Fudge N Stuff

YUM. I have been eating the candy and fudge here for as long as I can remember. The fudge is some of the best I’ve ever had. Very kid friendly abs they have plenty of ice cream flavours too.

The ice cream is overpriced and disgusting; I could not even finish my small peach cup. You know the texture and taste of ice cream when it melts and gets refrozen and there’s this weird ice false sweetness? If you like that melted pseudo freezer burn texture and fake-​sweet-​too-​brightly-​colored taste, then this is the perfect place for you! They should really reconsider the «stuff» part of their store and stick to their fudge. My boyfriend and I only tried the ice cream, but I hope for Fudge N Stuff’s sake that their fudge is better than their ice cream.

This store is an adorable fudge, candy and ice cream spot located slightly off the main downtown street in Montauk. The store is the definition of a mom-​and-​pop store — most all of its treats are homemade and the staff is delightfully friendly.
The birthday cake ice cream was the best type of ice cream. It contained chunks of actual cake, gobs of icing and a scattering of real rainbow sprinkles. Almost all of the other ice creams did not taste sweet — the taste of cream and ice overpowered any other sort of flavoring or sweetness (which is why this place gets ³⁄₅ stars).
While ice cream might be most appealing, especially on a hot summer beach day, the real gem at this place is the selection of fudge. Above all, the birthday cake fudge was the best treat in the whole place. Like the birthday cake ice cream, the fudge contained pieces of cake and sprinkles. The mint chocolate fudge was a second best.
I would recommend this place if you are craving fudge, chocolate covered goodies and/​or candy or if you want to get an edible gift/​souvenir for someone. For ice cream, however, this place is not the best option in town.

Just stepping inside and smelling this place is worth going in for! They have the best fudge around and have been in the heart of town for many years. Their cotton candy flavored ice cream is delicious. I also look forward to getting a box of saltwater taffy everytime I’m in town. Many places in Montauk have changed, but I’m so glad that this store is still around – a staple in Montauk that I looked forward to as a kid and still do as an adult.

The fudge and ice cream at Fudge N Stuff is delicious. My only concerns with this place is the employees can be a little rude. For example, one time I asked for a new piece of fudge because my boyfriend who is severely allergic to gluten ordered plain chocolate and since they didn’t wipe off the knife there was oreo from another type of fudge all over his piece. The woman seemed really annoyed and I basically had to fight her to give me a new piece with no cross-​contamination. There’s actually a law in New York that makes it unlawful for her to say no to a new piece, which she was completely unaware of.
Also, one time while getting ice cream I asked for a cup of tap water and they tried to charge me $ 1.50. I’m pretty sure there’s law against charging people for tap water as well. So they were definitely trying to rip me off.
In conclusion, don’t ask them for water and be careful if you have allergies but otherwise the food is tasty.

The fudge is very good, but the «stuff» is the X factor. The ice cream cones and sundaes seem to be the big hit. There always seems to be a line. They off some non-​routine flavors such as pistachio and coconut which is a nice change. My son was a fan of the hot fudge sundae.

Forget the «stuff» and go for the fudge! This cute little store has a great array of fudge that it was so hard to choose. I didn’t realize that we could get an assortment of them, even in a ¼lb box, until we saw someone do it after we bought it but my toffee fudge was out of this world! They do have some sugar-​free options, which is good when you have a diabetic in tow. Her amaretto fudge was tasty — I didn’t expect something sugar free to taste as good!
Cash only.

I appreciate places that sell sugar-​free fudge. My friends had been wanting to stop in here since we arrived in Montauk and I do LOVE fudge, however, regular fudge with a ton of sugar always makes me sick. We went in here and I expected not to find anything I could eat but then I saw a sugar-​free section. The flavors are limited but all the basics are there. I went with the amaretto and yes, it did taste like amaretto fudge with sugar. Nothing was lacking and it didn’t taste like cardboard.
They also have a selection of ice cream, which one of my friends told me was tasty. There’s also a wall full of different kinds of candy. Tons and tons of stuff for anyone with a sweet tooth. Prices are fair but they are cash-​only. Thank you for making sugar-​free fudge good again.

I was there over the weekend and it was cool to find a shop open until 11 in Montauk!
Although we didn’t try the fudge, we did have the ice cream. Peanut Butter and vanilla was so decadent and delicious.
Cake Batter and Cotton Candy was also better than I’ve tasted in other ice cream shoppes.
The charm of the store was also in the colorful containers of candy that surrounded the walls. It was a nice treat different from the chain ice cream shoppes.

Wow, a fudge shop open late in Montauk! My friend and I stumbled upon this place after dinner Friday night and was surprised it was still open past 10pm.
They have decadent array of fudges such as mud pie (which consists of caramel, oreo cookies, chocolate) to mint chocolate. I’m a glutton when it comes to desserts and I picked up this sucker the next day at 11am on my way to the beach.
For ¼ a lb, (which is about $ 4) one of the girls behind the counters slices you a an amazing piece of fudge wrapped in their cute Fudge N Stuff packaging. It comes with a little knife for you to slice into tinier pieces for you to share with your friends.
Everything looked delicious and on the lower counter, they have sugar free sweets for your more health conscious friends.
On the left side of the candy store, they have ice cream and on the shelves, they have little candy knick-​knacks to satisfy your sweet tooth.
All fudges are made in their own kitchen so you know it’s good and made with love. However, make sure you have cash as it’s cash only.

The fudge here is OUTRAGEOUS! Better than the Jersey Shore (location not the show), Cape May and Atlantic City. The almond joy fudge was my favorite and the chocolate mint was my husband’s. The chocolate vanilla swirl and chocolate marshmallow were also delicious.
The only negative is that they don’t take credit cards — cash only. Not too big a deal though, the prices are reasonable.

Jesus. This place has a lot of rules for a fudge shop.

I didn’t even think I liked fudge till I came here.
Do youself a favor and get a block of MUD SLIDE. Milk chocolate, oreos, caramel, nuts… HOLY FREAKIN GOOD.
I wish I can sink my teeth into it and nibble on it all day long.
I heart you.

We stopped in somewhat randomly on a june weekend before the town gets crazy. They’re cash only, so make sure you hit the ATM.
Picked up several different kinds of fudge in a decent sized box for about $ 8. Very good, certainly worth the price.

What is a summer beach town without a good sweets shop for the kids?
Fudge N Stuff fits the bill nicely. In a town not known for modest prices on anything, this place delivers with a $ 2.25 kids sized ice cream cone, a gazillion packaged candies, and chocolates by the pound (or fraction thereof).
But clearly, the coup de grace is the cotton candy. Not just cotton candy… cotton candy made to order.
I can’t even get cotton candy made to order at most carnivals, circuses or fairs. They are all pre-​made these days and shoved into bags, hours before you buy them. Can’t blame the vendors per se, because making the stuff is such a mad sticky mess.
BUT, Fudge N Stuff sells the real deal. And you can pick red or blue. Granted, the blue isn’t terribly blue… but that’s probably for the best.
When you go, just be prepared to wait. And to be yelled at. Not in anger, mind you, it’s just hard to hear above the roar of all the sugar-​high kids.