John’s Sweet Tomatoes Pizzeria

Excellent pizza! Yummy lobster rolls but the price has gone up on them. Last time we ordered it was almost $ 30 for 2 lobster rolls and fries. :(sorry, won’t be back at that price

We love coming here. They have amazingly delicious fresh fish, wonderful pizzas and the service is very efficient and welcoming. It’s not a fancy place but who needs fancy when you have good food?

friendly staff and amazing pizza that makes your mouth water! If you ever considered going here you should, won’t regret it

Awesome pizza! Our team at America’s Best Contacts and Glasses down the road order a few pies every weekend. Their pizza is so good! Makes me feel like I am back up north, with oldies playing and family atmosphere. Thanks so much for bringing back these memories. Pizza and the Four Seasons! Forgettabouddit!

Absolutely recommend their Vegetarian pizza — The crust was so fresh and so were the toppings. The portion sizes for other dishes like Baked Ziti with sausage were good. I don’t think I’m getting pizza from anywhere else in Melbourne!

Great pizza place! Friendly servers and it was not a long wait for really good pizza. We were grateful to find this on Unilocal

Another great find. In town for golf, used Unilocal to find great pizza place. Pizza is excellent. Would highly recommend

This place absolutely lived up to the reviews. Everything we had was absolutely delicious!!! The service was exceptional. Our waitress was personable and very friendly. The place was on the cozy side so you could see what was going on all over the restaurant and all the employees seemed to be just as welcoming as ours was.
We ordered a Chicken Alfredo deep dish pizza, a Shrimp and Bacon deep dish pizza, Chicken Parmigiana, a spinach and cheese calzone and a Pepperoni, Beef and Mushroom pizza and 2 appetizers. The food came out quickly and was piping hot. The Chicken Alfredo pizza was probably the best I’ve eaten. We had plenty of leftovers and they were eaten before the end of the night. My 3 teens gave it two thumbs up!

I can only speak to the pizza so, if you’re looking for review on their other offerings, keep scrolling. Their pasta, sandwiches and seafood look great, but I’m all about the pizza.
Best in Brevard county. My wife and I do pizza 3 times a month and our date nights consist of happy hour and a new pizza joint. We’ve been to most between Cocoa and Sebastian (and beyond) and Sweet Tomatoes is by far our favorite.
There are so many sub-​par NY style pizza places in Brevard. It’s as if anyone from NY thinks they can come down and open a pizza joint and it’s great just because they are New Yorkers. This is not NY style in the sense that the crust is not mushy, but not cracker-​like either. It’s right in between, meaning you can pick the piece up by the crust and it will «stay straight.» Great chew like a real NY style pizza (from NY, not here).
Service is always great. John seems like a hoot, but I have never met him. Several servers have been there since I’ve been going (10 years).
Try it… you will like it!

Driving home to WPB from orlando. Couldnt decide where to stop but ended up here via Unilocal help. Pull up and the place looks quaint, and somehow you just know its going to be good.
Sat down right away, had the mom n pop feel and a new england sticker, i felt at home!
Had the greek salad, good dressing! But i always appreciate greek salads with chunks of feta, chunks of tomatoes and cucumber. Just my preference but still great.
Also had calamari that i dont believe was ever frozen, super delicious.
Lastly the new england style pizzas, one buffalo chicken and one Margherita. Both excellent!
Service is as expected, friendly and easy going. Next time im driving through town i will go again

We came across this gem while making a pit stop in Melbourne on our 6 hour drive back home from visiting family on Thanksgiving. We ordered their white pizza, and after having my second slice I was disappointed when I looked down at the box in my lap and saw my bf had devoured the remainder of our medium sized order.
I’m a huge white pizza fan, and Sweet Tomatoes’ white pizza is on point. It was very flavorful and had the right amount of gooey cheesiness, without the drippy mess of being overly greasy.
Oh, and the best part? We ate for less than we would’ve had we stopped at a fast food establishment. I hope we get a chance to dine in next time and try out some of their pasta.

I’ve been eating here for years great food great service fast for takeout cheeseburger sub is my favorite.

Just ok. I got a garden salad and house Stromboli togo. The Stromboli was good, the marinara was not (too bitter). The salad was not good either. Iceberg with red onion, one cucumber slice, and one grape tomato. That would have been fine, but there were several slimy green pieces of lettuce.
I give this place 3 stars, instead of 2, because it was packed on a Thursday night with locals and has a dive feel. I like that.

Lunguica pizza. For this Massachusetts transplant I need not say more. YUM! I am sure the other food is good, but I’ll never know. :)

Stromboli is a must best food I have had since coming to Melbourne for work! Will be back to try other menu items very soon!

I would call this place a cozy little Italian/​Greek/​Seafood «Diner.» I had the lobster roll that was on their specials board but everything looked and sounded great. I can’t wait to try more of their menu.

Not sure why Unilocal lists them as delivering. I called tonight and was disappointed to find out that they don’t deliver.
I gave them 5 stars anyway because it wouldn’t be fair to knock them for this… Just wanted to save other people time.

Tonight we had three different entrées. The mini Stromboli which is always one of our favorites. The lobster and shrimp casserole which is good but small. The grilled salmon with vegetables which was very good as well. They are super nice here and always consistent and good

Stopped there on my way down to Palm Beach. What a welcome stop for a quick dinner. Service was pleasant and speedy. Pizza was outstanding as was my mother’s Greek Salad. Great stop for families, very reasonably priced.

Good pizza, good price, the waitress was friendly and quick, local place as opposed to a chain, I’d go back.