream cake ever! Cake pops and rainbow cookies are the best around! A lil pricey though… but goooood stuff!
Christian D.
Tu valoración: 5 Merrick, NY
This is a neighborhood spot for myself and I must say everything I’ve tried is absolutely delicious. BUT nothing beats the jelly croissants. If you haven’t had them it’s a MUSTTRY. It’s seriously a piece of heaven in your mouth.
Raven R.
Tu valoración: 4 HOWARD BEACH, NY
Thank you Tom for a wonderful and professional experience with your shop. Our wedding cake was absolutely beautifully done and everyone complimented the flavor!
Christina B.
Tu valoración: 5 Bellmore, NY
Cakes are moist, decorated to perfection, and worth every penny! Their irish soda bread is the best i’ve ever had. I love the cookies and cupcakes as well! More recently I had the croissants filled with jelly, fried and dusted with cinnamon sugar. ADDICTIVE!
Glenn S.
Tu valoración: 5 Farmingdale, NY
I recommend this bakeshop if you want that old time bakery. A taste that I haven’t encountered in years… Growing up my Grandfather who was an old time German baker would bring treats home for me. Especially those giant chocolate chip cookies. Since his retirement I have been searching years for a bakeshop that made that same cookie. You can tell as soon as you walk in, that wonderful smell of quality baked goods. ANDYES that chocolate chip cookie is made exactly the way I remember it. If your in the neighborhood stop in and have a cookie you wont be sorry. You will know what I’m talking about once you step foot in this bakeshop.
Paul F.
Tu valoración: 5 Bellmore, NY
The best cakes on long island. So moist and delicious. They may seem a little pricy, but worth every penny. We use them for every family members birthday. Never any left overs either. Huge hit every time. Has never said No to our last minute requests.
Lisa E.
Tu valoración: 4 Westbury, NY
This is a small but ambitious upscale bake shop and custom cake maker. The web site displays a vast amount of cakes created for many occasions… from baby showers to retirement. They seem to be able to tackle any theme and many price points. Extremely creative, but if you read the reviews, everyone raves over the taste and quality as well as the gorgeous appearence of the cakes. Their brownies are rich and delicious but there are two other really special things that i have found… jelly rolls, I guess I can call them… oblong beauties filled with jelly(or plain) and rolled in sugar… and another cookie that resembles a huge lace cookie with an amazing chocolate(ganache ??) layer between 2 cookies. Hard to describe, but really great… so go in and try something and then try to write about it !!!
Jenny S.
Tu valoración: 5 Nassau, NY
This website features beautiful cakes and creations, but their cookies and pastries are amazing! The small but immaculate bakery smells of butter and sugar the second you open their door. The chocolate chip cookies are so good my hubby almost weeps when eats them. I always stop there before heading to a holiday dinner because their offerings are always beautiful, creative and incredibly delicious!