Their pizza is about average but the reasons for the low stars is that they only occasionally actually«deliver» since there is usually only one person working, and they can’t deliver– their hours stink and it is FAR from authentic NY Pizza. Very far. I have tried and tried to give them a chance to redeem themselves but they fail over and over. Sorry guys.
Nic R.
Tu valoración: 1 Rockford, IL
Absolutely by far the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Was not hot and delicious, the cardboard box would have been more appetizing with a little sauce on it! The people who rated it five stars must be either fake or friends told what to write. Ordered all sausage and half green pepper, received all sausage. I then called them to make sure I received the correct one and she told me «oh it’s the right one», with no offer to fix the problem! No one in there sane mind should have given one star let alone five. What a huge disappointment!
W L B.
Tu valoración: 4 Naples, FL
First time here. Ordered a large pepperoni and a small white. Both were delicious. Lots of great tasting pepperoni. Very pleasantly surprised!!! The white was excellent also. Definitely will be back to try more items. Thanks Tracy for the background story. The name says To Go but they do have seating.
Jess S.
Tu valoración: 5 Miami, FL
The Pizza is cheesy and saucy. Employees are friendly and knowledge. They deliver locally. I would return soon.
James L.
Tu valoración: 5 Naples, FL
Gatsbys is the best homemade pizza in Florida; finally a thin brick oven crust with a great taste and fresh ingredients. The pepperoni is the best tasting I have ever had. Cheers to Gatsbys To Go
Christine L.
Tu valoración: 5 Naples, FL
The best pizza around; love the pepperoni and thin crust. Also, the square cut is perfect.