Cappy’s Pizza

Went for the buffet, hardly any options and the pizza was terrible. Don’t go.

Good pizza! We always get it cooked extra crispy. My husband also likes their wings.
Salads are good as well but not a fan of their Italian sub.

Quality-​wise, this is the most «quality» pizza in London. The pizza is pretty delicious and the seating area is very clean. Within the last year, they moved to a new location.
The salads are good, but the the wings are puny. They lack size and be warned that the mild is Frank’s Hot Sauce, while the hot wings are Frank’s Extreme Hot Sauce.
I dropped them down a star for having poor quality wings and just okay salads. They’re better known for the great pizza at Cappy’s! Well worth the pizza pies!

Well if you like pepperoni pizza this is the buffet for you because that’s about the only kind of pizza they put on it. I expected a few different selections for $ 8 per person

Awesome Pizza! One of the best! The meat head special is amazing! This is a regular stop for us!

The food was good, but the service overshadowed it. We always like to try different local places rather than chains. When we first walked in we sat down at the table for about 10 – 15 minutes and THEN realized we needed to order then sit down. Meanwhile workers were cleaning and could have said something while we were just sitting there. Maybe a «hey you need to order first!» Rather than just letting us sit there. The food came promptly and was good. For being a newer restaurant you really think they would go out of their way to provide the best service, but we did not witness during this visit.

Worst pizza ever Cappy Favorite. Guys change supplier of Pepperoni. If it’s grease then it’s not properly aged. Lack luster flavor. If you think this best you probably don’t get out much. Brought appetizer out with pizza. Biggest waste of $ 26 this entire trip!

This place is pretty fantastic. It has become our local go to during or after long bike rides. The pizza is glorious. Thin (ish) crust, a little spice to the sauce– really a contender for the best pizza I have had in central Ohio. The service is generally friendly, though the place could definitely use a touch up or two.
They have beer. Good, cheap domestic beer.

The greatest pizza I have ever had. I grew up with it my whole life and so did my parents. My family from columbus drives to london to pick up a pizza. Just to fill the urge and have the memories they had growing up ful filled

Great Pizza!!! I’m craving it now.

We just discovered this place and love the thin crust.
The lunch buffet is great and the price is right. Pizza, salad, and more. Great!

Pizza calls me mostly on Friday or Saturday evenings like some summoned Pizza Zombie Queen, it is in my veins to try new and interesting pizza joints outside of your normal chain places.
Cappy’s can consider themselves different in the vast and overcrowded pizza realm that is Ohio.
Cappy’s pizza has to be one of the thinest pizza crusts I have ever eaten AND the crunchiest as well with small pepperoni’s curling up and pooling with grease.
Cappy’s = Cracker crust… hands down.
The way Cappy’s ordering works is you walk in, and order at the window, then the food is brought to you. This might prove a frustrating concept for some, but whatever, it worked for me, and there’s no need to deal with having to tip the server since everything is mostly self-​serve.
The back workings of this place is like something out of the movie Metropolis. I’m expecting to see people turning cogs, and pulling levers, while steam pours out around them. There was quite a few people back there… all sweltering in the heat of the pizza ovens. Poor guys.
Cappy’s was not bad at all in my opinion, but it was a bit of a drive being all the way out in London.
It’s still good pizza that stands by itself and is worth a try.

A great local pizza shop. The style of their pizza is unique. The pepperoni are the tiny ones that cup up and collect grease and the cheese is generous. Consistency is the reason for a four star review. The pizza is usually great, but sometimes it’s just good.

I have never had pizza like Cappy’s anywhere else. The sauce and crust are truly their own. You will either love it or hate it. I love it right down to the pools of oil that form in the pepperoni pieces. They are generous with the cheese and they cut the pie in squares.