I definitely should have read the other Unilocal reviews before I ate here. The service was polite and speedy but the food was disappointing. I ordered the chicken alfredo and a large drink. It came with two pieces of garlic bread. The serving size was so big that I could have easily shared with a second person. However, the dish was mostly noodles with far too little sauce and a tiny amount of chicken. It really seemed like they filled a fairly large dish with dry noodles then just sauced very lightly on top. The actual sauce was about on par with the quality served at Fazioli’s. The garlic bread was very sweet tasting. I didn’t enjoy the pasta or garlic bread at all and threw both away after just a few bites. Overall I probably would have been happier going to Fazioli’s and paying about the same amount for more sauce on my dish and better garlic bread.
Erin B.
Tu valoración: 4 Mooresville, IN
Tasty spaghetti. Hubby and I dined here for a quick, inexpensive bite. This place didn’t disappoint. The spaghetti and meatballs had a great flavor in both the sauce as well as the two meatballs that came with it. I did like the bread, however, I would have preferred it to be toasted rather than soft. It was still very good. Just my preference. Would return if in the area again.
Dana L.
Tu valoración: 3 New Albany, IN
Just quick and cheap fast food Italian. Nothing special but it’ll do in a bind. I like the garlic bread and you get free refills. They can go light on the spaghetti sauce but when I request extra, it’s never a problem. Just quick and convenient.
Kristie T.
Tu valoración: 3 Jeffersonville, IN
Ok, my kids just said«This is the first time we have heard you say you didn’t like something»… When we walked in, there was a sign saying they were out of Alfredo. Greeeeat. Since I’m not fond of marinara the next best thing was shrimp scampi. It was dry and burned. They liked their cheese bread pizza ok and it was only $ 3 something and came with garlic bread and drinks so… The menu said it came with a treat, but they didn’t get a treat and we didn’t realize it until we got home. I was hoping their previous reviews were wrong. :(
Sean L.
Tu valoración: 1 Sellersburg, IN
It’s cheap, as in money. That’s the best I can say. The carryout we bought tonight was cold, flavorless, and could not have tasted more processed.
Jacquelyn S.
Tu valoración: 1 Sellersburg, IN
I have been avoiding this place b/c to pay those prices for basic Italian is ridiculous. But today being a lazy Sunday, and didn’t feel like cooking and pasta sounded like good comfort food, I broke down an went. I tried the Sampler so that way I could get a taste of a few items… for take out… WOW… big mistake!!! Lasagna tasted worse than frozen food isle. Pasta sauce was bland and Alfredo was gross garlic mess. The garlic sweet bread was burnt on outside and soggy in the center! Won’t ever go back!!!
Amanda W.
Tu valoración: 2 Palmdale, CA
Italian food? Really? It tasted like the skyline chilli’s spaghetti in Ohio. And the garlic bread is terrible, no garlic, perhaps just a powder spice and it was soggy? Well, I suppose you get what you pay for. Baked Ravioli was not all that great, my son usually eats all his food but he left more than a half of his plate, that is just abnormal. When I came back from Europe, one and the only place served close to the actual Italian food was in Pasadena, California somewhere. I cannot remember the name of the restaurant but I will try to think hard and write a review.
Richard C.
Tu valoración: 3 Tucson, AZ
We have eaten here three times and the food is good and prices are fair. The restaurant is clean, service is fast. The four grandkids that we’ve brought here love it. Two of them like to have their pasta plain with no sauce, just cheese and they are completely satisfied. They offer all the traditional Italian fare: spaghetti, lasagna, chicken alfredo, subs, fresh garlic bread and various salads. They also offer kids-eat-free one night a week with every adult entrée ordered. You can get family meals as carry out to make an inexpensive delicious healthy dinner to take home after a busy day at work. A great place for a filling meal for the family at a reasonable price. A meal everyone will enjoy while giving mom a night off from cooking.
Jerry P.
Tu valoración: 2 New Albany, IN
Ok for fast Italian. It was much better before it moved. Our family went there often, but not much anymore.
Sydney R.
Tu valoración: 5 New Albany, IN
The Spaghetti Shop is absolutely one of my favorite restaurants! I eat there often and I have yet to try something on their menu that was less than delicious! My favorite items are the Spaghetti Sub, Uncle Louie Sub, and Baked Alfredo! Not only is the food great, but the service is pleasant and the meals are priced reasonably. I am recently aware that they CATER to office events and parties, I cannot wait to explore that option as well.
Mike D.
Tu valoración: 2 New Albany, IN
Not that I expect much from a fast food Italian place, but they really set the bar low here. I waited about 15 min for a sandwich that was just OK and Italian fries that were burnt. The location is good and the restaurant is nice and clean, but its just not going to cut it when there are so many other options. Italy would give this place the boot.