Jersey Mike’s Subs

I’ve been to Jersey Mikes many times and I pretty much get the same thing. #9 mike’s way no tomato. Every store that I’ve been to has consistently made the sandwich the same and I love that they slice the meat fresh in front of you. Cuts down on the feeling that you might get sick from meat sitting out to long.
Only gripe is how hard they try to sell you the combo. I had a guy at the New Lenox location ask me like six times if I wanted chips and a drink.

I love this place. They know my name they know my sandwich just makes me feel like I’m at home. Friendly crew awesome Subs

Food is good, service is fast, employees are friendly and accommodating. Eating area is clean. I think that’s pretty much what anyone could expect from fast food. Also, bathroom was clean.

Always fresh! The meat the buns and I NEVER get sick from eating there like when I eat at Subway. Everything looks very clean. Today 1÷12÷16 everyone was so friendly and nice, excellent staff!!!

I will say one of the managers is very pleasant every time I visit this location. Always cracking jokes and very interactive. It seems decently clean and well kept.
My dad received a sandwich the other day that had hair in it. He called and a different manager than explained above, offered him a full refund of our entire meal. When my dad got there yesterday afternoon the manager only refunded him for half of the meal. He appreciated it but it was kind of ruined both of our appetites and was a waste of both of our meals that ended up in the trash.
Considering how expensive this sub place is compared to others in the area it was a let down.

Love this place. The worker are friendly and know how to give you a good laugh. The food is fresh and prepared right in front of you. The sweet tea is pretty good. You can either get it mikes way or your own way. Shop is clean and organized.

My go to sub shop. I like the #5 swap the ham to turkey Mikes way minus onion. Staff is curious and shop is clean. Buy the SIAM discount card from the high school and you get a chip and drink for free. Rewards members get points and go towards offers.

Always #7 Mike’s Way… Taste’s Terrific Every Time! This place is clean, the people are energetic and friendly, and the food is fantastic! What else can be said!

Jersey mikes is always pretty great. They are consistently clean and the staff is always friendly. The food is pretty delicious too. I have only had the tuna as I am a fish-​only eater but it’s always been good. Try your sandwich «the mikes way»!! I can’t off the top of my head remember what the ingredients are… but I get it every time.
4 stars for no meatless choices.

Good subs (too much lettuce). Owner was really nice. Way overpriced though. $ 26 for 3 subs and chips… w/​o drinks? I’ll make my own sub next time.

So with all the positive reviews, I decided to try this place as I was craving a fresh sub. It was nice and clean, there was no line, and the staff was friendly so I was initially pleased. I’m not sure the slicing of deli meat to order adds any value or quality to the sandwich except for taking more time to assemble your basic sub.
My turkey was of the pressed variety and the provolone looked pretty sad. I got it Mike’s way, which was lettuce, onion, tomato, oil, vinegar, salt & pepper. I ordered a «mini» sized sub (which I think was 4 inches) and a small drink, and I got a buck and change from a 10 spot. Really???
I was starving, but after taking my first and second bites and only tasting the double mound of cold shredded lettuce, I wrapped up my sandwich and took off. I will admit, the next day there was a bit more flavor as the oil and vinegar was able to permeate all those bits of greens (like a coleslaw) but I wasn’t after a salad on a roll. I have no idea if Mike’s other offerings had more potential. In the end, it didn’t really matter as I won’t be coming back.

Jersey Mike’s impressed me more than I thought it would. Upon entering and looking at the menu, it looked like another Jimmy John’s or a glorified Subway. Nonetheless, I decided to give it a shot
I got a #2 (Jersey Shore Favorite) on wheat with lettuce, tomatoes, onion, oil, vinegar, oregano, and salt. It seemed like their flagship sub, and I figured that if this wasn’t good, then there’s no need to come back.
The staff was friendly upon ordering. The process was slower than anticipated, but the group ahead of me had a lot of demands so I won’t hold it against the staff. The restaurant itself had some cool decorations and nods to their Jersey origins.
I took a bite of the sub and I was hooked. The ratio of oil, vinegar, oregano, and salt was perfect. And the wheat bread was delicious.
If I’m back near a Jersey Mike’s when hunger strikes, I’ll be there.

This was my first (then the next day, second) visit to a Jersey Mike’s and I was not disappointed. All the staff was VERY fast, professional, polite, and personable. It was nice being helped by someone who seemed like they actually wanted to be there. When I went there my second time, there was a LONG line (last day of a big promotion) and the slicer went down — uh oh. Two employees swapped it out within 90 seconds — it was impressive to see. You can tell they are trained very well, good employees who enjoy their job. The food was also very good. Little higher price point than other quick sub joints, but for the quality of service it is worth it in my opinion.

It’s great! Beats subway hands down. The subs are always fresh and tasty. Not too pricey either. One of the shift manager dude is a little annoying, but otherwise we love it!

This was my first time trying any Jersey Mikes, not just this location. On the plus side, the staff was friendly, the place was clean, and my sandwich had a good flavor. I also liked that they have diet Dr Pepper in addition to diet Pepsi. Although my gluten-​free husband wasn’t with me, I was pleased to notice they acknowledge the gluten-​free issue, even if it was only by offering subs in a salad format rather than on bread. Negatives: I thought the food was overpriced. My regular cheesesteak and small drink was just under $ 10. The amount of meat in comparison to the size of the bread was very skimpy. With increasing numbers of people being diagnosed with gluten related health issues, they really should look into adding some gluten-​free bread to their menu. All-​in-​all, I will probably stop in again and try one of their cold subs but I wouldn’t bother with the skimpy cheese steak again.

This was the first time I’d ever been to Jersey Mike’s, and I’m hooked.
Went here on Sunday afternoon around noon. We were immediately greeted by the manager and other staff. The staff is super friendly. They explained the menu to us since we were newbies and were helpful. I ordered a Philly steak and the husband ordered a Philly chicken. Everything was made fresh to order. No pre-​measured slices of cheese or paper trays of steak here (I’m looking at you, Subway). Food was out to order about 5 minutes after we paid.
Bread was fresh, meat was tasty, and that melty cheese… I’m drooling just thinking about it.
The only reason I’m giving it 4 stars is for the price. I’d likely not go here without a coupon. Philly was around $ 7 just for the sandwich, and while I don’t mind paying a premium for fresh ingredients, it’s still a bit on the high side for me.
But as soon as I get another coupon, I’m there.

Good subs, but not enough to justify the egregious prices. C’mon, it’s a sub sandwich, not Chateaubriand.

Employees are extremely friendly! We were glad when they opened to try something new in town. I love how fresh everything is. Longer lines but it happens being new in town. Store has been clean every time we’ve been in. They can also customize a sandwich if you don’t see it on their menu. Will definitely be back to try more on the menu!

Eat at your own risk!
Someone just had there wallet stolen when i was here and they have NO CAMERAS!
Been here 25 minutes and still no police!!!
Music is way to loud.
Staff is VERY disorganized
Sad representation of jersey mikes since all others ive been too were awesome.
Sandwich was still good, after i told them the proper way to make it mikes way.

I’d never been to this sub chain before, so when one opened in New Lenox I had to try them out and see how they compared to Jimmy John’s. I played it safe for my first visit and ordered the No. 7 (turkey breast and provolone) on wheat bread. The bread is very crisp and crusty, the meat is sliced in front of you in deli-​thin slices, and all of the toppings are fresh. And the employees are super-​friendly; they must hire them for their outgoing personalities.
The only reason I didn’t give Jersey Mike’s five stars is because I ordered my sub with «everything,» by which I meant pickles, hot peppers, and all of the other toppings they had displayed. But when I got home, I discovered they had only made it «Mike’s Way,» the standard topping of lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, and spices which is included on every cold sub at Jersey Mike’s. It was still a very tasty sandwich, and I probably should have watched while they made it so I could have told them exactly what I wanted. But still, doesn’t «everything» usually mean. .. well, everything?
No matter. Jersey Mike’s still whips up a mean sub and I plan on coming back here soon to try the Club Supreme or the Grilled Pastrami Reuben. I’ll just make sure I tell them EXACTLY which extras I want!