The Surf Club At Montauk

there was mold and roaches when we went, do not go there.

We just returned from a great family vacation at The Surf Club! I would highly recommend this place to families with kids. We were looking for a condo — not hotel room — so that we could cook our own meals at night. The kitchenettes are great! Have most of the necessities (pots, pans, cutlery, glasses, etc…) although we will be taking our own knives next trip… You can take your own groceries, spices and wine and you’re set! We stayed in room 51 with a great pool/​ocean view. Room was very clean. Bedroom is upstairs so we could put our infant to sleep and continue with our evening. Staff is very polite. Hotel is totally walkable to coffee shops, restaurants, bars and the heart of town. Overall I could not be more pleased! And for the price: under $ 300 a night for June?! That’s so inexpensive! We will definitely be continuing our summer family vacations at The Surf Club!

A fun casual place. Great outdoor space.

We stayed at the Surf Club for a wedding in Montauk during October. They charged us an additional 50% for a single night stay. We were required to send a check for a full night to book the room, two months prior to the event. There was an additional $ 53. charge which we were able to put on a credit card. The location of the motel was good, but the rooms and bathroom were not that clean. Furniture in the condo was worn and there were stains on the carpet.

i would give the surf club negative stars if it were an option! we stayed at the surf club and our room was infested with LARGE spiders. Disgusting conditions to have to deal with especially when we have a 4 month old and one of the spiders was in close proximity to his crib. When we called to complain, 4 messages later and still no response. In addition to that the bed frame broke while my husband was asleep and the bed was partially laying on the floor. The staff including management should be absolutely embarrassed to run a business this way. We packed up in the middle of the night and left thats how bad it was.

I used to come here a lot as a kid but my most current stay was disappointing. The unit had not been cleaned, had cracked windows, dirty dishes and a broken toilet. We asked the staff 3 times for assistance yet we didn’t receive any. For example when we asked the housekeeper to clean the dirty floors she asked us if we wanted a mop to clean it ourselves. In the morning we spoke to the manager he was not helpful to say the least. He threatened us and told us to leave if we were not happy. For $ 600 a night we expected a clean room and more courtesy.

Well stocked kitchens, good wifi and tvs, close to the beach. Nothin to complain about.

Left at 10:30 at nite. blanket from 1973 had not been washed in a decade. Other than that location is fantastic.

I felt totally big pimpin’ checking into this bad boy. For just $ 85 a night (it was October, so the rates were extremely low, and they were offering an additional 15% off just because they rule), we had a duplex that is bigger than my apartment. The bedroom (with a sink! hell yes!) and bathroom are on the second floor, and the first houses the kitchen, living room, and outdoor patio. The staff was extremely accommodating, and allowed us to switch nights free of charge without issue at all. Upon arrival (we traveled from Brooklyn after work, and thus didn’t get there until around 9pm), we found a note on the office door letting us know that our condo was open and the keys were on the kitchen table. How easy!
We had an absolutely fabulous time, and are planning on staying there again in the future. I can’t imagine wanting to choose another place in Montauk! While they did not have a jacuzzi (the only bummer), they did have a nice steam room that we took advantage of, and because it was the off-​season, we virtually had the place to ourselves. It was a heavenly escape from the city for three glorious days. I can’t recommend The Surf Club highly enough. You won’t be disappointed, except about the fact that you have to leave!

The surf club was a really great place to stay. Life doesn’t get better than waking up and hearing the ocean right outside your bedroom window.
The pool was beautiful, with an extensive pool deck complete with lounge chairs and umbrellas. There was a short path right from our room to the beach, where we spent most of our day, walking around and playing in the beautiful sand, sun, and surf.
Another plus was that we could walk to town right from the hotel — so all the gift shops and restaurants are right at your fingertips!
As for the room, the kitchen was tiny and the comforter in the bed was not satisfactory. However the sliding doors leading to a porch with a view of the ocean was great. Plus, I really liked that it had two floors, and the upstairs bedroom had an even better view than downstairs. The tile floors were really nice and the bathroom was clean. The room also had most kitchen appliances and 2 flat screen televisions.
So, our stay at Surf Club at Montauk was an enjoyable and relaxing experience.

This is the coolest place to stay in Montauk. It’s on the ocean, so always book early and get an oceanfront. not garden or pool etc. There are two floors and you can bring an extra person. More like a mini-​condo! Way to go if you are willing to spend a bit more. Bedrooms are upstairs. so you can wake up to hear the ocean waves. leaving the sliding doors open of course.
This is what makes this town amazing. waking up to the ocean. and strolling into town for pancakes at Johns. Thats the routine out here. then of course swimming, strolling the village, driving back to the lighthouse, walking on a quiet beach later in the day then maybe going to the local pub or Montauk movie. with only one show playing IF your lucky. hehe.
This is a clean place, not seedy… you can bring a mother or aunt and have no complaints.

last year we came here for a weekend and loved it. this year we came back and wanted the same room — coming during off season is an excellent deal and we got an ocean view room for under $ 100, almost unheard of out here. the bed are a little firm, and the place was just redone on the outside. this year, however, the hot water wasn’t running, so the maintenance guy came and turned it on, but a few hours later it still wouldn’t work. we called the front desk and he gave us a few keys to other rooms to take our pick of which one we liked — including an ocean front room which was double the price, free of charge. no questions asked. we will definitely be coming back a 3^rd time next year.

This beach front hotel in Montauk looks more like clusters of little condominiums than say, a giant, obvious hotel. It’s nice and homey with different room options. I stayed in a suite here that looks more like an apartment than just an open room. There’s a kitchen, living area, bathroom and two bedrooms. There are various rooms and rates, of course. (Rooms range from one bedroom to two bedroom duplexes with different luxuries, views and locations. The biggest difference between rooms is the Poolside view versus the Oceanside view).
This hotel is a bit on the pricey side. And you can actually buy a unit, if you so desire. And of course have the extra pocket change laying around. The rooms themselves are always clean, bright, and airy. It’s nicely decorated but not too fancy; more of a minimalist design, which I prefer.
The Surf Club is on the beach, a nice plus so you don’t have to travel so far to soak up some sun. It’s also near the center of town where the nightlife and shops are. There are other amenities such as television/​cable, telephones, air conditioning and swimming pools. I do not know if there is internet or wifi available, though. A great location, nice and accommodating staff. I have only lovely times here.