Hands down My Favorite Pizza Place!!! I’ve been going here since they’ve opened and always have a good experience. They always offer a good selection of pizza. The food and soups are great to. I’ve always had a pleasant experience with the owner and other staff members. I eat from here at least once a week, I’m a regular and recommend this place to all pizza lovers.
Rich M.
Tu valoración: 3 Wappingers Falls, NY
Stopped in for a couple of slices for me and my friend Marie to it back to her office for lunch… was OK except when my friend at her slices… the cheese ran of the pizza and into her lap needless to say she was pissed… this is not my favorite place
Lisa M.
Tu valoración: 2 Beacon, NY
I guess the other reviews said it. The balsamic dressing is amazing but the owner and the staff are beyond rude and nasty… I mean really bad!!! Also they are so grossly overpriced on «toppings» and there is no room for customer service with them. I literally asked to take 3 toppings off a salad and asked to have olives on instead and he told me that I would have to pay $ 1 more… my coworker got a salad that had olives and she had 4! 4!!! so .25 per olive? They better hope Unilocal isn’t well used because they will lose a lot of customers. I know they lost me and my job.
Westchester C.
Tu valoración: 2 Mohegan Lake, NY
Good enough food. Owner is a creep. Not sure why he wants a job dealing with people when he should be working out of a cave somewhere. Or just make your pizzas in the back kitchen. Balsamic dressing is awesome!
Telling It L.
Tu valoración: 1 Cortlandt, NY
Hate this place. Everything from the pizza to subs are just nasty. I got a chicken parm sub from them once and ended up in the ER with food poisining hours later. The owner isn’t very nice either, he was downright rude to his staff while I was waiting there for my sub that wasn’t done yet even though I called ahead. I even heard him yelling at his delivery boy who was clearly mentally challenged calling him a cripple and saying his mom should have aborted him. After hearing that and getting sick from their food I will never return and neither will any of my friends or family I told about these horrendous acts
Artie B.
Tu valoración: 1 Cortlandt, NY
Pizza is tasteless and expensive. The chicken franchise taste terrible. The atmosphere is stressful due to all the screaming from the owner.
D M.
Tu valoración: 2 New York, NY
The pizza is very thin, so thin you could almost see through parts of it. It was very salty and lacked flavor.
Melissa N.
Tu valoración: 5 Mohegan Lake, NY
We love My Favorite Pizza! They have the best soups anywhere in Westchester, especially the escarole and bean, the cobb salad is ridiculous and their gyros are the best. For dessert try the cannoli stuffed zeppolis-unbelievable. The owner Frank is an absolute pleasure-what a nice guy!
Shannon C.
Tu valoración: 1 Cortlandt Manor, NY
Horrible and over priced. The owner is beyond rude to customers and the staff. While waiting for my order I saw the owner(angry bald man mentioned in other reviews) yell at his young staff for seemingly no reason. There is a grill in the back by the dumpsters that the staff looks to be using. Hopefully not for my food!
Agitha C.
Tu valoración: 1 Poughkeepsie, NY
went in recently to pick up an order. i was horrified how the owner tripped and dropped a pie on the floor(looked like a mac attack so beware) he slid it right back into the rack like nothing happened. i stared in horror hoping he would do something about it. I’m sorry not coming here anymore, i don’t want floor pizza…
ChristoFF C.
Tu valoración: 3 Yorktown Heights, NY
Food is still excellent but staff not friendly
K C.
Tu valoración: 3 Estero, FL
Good good both times I was there. The owner is good cook but could use some ‘social’ coaching.
M D.
Tu valoración: 1 Mohegan Lake, NY
We’ve tried everything from the pizza to the main courses, and they were average. What absolutely cannot go unmentioned is the owner is not a friendly man. He is very nasty when you ask him questions, like he doesn’t want to be bothered, and he is abusive to his young female staff. The last time I was there, March 29th, 2014, he towered over this young female(of course) employee in an abusive, threatening manner because she didn’t take an order the way he wanted. She was so upset, she was crying at the counter. Then he continued to abuse her by scolding her and demanding responses to his questions. We will no longer give him business.
Ron P.
Tu valoración: 3 Yorktown Heights, NY
I popped in for a slice for lunch and decided on a «meatball parm» slice. The meatballs were sliced real thin and didn’t weigh the pizza down. I like that. There were plenty of slices on the pizza. I like that too. Ate lunch and went to pay…$ 3.75 for a slice. I didn’t like that. That’s a whole pile of money for 1 slice of pizza.
Michael Q.
Tu valoración: 2 Yorktown Heights, NY
I used to go here alot a while ago the taste deprecated a bit. I popped in after many years and had a BBQ chicken slice and it wasn’t good, the sauce was a bit sourish and it was covered in sauce and onions. it was not really that good. The sauce tasted like the red onions that you put on hotdogs in the city carts. Then I did something very fat and drove up to Gigi’s in Jefferson valley and their BBQ chicken slice was great. I’m sorry but my favorite pizza fell off, they use to be good before Pizza Hut moved in but it’s like there not into it no more.
Jennifer L.
Tu valoración: 4 Baldwin Place, NY
Decent wedges… Ordered Chicken Parm and Meatball Parm. Both wedges were a bit dry and needed more sauce. Next time I will ask for it on the side!
Rich P.
Tu valoración: 5 Newburgh, NY
Consistently great food… Order from there weekly and everything on the menu so far has been at least good to excellent.
Tubby T.
Tu valoración: 4 Peekskill, NY
Home of the Mac Attack slice! Enough said!!!
Joanne M.
Tu valoración: 5 Westchester County, NY
I really love this place! The pizza is superb. I’ve had the eggplant and it is wonderful as well. Cheese calzones are great! I get their meatballs as a treat for my dogs when I treat myself to pizza. I’m a vegetarian, so I’ve never tasted them, but my kids love ‘em. The service is very attentive and the delivery is speedy… I especially love the drive thru!!!
Robert C.
Tu valoración: 4 Cortlandt Manor, NY
We have yet to be disappointed here — even the veal was thin, tender and flavorful, hard to get from a «pizza joint». Pizza is thin crust, the margarita pizza rocked. Try it for your next delivery!
