Amish Heritage Market

I had the best food experience ever I love trying new and different food and desserts

I had THE best sandwhich here today. First let me describe the store and then I’ll get to the most wonderful, incredible, yum-​a-​licious sandwhich.
Amish Heritage is a tiny store right on Main Street right across the street from the Fairgrounds. I believe the store may be going on it’s year anniversary. Inside are a plethora of wonderful Amish baked goods (they get their fresh baked goods typically on Wednesdays and Saturdays), huge selection of spices, tons of baking ingredients you can’t find at the grocery (ie: Xantham gum), specialty dessert and dip mixes, nuts, candies, lunch meat (Trail bologna), amish cheeses, drinks, make your own peanut butter and much much more. The store is cramped and small but there is a ton of selection.
They make these homemade fried pies (think along the likes of those hostess cherry/​apple pies) that are to die for. Homemade flaky pie dough with various different fillings to choose from like (Raisin, Apple, Peach, Cherry, Rhubarb in season and more) and then dunked in a yummy glaze. When these are fresh they are so darn good (I wanted to say dam* but figure since I’m reviewing an Amish store I’ll keep my curse words in check :) The store also can put together party platters for you pretty quickly with meats, cheeses, breads and so on. They have specials for $ 5 you get a homemade sandwich of your choosing, bag of chips and a can of soda. Now… drum roll please… On to the sandwhich.
I was running a ton of errrands and forgot to eat lunch so I figured I’d stop in and see what they could whip up. I really didn’t know they could make sandwhiches on the fly but now I do and my oh my I’ll be back. They have a ton of lunch meats to choose from and are happy to slice whatever you’d like for you to try before you buy. So the lady gave me a sample slice of the trail bologna. She said it was pretty popular. I took a bite and said… oh yeah, whip one up. I selected munster cheese and she had fresh made buns. She asked me if I wanted it warmed? Um heck yes… didn’t know they did this either. She had a sandwhich maker in the back and put the bologna, cheese and toasted it. Then she added some mayo and mustard, wrapped it up for me to take.
I got to the car, took a bite and said SHUT YOUR MOUTH!!! OMG it was soooooo good. That sandwhich got wulfed down with a quickness. I also bought some pumpkin cookies with buttermillk frosting for this weekend, but couldn’t resist trying one and mmm mmm were they good and fresh too.
I’m telling ya, this store rocks and the lady that runs the place is super helpful too. She really enjoys talking to customers and meeting the people of the community. If there is something in there that you wished they’d carry, she wants to know about it and will do what she can to accomodate you. No need to travel way up North to Amish Country when you have a little slice of it right here in good ol Marysville.