Island Pizza and Pasta Company

We have tried pizza from many restaurants on the island. We believe that Island Pizza makes the best white pizza on Marco. We’ve tried a few different kinds and they are all good.

Not that SW FL is known for great pizza but this was barely (and not really) even edible. The thin crust was rubbery and crusty at the same time which I never thought would even be possible. It was overcooked, and tasteless. When we called to complain, no one cared. Needless to say, we will never return.

Just ok.
The large is very large. Pineapple chunks are too big and the crust is without flavor. It will do if your expectations are not too high.

Good but not great pizza. Salad was a good size. Best for takeout; not much dining space. Ample parking

Short summary; a dump with 4 tables and jerks running it.
If I could give a negative star I would. My review has nothing to do with the food as after entering the place it’s quickly devolved into an argument. I slipped on water upon entering the door and cut my hand on the the door handle. While I did not fall and was prepared to eat there still what followed was bizarre and by far the worst experience I have ever had at an eating establishment. I changed my mind about eating there with my family after being shown no concern for the event. Upon leaving, I was followed out the door by 2 people yelling at me. The young one was in my face while the elder threatened to drop me in front of my family. This continued until we got in our car and left. Perhaps they have good pizza but they are from being considerate human beings. You take your chances if you visit,

Delicious pizza — well seasoned, crispy crust, fresh. Friendly staff. This place was hopping tonight! We will definitely be back.

I’ve been a regular since it opened. The pizza is authentic Chicago style pizza. Same owner of NeNe’s who has excellent breakfast, lunch and phenomenal dinners (in season only). I will continue to be a regular at Island Pizza and Pasta Company.

So, I traditionally don’t complain about restaurants and while I realize that they must have been busy my experience was absolutely shocking. I called asking about a delivery that was now 1.5 hrs (from the time it was ordered) and when asked the guy said it was just being placed in the oven. While I was disappointed to hear this as I was feeding 3 kids, I figured I’d ask how much longer. He said 30 minutes to 1 hr. I repeated this back to him. And the reply «What the F do you want me to say, 15 minutes, 5 minutes, I am right outside your door.» He then hung up.
I called back twice and each time got placed right in voicemail. Finally spoke to someone who, without apologizing simply said «we will cancel your order».
Hopefully when I request the owner tomorrow I will get a more respectable response. I will be letting the hotel know of this experience.

Good pizza and salads the owners are from Chicago it’ good to find good pizza so far from home

Found them via Unilocal and was really hesitant to try them because they had no reviews. It was friday night and we had just arrived on the island tired and hungry. We threw caution to the wind and decided to give them a try. We were pleasantly surprised not just by the sizeof the pizza but also the taste. Amazing thin crust pizza delivered to your home piping hot. I’m definite fan and will order again.

good pizza, a bit greasy but good sized slices

Good thin crust pizza after a day at the beach. Minimal seating inside but it is primarily a take out place. The house salad with romaine, spinach, pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, green peppers, tomato, cheese, black olives, banana peppers & homemade croutons was a treat. A good choice when the better known pizza shops (Joey’s, Five Brothers) are standing room only.