Andy’s Susie’s Too & AJ’s Ice Cream

I have always liked the friendly local feeling of Andy’s. It a nice stop of ice cream. Tonight when we went in, the entire place spelled like warm waffled which is fantastic! I was disappointed because they were out of A LOT of the ice creams. I am hoping they get them in soon!

Mission accomplished! While my nephew was visiting, we had a goal of finding the best milkshake in Naples. On his last day here, I randomly pulled out my phone, and, thanks to the wonder of Unilocal,I found this place. A place I drive be regularly and have never even noticed. Could this diner/​ice cream joint really have a 5 star milkshake!!! YES!!! It’s true.
The restaurant is divided into a diner on one side and ice cream parlor on the other side. It is located at the Public strip mall on the corner of 41 & Thomasson/​Rattlesnake Hammock on the end closest to Culver’s. You enter through the ice cream side because surely they want to taunt you with looking at all the ice cream before you take a seat in the diner. They do have seating on the ice cream side too if that’s all you are coming for. Our server had a cute and bubbly personality and a few other girls checked on us too during a visit – they were all really nice.
I went for the soup & sandwich combo – I chose the pastrami reuben and chili. As the mission was for shakes, I ordered a chocolate peanut butter milkshake. My nephew Is sprouting into quite the foodie, even at 10 years old. He ordered a burger medium rare with cheese, bacon, and an egg over easy along with a chocolate milkshake. Before I focus on the shake, I will say that this reuben was absolutely delicious. They must use some sort of secret amazing sauerkraut to make it this good. If I never even knew about the shake, I would have still left happy. The shake came out in a traditional old-​time milkshake glass with one of those mega wide straws. I will never forget that first slurp! WOW! This is what a shake should be! My nephew quickly agreed that it was the best shake and it beat all of the other ones he liked. The Shake Shop has nothing on these guys.
I left the diner as the best and coolest aunt ever! I will most certainly be back. I did take off a star because we came close to shift change so at the end of the meal, we waited and waited and finally had to get up and ask for our check. Everyone had disappeared to the back. Also, things weren’t as tidy in there as they should be which I suspect was due to the Sunday breakfast rush.

Super nice servers. Big menu. Good tasting food. Popular place with the locals for good reason! Unique almond oatmeal honey French toast. Kielbasa omelette would have been better with real cheese. Great service that kept the coffee coming and ice tea glass full

I had breakfast here with my family. Everyone order different things off the menu. On the menu its states in omelette section egg omelette with cheese bacon or sausage $ 8.25…
Waitress asked if I wanted the bacon in the omelette I said no. She forgot to mentioned it would cost me $ 3.75 for burnt bacon…
A $ 15.00 breakfast I could of gone to Lakewood golf club for a beautiful brunch of fresh

Well this place has the best milkshakes in Naples, well the service was great she was nice and she knew what she was doing. The food was great my burger and fries were good. But the highlight was the milkshake my chocolate milkshake was so good, they has a perfect amount of chocolate. I will definitely come back I would recommend this to everyone!

We always stop by this place when we are in town. Delicious home cooking, great service and comfortable atmosphere. My last time through, I had a cheese burger with french fries and a chocolate milkshake. The hamburger was cooked perfectly and was served with two thick tomato slices and crisp lettuce.

Amazing place! Love to come here on the weekends for their breakfast menu. Their omelet are delicious. Any of their ice creams are great but my favorite is the coconut. Easily one of the best places in town.

Fantastic and friendly service. We are from out of town but were welcomed with a genuine smile! They were fast with hot coffee and kept it coming.
The food was excellentI had a club sandwich with crispy bacon on a very nice and fresh gourmet tasting white bread. The meats were plentiful and high quality. The lettuce was fresh, dark green, and crisp. The tomatoes were flavorful and tasted like they were locally grown.
My lady had a breakfast skillet. She really like it and the portion was generous.
If your looking for breakfast or lunch in Naples, this is the place!

The coconut ice cream was the best I have ever tasted. They have a large vatiety of flavors and you can taste a sample of any flavor you desire.

Great food, great service! Had a Benedict and country fried skillet — huge portions and very good. From CT and picky about breakfast.

The milkshake was one of the best I’ve had! They make it from any of their ice cream flavors. I had the country Benedict which was decent. I would’ve liked more gravy — enough to cover both biscuits, not jusy one.
I give this place 4 stars because they auto grat 20% for a party of one. I had a groupon and I know gratuity isn’t included. I personally always tip 20−30% (of the original bill) depending on how stellar the service is. But this auto grat is odd to me and somewhat insulting. If it was declared beforehand then I wouldn’t have minded. They just lost another 10% on their tip.
Having worked in the service industry I completely understand not everyone understands how to tip. Especially, in naples, where the demographic is more mature and what worked for them then may not work now. Regardless, you just got to suck it up and do your job well. If you must auto grat then state it up front on a sign or something of 15 — 18%. 20% is uncalled for.

GREAT SERVICE AND STAFF! My companion had coconut shrimp of which she considers herself a connoisseur and she said it was some of the best she’d ever had and the pineapple salsa served with it was fantastic. My burger was cooked perfectly and the sides were amazingly good. I have been back many time since my first trip and I highly recommend it,

Huge portions! My husband had cabbage roll soup and meatloaf for dinner. He said both were delicious, and he’s got leftovers for tomorrow. I had a Reuben; the corn beef was good — not the type you get in a grocery store! My sandwich was large enough that I also have a ½ sandwich left over for tomorrow. Service was quick and accommodating! Will definitely return!

Best omelet I have ever had, fresh fresh fresh. Service is great and staff are friendly.

I live near this place and never went to try it out for years. About 8 months ago I was in a hurry and decided to go for a meal in a hurry. I saw liver and onions on the menu and asked to have it prepared in a certain way and they obliged very willingly. It had to be probably the best I ever had to the point that I have been a customer once or twice a week ever since. I also guide a Neighborhood Dinner Party and arrainged to meet there also. We had 19 that night and didn’t get a complaint from any of them but rather had suggestions that we go to places like that more often. Over the months this place has become almost like a family spot for me because I know all of the names of the servers, chefs and owners and their friendly and efficient attitude to us when we come in. It has to be the best American Cooking in Naples.

I’m visiting the area and did a charter fishing and caught a bunch of fish. I love that they allowed me to bring in my fresh caught fish and they fried it for me. They did an excellent job and provided fries and coleslaw for a nominal cost. The ice cream shop has delicious ice cream. We’re planning to go back and finish off the rest of our catch.

Wir kennen Suzies Too schon vom Davis Boulevard. Dort war das Frühstück schon mal sehr gut. Jetzt ist es nicht mehr so zentral aber es nach wie vor hervorragend. Sehr freundliche Bedienung und große Portionen sowie gute Auswahl.

My girlfriends father and grand father have been regulars for a while, always heading here after a early round of golf. We had no idea, and just happened by and stopped for breakfast one morning. We were blown away by the service, food and prices. Don’t be fooled by the location in a strip mall, this could be a hoping breakfast and lunch joint in the middle of 5^th Ave.
I am addicted to the Meat Lover’s Skillet and have stopped in for breakfast at least one day every weekend for the past month (add jalapeños for a nice kick). My girlfriend has had the pancakes, which were amazing and the size of a plate, as well as the French toast which is also extremely tasty.
We also always get a half order of biscuits and gravy, which is just like mom made. Be sure to ask for the biscuit grilled, you’ll be happy you did.
To make a good food experience even better, the staff at Susie’s are attentive, friendly, and genuinely care about your experience there. After just 3 visits they knew us by name and greated us warmly. You just can’t ask for more from a restaurant.

Our family ate dinner here lastnight, figured it would be more of a burger place, boy was i wrong. I ordered their chicken caccuri. Omg it was amazing!!! Service was amazing as well! Wish i could remember or servers name! Great food, great service, very clean! We’ll be back for sure!

We chose this eatery simply because it was close to our vacation spot and we wanted to try a local casual diner. So glad we did! The décor is cute and happy, and very clean. All the staff is extremely friendly and attentive. Our food was AMAZING! I had a delicious Kraut and Pork soup (had never heard of that!!) and it was my first time trying Fried Chicken & Waffles. What a treat! The Waffle was wonderfully light and crispy, while the chicken was moist and breaded to perfection. My partner had the Pork Loin Dinner special and it too was outstanding. Fresh veggies, great mash, and succulent pork. We couldn’t stop sharing from each others plates! Portions are large but not overwhelming. We heard compliments from every table of other guests, and many of them mentioned that they visited because of very high recommendations. I recommend everyone try it indeed! Many lovely menu choices. They serve beer and wine at good prices. My only suggestion to the management would be to offer finer beer choices — perhaps some craft or local beer? Otherwise, keep up the good work! Dessert choices look delicious but we were too full to try any. Prices are inexpensive and good value for such a fabulous sit-​down meal. Everyone should make this a destination in Naples!

Great ice cream. Vanilla with Oreos mixed in, how can you go wrong. They also serve breakfast, lunch and dinner. The place had a nice crowd at 6:30 on a Monday. Nice server who was very helpful. Will come back again.
They gave my boys goody bags! Awesome