Casey’s Carry Out Pizza & Subs

I am a fan of Casey’s and I always stop when I see one. Today I need an afternoon pick me up. Love the fountain Diet Coke because they always have the foam cups. Love the potato wedges…

Wow, how the great have fallen. I love this place for my kids, once a week, loved the subs, loved the friendly people, and actually liked the food. 4 times in a row, carryout single topping pizza, ordered 20 minutes before pickup, and got there 20 minutes later. Pizza wasn’t even in the oven.
I hate how Casey’s is so hit or miss. they either are 4 or 5 star, or 1 star. I guess we’ll find a different place to have our weekly pizza night. You guys need to hire some better employees and managers. I had this same problem in my last location too, great to start, horrible after a year or so.

I’ve been ordering pizza here for several months. It all started when I was exhausted from yard work in the spring and too tired to shower. So I call the local convenience store order a pizza and surprised when they said it would be ready in 10 minutes. I’ve never had to wait over 15mins for a pizza ever. They are always extremely down home sweet with a «be careful its hot darlin» or «sweety» etc. Always quick nice and sincere. Never had a bad experience. Why you’re there pick up a brownie or cookie in the lil bakery section. Always fresh. I’ve been more than pleasantly surprised. Haven’t tried a sub yet but I bet I will on another lazy Sunday. Yes it’s a gas station but I sincerely highly recommend getting a pizza here.