Purchase Street Market

I love Purchase Street Market’s subs, they’re exceptional. Better than any of the sub shops in Milford. If I had any complaint about PSM, it would be that, while most of the staff is friendly, there is this one guy who works there who has absolutely no personality and is grumpy, barely talks to you while you order your subs. However, the rest of the staff is very friendly, and the sandwiches are the best, so overall I’d say don’t pass up a chance to get a sub here! Oh, and, their small is like a medium anywhere else, their medium is like a large, and their large is like the size of an actual submarine, so chose your size accordingly, you need to be very hungry to order anything bigger than a small!!! They also sell excellent deli meats and a small variety of groceries.

Moved to Milford last year, and this is the place that I find myself returning to time after time. The Italian subs are great — you will not be hungry after eating one of these subs! I have tried their catering as well, and while I have definitely liked some things better than others, the food was always good and always prepared and hot when pick up time arrived.
Definitely worth a try for anyone who has not been here.

It seems like most of my reviews are either «love it» or «hate it» type reviews. Purchase Street Market definitely falls under the «love it» category.
First, and foremost, the food. It seems like ALL their food is homemade and delicious. I have had the meatballs, the sausage, the steak tips, and the porketta (oh the porketta!!). The sandwiches are HUGE, a great value for the money. Don’t get me wrong, they could probably raise the prices on their sandwiches and I would still eat there because the food is excellent.
They have daily specials which are also delicious. Soups, pizza, stuffed peppers, and the list goes on. They just started carrying Boars Head brand cold cuts and cheeses (just happens to be my most favorite brand!). Check out their Facebook page, they sometimes post pics of their daily specials. I will be heading back soon to try an Italian on that delicious bread made with Boars Head meats (whew, my mouth is watering!)
The place is small, but very clean and seems to have everything one would want from a convenience store (even beer and wine). They also cater and sell some of their meats to take home and cook yourself. There are lots of good little delis scattered around the Milford area but I must say my favorite is The Purchase Street Market!
I highly recommend it! … Peace and Love …

decent sandwiches but HOLY GRUMPUS BATMAN
That dude wakes up on the wrong side of the bed EVERY day it seems. I would go here far more often if they had better customer service

Never had a bad meal from them. Must be good because it’s very busy all the time.

Great food but horrible customer service. I live around the corner but would rather go across town to get the same they offer. Been there a handful of times thinking maybe the woman working there was having a bad day. After the 5^th time I realized it wasn’t an off day. Made it my mission to make sure I tell whoever I see about the poor service I received there. I honestly can’t understand for the life of me how they stay in business.
Check Oliva’s great food AND great service.

Don’t go here often but may start now that I’ve realized the deli is legit. Been getting subs at chains and pizza joints all around town for years but the outside advertising recently caught my attention. Decided to give the porketta and sausage subs a try. The sausage was delicious as everything was homemade, but the porketta was not true italian porketta, it was roast pork thinly sliced. It lacked the traditional spices you’d typically find and was unfortunately rather dry. For a really amazing porketta sub I’d highly recommend Gene’s Variety also in Milford. Another tip worth noting, you can order small, medium or large subs. The large is XL. For those who can eat a large sub from your typical sub shop yet still feel like you could put away half of another one, that pretty much sums up the size of what you’ll be getting here. No doubt worth the $ 7 – 8 bucks it will cost you.

I’m going to have to co-​sign Terry M’s comment, they really do have the most delicious and gigantic pastrami I have ever seen or tasted, their pastrami is thicker than any place I have ever had pastrami. They put enough meat in one sub for you to eat until full and then have leftover meat for a week, the only thing that stopped Purchase street from getting the 5 star special is that they don’t make the neatest subs, usually I have to take off the top bread and re-​position my meat and cheese so that I don’t get one bite of all condiments followed by one bite of all meat, but other than that this place is phenomenal. If you go during lunch time be prepared to wait in line. Some other honorable mentions from me would have to be the Tuna, which I am waiting for my fiancé to bring me as we speak, and the cranberry walnut chicken salad. In Milford, most of the delis here have very loyal customers that only eat the same deli, me on the other hand, I like different subs from different deli’s, but when it comes to pastrami, there is no need for thought, I’m Team Purchase Street all day. Now stop reading and go get your mind blown by the size and quality of this sub… do it right now. Enjoy

Purchase Street Market is a great place to get a sub or lunch time snack. The subs are flipping massive. They bake porketta on at the store that is tender and good. The store staff are all friendly and helpful when you need to make a catering order.