Geo’s Pizza

Geo’s is one of two pizza places I can get my best friend to eat at. I think the food here is pretty good. I really like the dough nuggets. I would much rather eat those than the pizza. The pizza is only a step up from Monical’s pizza (and I am not fan of them). The service has never been great. Somehow I always get the inattentive waitress section. I look to see other table’s with the friendly, helpful waitress. I always order tea to drink. This last visit, the waitress brought me the container that holds the sweeteners. I picked up a packet and it was wet. The whole container had liquid at the bottle. It would not have been so bad if the waitress did not disappear for a while. Our pizza was brought out by someone else and we were offered refills by another waitress. The waitress showed up at the end to do the «please leave me a tip» interaction.
For some reason, every time we go to pay no one is at the register. There will be people in the back looking at us but no one acknowledges us right away. Whoever shows up usually says «Sorry for the wait» however it seems meaningless since they stared us for a few minutes before showing up.

I love this pizza place! Their salad bar is great and their pizza is always fantastic! You place is very clean and has a good atmosphere.

A local staple. Dough nuggets are manna from heaven! I have it every time I’m in town. When I had my tonsils taken out, dough nuggets were my first solid food in weeks. It was all I wanted haha

My favorite pizza growing up! Its a little pricey but not that bad. I would recommend going on Wednesday night or Sunday night for the buffet. Also always get the Go Nuggets, eating in or ordering.

Great pizza and they get your carry out fast. Really like this pizza a lot way better than other local places.

Okay so we showed up at 8pm. The sign on the door says 10pm so you would think we were fine. First of all no one comes to wait on us for about 10 minutes (even though everyone in the kitchen looked right at us as we walked in) then the waitress comes over and says «oh I didn’t see you» My daughter orders the buffet, waitress says we wont be putting any new food out just whats there as it ends at 8. My daughter says that’s fine. I ordered Geo nuggets «for starters» and a Garlic chicken pizza. Here is why they get two stars… the pizza is not bad. So for the bad stuff… Pizza came before the nuggets and when she asked can I get you anything else I knew she forgot the nuggets but I asked for them anyway. they did eventually come out. They broke the salad bar down while my daughter was still eating. To be fair they did ask her if it was okay but what would she say. The waitress staff was putting all the chairs up on the tables and they were mopping the floor in front of the buffet. We got up and served ourselves for refills as we were never asked if we wanted anymore. It was obvious they wanted us to leave. Could not have been a more uncomfortable dinner. Will try somewhere else next time.

I grew up in Metamora and I love Geo’s pizza… it’s delicious! They also have the best Cheese Nuggets you’ve got to try! Go on a Sunday and try out their pizza bar… that way u can try different pizzas they make… you’ll love it! Great experience for travelers!

We were in visiting family and looked up places that used
. Stopped in for pizza. The first thing that told me we were in for a good meal was the smell. Anyone who has been to a good pizza place knows that smell or pizza crust, garlic… mmm. We ordered three of their mini gourmet pizzas. We had the roasted garlic, bbq chicken, and the spinach, mushroom, and chicken pizzas. Service was pretty quick and the pizza was really good. The crust was flaky (we got pan pizzas) and the toppings were great. I would suggest if you are going in with another person opt for several mini pizzas so you can try several. I am really glad we did. There is no doubt that if we are back in town we will eat here again.

I was expecting better! Don’t get me wrong, the pizza was fine, but it wasn’t anything special. My husband and I both thought the deep dish tasted just like Pizza Hut. For a small town independently owned restaurant, I thought there would be some originality to the taste. The ‘nuggets’ are just garlic breadsticks cut up into smaller pieces. All in all, very disappointing.

Having recently moved to the area, we decided to try Geo’s in Metamora Illinois. We were greeted by a friendly staff member and told to sit where we wanted. large tv’s showed the current sports game Du’jour. service was fast and the choices many off a great menu. The cheese nuggets could have been a meal, the size of a small pizza and very delicious. Had we known, that would have been plenty but the food kept coming, the pizza, thin crust extra large was really good. We had the supreme. Prices are reasonable and we will be back!

Wasn’t expecting anything around in the middle of nowhere, here in Metamora, IL. However, good ‘ol Unilocal proved me wrong and we found Geo’s. A quaint little pizza place in a quaint little town… and it was good! Garlic cheese bread was perfect and we ordered the Classic Combo which was delicious. Sauce was perfect, toppings perfect, and crust perfect. If I wasn’t so full I would try more stuff, lol!
I love places like these where you are suprised with an excellent place in a tiny town…

Metamora Illinois is one of those classical American sleepy little towns. The people are laid back.
They are lucky to have Geo’s!
We enjoyed the cheesy garlic bread! Tasty and cheesy, just the way I like it.
Had the pan style classic combo. Wow! The crust was crispy (difficult with a pan pizza), sauce was rich and flavorful, lots of cheese, and enough meat to satisfy any appetite!
Price is reasonable, good service, clean dining room.
The only drawback was (let me think) none!
GEO’S us no exception. This place is not busy, which surprises me, because it is really good!