Milk Jar Cookies

Milk Jar has a variety of cookies that aren’t very common and it was good to try. I do love dessert but just not anything too sweet. I ordered the BANANA SPLIT, and the CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER. The cookies were great. Next time I’d love to stay to enjoy it with coffee. :D ENJOY!

Cute shop. Kind of hidden. Parked in the back parking lot where it says ‘Americana Plaza’ visitors only (or something like that). Sashayed through the door before 8pm and we were the 2^nd peeps in line. Amen! Again, another place where the rush came after us.
Workers here super jolly and nice, throwing smiles like there was no tomorrow. So they have a fair assortment of cookies, some gluten free too. Tried the chocolate chip, banana split and salted caramel butterscotch cookies.
–Chocolate chip was filled with a thick goodness of chocolate and cookie dough.
–Banana split, I suppose I expected more. Little banana flavor and were there chocolate chips? I really want to like this cookie, do I try again?
–Salted caramel butterscotch, my husband’s new favorite cookie! He swears by it’s intense deliciousness. I didn’t try it, but I believe him. Upon leaving, he got the gluten free one too and it was equallyummy to him.
A dozen cookies are $ 30, half a dozen $ 15 and 3 cookies for $ 6. My husband wanted a dozen salted caramel butterscotch and I thought he’d went berzerk (perhaps another time).
Eating inside feels like you’re having tea & biscuits more than cookies & milk. Feels like home. Looking to fulfill your cookie craving? Indeed, it’s for sure worth a try!

These are cookies are delicious, fat, soft, expensive. How do you make cookies like these? They’re baked in such a way that the middle is thick but completely cooked. They will cost you though so I just purchased a couple for the road. They also offer gluten free cookies for celiacs. Parking sucks here. Be aware. I walked here from LACMA so it wasn’t too far.

Cookie monsters unite! This is a gem to all you with that aching sweet tooth for all desserts being cookies!
COOKIES: The perfect cookie involves the right amount of moist, crunch, flavor, & fluff. Milk Jar. I applaud you for having that with most of your cookies! My first visit was during the holidays as I treated my dad to cookies instead of cake for his birthday! We got a variety of half a dozen for $ 15. A few weeks later, I treated my family to yet another half dozen because I couldn’t help it. I missed some of those cookies too! So without much else, here are the flavors we had tried with both visits:
— Banana Split: Quirky cookie. It smells of bananas but taste of strawberries and vanilla. There were some chocolate in there as well. Given the title, it literally was a banana split with all aspects of a banana split present!
— Chocolate Chip/​Choc. Chip with Walnuts: The traditional cookie. Good, ordinary, just as you suspect for it to taste.
— Peppermint: My favorite! However. It was seasonal. Had I known how much I’d love it, would’ve gotten two! It wasn’t too sweet & the peppermint was in every bite, every piece, even every crumb! Delicious!
— Oatmeal Chocolate chip: Ack! Move on. This one was dry! Was not mine or my family’s favorite.
— White chocolate raspberry: Got this on both visits. The second time we had it, it was much sweeter. Didn’t seem like the middle was really baked through. But if you tried this cookie from Subway, it’s pretty much that but bigger & tastier.
— Mint Chocolate Chip: So imagine a thin mint but moist with chocolate chips! The taste got a bit tiring but it is what it is.
— Butterscotch (also seasonal!): Ah! Seriously. Their seasonal ones tend to be the game changer cookies! I was expecting this to be extremely sweet because of the butterscotch chunks they had in there but to my surprise, it was a great cookie!
— Rocky Road: This is the chocolate chip walnut cookie making babies with the double chocolate chip cookie & marshmallows being thrown in. Just like the banana split, it had every aspect of rocky road present making it successful but it was just alright.
FOR THE MOST PART, all the cookies are delicious. The flavors come off a bit flashy because they’re aiming for creative flavors! But some flavors should really just stick to being ice cream flavors. While the seasonal flavors should make extra reappearances! Milk Jar definitely aims to think outside of any grandma’s cookie box. With some hits & misses, I do applaud Milk Jar for bringing some fun back into the regular cookie.
Top hits:
— Photo-​worthy place! Cute interior that really ups your milk & cookies experience.
— They have gluten-​free cookies.
— Their cookies are just as deliciously paired with tea!
— 10% off with Unilocal check in
— They do ice cream sandwiches & their ice cream is by Fosselman’s! :)
Heads up:
— Parking is minimum but there is parking in their back lot!
— The cookies themselves are a good $ 3 individually. So I would HIGHLY recommend a half dozen assortment for your first visit!
Life’s short Unilocalers, so you better eat cookies to keep it sweet!

We received a box of Milk Jar cookies at work. And OH MY GOSH were they amazing. Even varieties that I wouldn’t typically like were delicious. If you are looking to impress and please with a variety pack of cookies, Milk Jar Cookies is your place.

After a couple hours of Art Appreciation at LACMA, we were craving some sweets; milk & cookies sounded divine and only a half mile from LACMA.
There’s no metered parking in front, but there is metered parking a block away on Wilshire.
Cute little shop with eclectic China plates & jars of milk; decorations of milk cans, Windsor chairs, distressed furniture. There are only a few tables (a couple outside), but we were able to grab one.
I had a white chocolate macadamia, while husband got the chocolate pecan caramel (plus he added a scoop of ice cream). Both cookies were very good, crisp, yet still chewy and sweet. I preferred the chocolate pecan caramel. Also, loved my small milk jar and they have cute paper decorated straws to sip away. Daughter had the Birthday & chocolate chip. We were all fans.
Further, staff was friendly.
Don’t know if I’d go out of my way to return, but would stop again if in the neighborhood.

When it comes to cookies, I just love a classic Chocolate Chip Cookie. Their big cookies are very filling that I usually eat half and save the other half for later. I love the slight crunch on the outside and enjoy biting into the chewy center with melted chocolate chips.
They also serve Fosselman’s Ice Cream, and my favorite flavor is the Toasted Marshmallow. I like the creamy vanilla flavor and bits of delicious charred marshmallows in every bite.
The décor is charming and cute just like a Pinterest board with DIY decorations and mason jars. It’s nice to get a 5 star sweet treat here because we are always greeted with friendly smiles. Milk Jar gets busy sometimes with every seat occupied, but don’t be fooled if the display is empty. They usually have warm cookies in the back, which are the best when they’re straight out of the oven.

Love!!! I was told by one of my friends to try this place while I was around and it did not disappoint. The girls working there have to be the nicest and I loved the chocolate chip cookie! While not my favorite, the mint chocolate was good at all. AND the place is adorable! If I lived around this would be my go to spot just to study and hang out. Also they have the cutest straws ever! Definitely recommended.

My girlfriend got me a bday package with cookies and milk in a glass jar. They delivered the package to my work and the milk was cold and the cookies were fresh.
Then we came to the store to try the cookies again. It’s a nice shop. The people were friendly and the décor was cute. It’s a good place to grab dessert. They had a decent variety of cookies to choose from. I liked every cookie I tried. They also had some gluten free cookies if you like those. They have ice cream, hot cocoa, tea, etc.
Delicious!

Milk Jar Cookies are pretty good. They’re fun, cute, and will likely be a hit with whomever you bless with their deliciousness. You generally stand to earn some nice street credibility by bringing Milk Jar Cookies to the party.
Milk Jar Cookies is a small cookie/​coffee shop in Mid-​Wilshire. It’s a cute spot – bring a date here and spend a little time inside, chatting, staring longingly into each other’s eyes, and enjoying some milk and cookies. Actually, enjoy milk and a cookie – their cookies are HUGE and very filling.
No seriously, the cookies are huge and delicious. One cookie will fill you up. I recommend splitting it in half or splitting with someone else. The cookies are also very rich. Sometimes overly so. But they’re tasty. I have always enjoyed the chocolate peanut butter and the regular chocolate chip, but I’m excited to try some of the other interesting flavors.
The one downside is Milk Jar can be a bit pricy. Just recently I bought a dozen cookies for $ 30. But recall that one cookie is really equivalent to two normal sized cookies. So you’re getting your money’s worth in mass, if not in quantity.
Milk Jar is a must if you are in need of cookies for a shindig and don’t have the skill or the time to make cookies yourself. It’s also an awesome spot to just check out. Highly recommend.

These are one of the best cookies I’ve ever had around LA — especially when they’re fresh out of the oven. I’ve tried most of their flavors now and they’re all really solid. My favorites are the chocolate pecan caramel and plain ol’ chocolate chip.
If you buy their drinks, they come with super cute straws too! And I beleive if you get a hot chocolate they drop in a homemade marshmallow. (haven’t had this, but I think my friend was telling mea bout it). They also sell jars of milk which I think is really cute and a great pairing with their cookies
It’s so bad (and good) that I live a 7 minute walk from this place… I end up coming here almost every time before I go to El Rey and whenever friends visit my place or have some time to spend before doing something else.

I like my cookies to be soft and chewy. I would not call myself a «cookie guy» because normally I turn them down once I see that they are hard. Just aint my thing. However Milk Jar perked my interest because of the deep gooey cookie that I have not really seen before.
Their store is super cute and the staff was quite fun. It was hard to decide what cookies we wanted, but I needed up getting the Double Chocolate and Snickerdoodle. I loved the cookies, but really wish that I came at the time when they were fresh out of the oven, the brand new cookies being put out were both Gluten free and I wasn’t too into them. The only thing that could have made these cookies better was if they were warm, because the inside was chewy and the outside was cooked with a little crisp. Actually like no other cookie I’ve really had before.
My friends got some milk poured into cute little milk jars and I was lame and just had water, but we sat down at the tables and enjoyed what felt like a tea party atmosphere as we giggled and shared our cookies. «I’mma only get one» we thought walking through the door, six cookies between us later… we felt the sugar when we were walking out.

I’ve been wanting to come to this place forever! The pictures I saw of the cookies from here looked so good I had to make a visit soon. Walking in, the aroma of the place was strong and I immediately got super happy seeing all the cookies hahah!
I was worried they would only make a specific number of batches in the morning & then sell until they run out. But nope! They constantly make them throughout the day so when I came midday around 3:30 PM, the cookie trays were almost all filled. It was hard to choose because they all looked so good. I ended up trying the oatmeal raisin, chocolate chip walnut and peppermint bark cookies. Oatmeal raisin cookies are my favorite in general and the one I tried here is now my all time favorite. It was really soft & wasn’t chewy like other oat cookies. It was perfect! The chocolate chip walnut was good as well. I recommend this one if you like chocolates and walnuts. It wasn’t too chocolatey. The chocolate and walnuts balanced each other very well. The peppermint bark is a great holiday season flavor. Overall, all the cookies I tried here were super delicious! I will come back to try other flavors next time. They also have ice cream and milk which I’m sure is even better with the already amazing cookies.
Also, I like how the cookies aren’t flat but rather pretty thick and large. But if you’re paying $ 3 for a cookie it should be expected to be a bigger cookie than average. The plates they come on when it’s ordered for here are vintage looking. So cute!

A cute little dessert shop on Wilshire! I’ve been eyeing this place forever but I was able to come through with a few friends after a day at LACMA (just a few block away).
We were greeted with very friendly staff. They had just baked a fresh batch of cookies so all the assortments looked delicious. It was on the pricey end for me. 1 cookie was around $ 3 and it was an average size. I ended up with the Rocky Road: chocolate based dough with slivered almonds and melted marshmallow on top. Very tasty and mine was warm. A little on the sweet side of things too. I also tried my friend’s Chocolate Chip with Walnuts and it was very tasty too. The dough was buttery and had the right amount of chocolate and walnut ratio. My other friend had the white chocolate raspberry. I think it was my favorite so far as the combo of the raspberry & cookie was delish!
Definitely coming back if I’m in the area.

Yaaayyyy my bookmark of this place can finally be removed. I’ve had this place bookmarked for over 2 years now and I finally had the opportunity to come here over the weekend.
I loveee this place!!! Milk Jar cookies is on Wilshire Blvd, the parking here is very difficult I don’t know if they have their own parking in the back or not but I had to park elsewhere for $ 1.00. But it was well worth it. I pulled up to 5466 Wilshire blvd walked right in and I truly fell in love. This shop is sooo cute and so perfect. I loved that they had a good selection of cookies which were not your ordinary. I ended up getting a half dozen cookies along with a glass of milk. They were very nice to warm my cookie upon my request. The cookie that I had ate there was the chocolate chip walnut it was good but not my favorite out of the bunch. I loved that my milk was served in a little mason cup and their straws were just sooo cute little striped swivle straws.
The other 5 cookies they wrapped for me individually and placed them in a brown box with a ribbon. I mean how cool and how cute is that. I was so impressed. The best part is that I got a 10 percent off with my Unilocal Check in!
The Banana split had to be my all time favorite, it was a burst of flavors in your mouth and it was just sooo good. It was banana dough filled with caramel, chocolate chips and strawberries inside. It literally melts in your mouth. The Chocolate pecan caramel was great too. I highly recommend warming them up and drinking it with a tall glass of milk and enjoy every single morsel.
Cookies were $ 3.00 each, $ 15.00 for a half dozen, and $ 30.00 for a dozen. They also sell ice cream which I’ll have to try next time. All in all a great place, feels like your in Grandma’s home with their wooden table/​chairs/​china on the walls and the china they put your cookie on. Very homely feel. I love it! Will come back!

3.5 stars
I was looking forward to finding the best tasting cookie ever. Unfortunately, these cookies missed the mark for me overall.
This is a cozy, little shop offering multiple flavors of cookies. Staff was very friendly. We decided to get 6 to try different flavors. Each cookie is $ 3. If you purchase a ½ dozen, it costs $ 15.
Each cookie is sizable. For me, the chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia nut, pecan caramel, and oatmeal chocolate chip were soft but with a cake-​like consistency and a bit underwhelming.
My favorite was the rocky road with walnuts and marshmallow, but it was more like a dense, brownie consistency. If I had only tried this particular cookie, it would’ve been 4 stars.
parking — metered but free after 4PM on Sat/​Sun

The best cookies in LA! They have so many flavor options. The cookies are huge, big enough to share. Somehow they make them a little crispy on the outside and ooey gooey on the inside. I don’t really get science but I’m glad they do.
My favorite flavors are the birthday cake and chocolate chip!
The customer service is great. The employees know they’re stuff and are always happy to recommend something.
You can get your cookies on a plate, which makes for a good Instagram picture.

BANANA SPLIT COOKIE.
Banana batter, walnuts, butterscotch chips, peanut butter chips, and a strawberry slice jammed in the middle. Delicious, chunky, soft in the middle.
Do it, best cookie I’ve had in a long time. I wish this could replace every cookie in existence at every coffee shop (Bold statement, I know).
Can I just say, Milk Jar makes it super convenient for those who need a quick, cutely packaged gift box of cookies. I ordered a custom box and you can customize a hand-​written note with your box of cookies. No extra charge, you can do it online. The process was very convenient and efficient!
Tip: I would just call ahead to the store to confirm the order before pick up.
Down side: Other than the Banana Split cookie, the other cookies I tried [pumpkin (seasonal), oatmeal raisin, and chocolate peanut butter] weren’t as good and a little underwhelming.
A price point of a cookie is $ 3 which is double the price of your local Starbucks (not comparing, just sayin’).
Just do as I say and get a Banana Split cookie. All will be right in this world.

I’ve been wanting to try Milk Jar Cookies for years now. I went with my friends to a store nearby and we just happened to walk by Milk Jar. I was so excited to try it out since my friends have been talking about this place for a few months.
It’s a cute little cookie shop that offers fresh cookies, ice cream, coffee and drinks. The lady that helped us out was so friendly and gave some of her suggestions on which cookies to order.
/​/​COOKIES & ICE CREAM /​/​
Horchata ice cream: A light horchata flavor with the typical hints of cinnamon. I enjoyed the ice cream since it wasn’t too sweet and had a subtle flavor.
Banana split cookie: By far the best cookie that I tried here! The lady said this is the second best selling cookie behind the all time favorite chocolate chip cookie. The banana split cookie included nuts, chocolate chips, banana and a slice of strawberry on top. It was delicious!
Chocolate caramel pecan cookie: Sounds delicious, right? Unfortunately this cookie came up short. It didn’t have a lot of flavor and it would have been nice if they had more caramel in it.
Lemon blueberry: This one was suggested to us by the lady. She said it was back and was the cookie of the month. It was a lemon cookie with actual blueberries in it. I was expecting a stronger lemon flavor, but this cookie was pretty light.
Overall, I enjoyed the banana split cookie and the horchata ice cream, but the other two cookies came up short and that’s why I only think it’s worth 3 stars. Milk Jar is also pretty pricey for what you get. The 3 cookies and scoop of ice cream came out to $ 12. They clearly use quality ingredients which explains the price, but I doubt I’ll come back based on this experience.

COOKIE monster’s dream in LA
$ 3 soft, thick cookies with some inner cookie dough consistencies but slight hints of buttery crust on the outside. not the best i’ve had but still enjoyable
–chocolate chip: so simple but this is the way to go, chocolate chips were still nice & melty
–banana split: seems to be the most popular but i wasn’t a fan of the baked strawberries in this one
–iced coffee: a bit watered down but then again this isn’t a coffee shop
NOTE: don’t forget to check in for 10% off your order