My Pizza

After a nice long record of awesome service and pizzas, they have either closed or moved.

Called the number listed and it was disconnected. I called a few times in case I had misdialed. I guess they must be out of business.

Really bummed this place is out of business they had great specials for bulk orders for parties and groups!

Great pizza but a little pricey for the toppings. However you should definitely give it a try. Owned are very nice and friendly. I wish them all luck. Seems that they enjoy what they do

The owner/​staff seemed extremely nice but to me their pizza just tastes blahhhh. I’d rather have Little Caesars which has similar quality for half the price.

The crust did seem a little pre made, but overall the pizza had good flavor. Tried the Italian beef with giaridiniera… boy it was a bit too hot for me. Tasty but too hot! Price was ehh… the above pizza, large size, plus tax and delivery was $ 26.

We recently moved back to the area from Milwaukee, and are thrilled that we hit the nail on the head with the first pizza joint we ordered from (thanks to fellow Unilocalers). It was also a pleasant surprise to find that we didn’t have to add our own oregano to the finished product. It’s the little things in life.
We ordered two pizzas for delivery, which was very timely. We thought the Italian beef specialty pizza would steal the show, but as it turned out, everyone really loved the sausage and mushroom most. Both were frankly phenomenal, and lucky us – we had leftovers for days!
It’s amazing how simple, quality, fresh ingredients can take a pizza to a whole different level, especially in such a competitive pizza market. Some more added bonuses: online ordering, and huge bang for your buck. My only tip for improvement would be to stay open later, but that may be very bad for my health. Try it out and you’ll understand what I mean. Enough said.

Very good pizza. Very generous with the cheese and ingredients.

Not good on all counts, except for the nice guy that delivered the food. Pizza was subpar at best. Gnocchi was inedible. Pasta was just drowning in butter and garlic. Salad was uninspired to put it kindly. People in this area must just not be too picky about pizza/​Italian food. Cannot fathom why this place is 4 stars…

I eat a lot of pizza. My tastes aren’t overly complex, but I do know what I like and good pizza. We went here while in town for work and were pleasantly surprised. Their Margarita pizza was fantastic, but I wasn’t as big of a fan of the cheese bread. However if it’s a pizza place I rate them on their pizza alone. I’ve had pizza all over the US in dives, in swanky modern places, in hometown chains, frozen, the next day, whatever. My Pizza beats out all of my previous pizza experiences.
Comment from my friend, «you know its going to be good when an 80 year old woman is ladling and spreading sauce for 10 minutes on your pizza»
The owner is very very friendly and the pizza is great!

This is our go-​to delivery pizza place. Much better than rozattis, Dominick’s or Gianorios. Much more reasonably priced as well. Haven’t ordered anything other than the pizza but I would highly recommend you give this place a try.

A great place to get an inexpensive dinner. My family orders from here frequently. The prices are great. The pizza is good. I’ve never had any major issues.
The gluten free pizza is decent. I need to do a gluten free diet now and having a pizza place close by is a benefit. The gf crust isn’t as crisp as I would like… but that is gluten free dining for you.
We did the $ 85 catering special for my son’s birthday. The chicken, pasta, and beef was great. Everyone loved it. The order was a bit later than I hoped it would be. However, the delivery driver was so kind and apologetic, I couldn’t be upset.
Thanks for helping our budget minded pizza cravings. We have almost forgotten that Little Caesar’s exists!

I feel honored living two turns away from this magical place. It’s essentially Rosati’s quality thin-​crust pizza for a fraction of the price ! I remember stopping by during their first few months of opening, and I have honestly NEVER been even the slightest upset with their quality or service. I’m probably one of their most loyal customers and they just treat me so well. The old man who runs the place remembers my name, and what I usually get just by facial recognition… You just don’t get that at other restaurants. Or at least I haven’t! I am finally writing this review after ordering COUNTLESS pizzas from this place. Recently, I was at a friends house who had ordered a thin crust pizza from Giordano’s, and I can honestly say that it actually LACKED flavor compared to My Pizza’s thin crust, even though they charged my friend $ 20 more than what My Pizza would’ve charged. Aside from that I also noticed that the consistency of the Giardano’s pizza crust was literally almost exactly like My Pizza’s pizza crust. All-​in-​all, this place has great service, amazing quality at an amazingly affordable price-​range, and is open pretty late. There is absolutely no reason as to why you shouldn’t check this place out !
EDIT: changed my initial 5 star rating to 3 stars because they jacked up the price

Yuck. I now see why their prices are so low. Pizza is seriously subjective, but if you like full-​flavor pizza and toppings, this isn’t your place. We ordered a thin crust pepperoni. Crust was bland, thicker than any «thin crust» I’ve ever had. Garden salad was sad… just iceberg with a small sprinkling of «vegetables». Also, I guess the main phone # is the owner (?)‘s cell phone… we called to order last weekend, no one picked up when we called twice during their open hours… and then that guy called back and left a voicemail saying sorry, this is My Pizza calling you back, sorry we missed your call. Weird! This is not going to be our go-​to pizza place.

I’ve received two Unilocal messages asking me to try this place– in several years of Unilocaling I’ve never had that happen with any other place. I wondered if it was someone associated with the restaurant.
We ordered a thin crust bacon pizza on a Sunday (I really appreciate their generous hours– many local places don’t open until the late afternoon on Sundays). The pizza was unique– the crust thin, not particularly crispy, but the cheese seemed strange– like it wasn’t melted all the way and like it was one thick piece on top of very little sauce. The bacon was perfect and spread out well over the pizza. I didn’t care for it, my husband thought it was OK but then liked it a whole lot more the second day when it was reheated for leftovers.
The price is excellent and that is a very positive thing in this area. I’m sure a lot of people are great fans– it just didn’t strike me as a new favorite. I hope they continue to do well, though!

They deliver till 1, it’s the best pizza within 10 minutes, and it’s absurdly cheap. It’s like they opened this place and designed their menu around my love of inebriation.

Everything about this place is amazing. I can only wish them the best of success in the future. The owner (?) is an amazing soul.
It’s not a «sit down» sort of place, but the owner told me to come in anyway with my date and he’d get us a table. Which he did. And in the middle of the date, while my date was not around, he asked me if the girl I was with was my girlfriend…
I said yes. And he actually sent us a custom-​made, heart-​shaped pizza.
Beautiful. Who’d of thought a joint like this would turn out to be the best date I’ve ever had :]]]
Thank you for everything, My Pizza. I had a beautiful night thanks to your selflessness and true understanding of what it means to make a customer truly happy.
A-​grade pizza too. And bosco sticks.
A+++ service.
What a wonderful night you have given to us.

My Guys! In Chicago — we really take to friendly, down to earth people who still bring their A game.
That is what they have done since they opened and I have been supporting them since around that time. Appreciate they take to their customer’s name, will run out to the grocery store if someone orders spinach (less ordered choice I imagine) and as mentioned the price often beats the best deal from Pizza Hut, Papa Johns.
I recommend the Sausage, the Cheese or ½ and ½.
Now I live in Naperville but still visit whenever I am on 355. Support small biz!

Conversations at the M household…
Let’s get pizza.
OK, where from?
Oh, I dunno, where do we have coupons for?
Much shuffling of flyers ensues. We have many options. On this particular Saturday, we decide to finally try My Pizza, which I have driven past dozens of times. We don’t need a coupon? That 7.95 price is every day? All righty then! We got a large pepperoni for carryout.
For less than a large at Pizza Hut, you don’t expect too much. But this is good stuff. The thin crust is rather crackery, but still doughy in the middle. The cheese breaks off when you bite into it, and had a nice just-​starting-​to-​caramelize brownness. The sauce was well-​seasoned. The pepperoni was salty and meaty.
I’ve paid far more for far worse pizza — it’s not quite in my upper pantheon of pizza, but it’s very good, and a fantastic value at that.

Thanks to fellow Unilocalers for the tip on this place. Like the others I couldn’t believe it could be good at this price, but we were pleasantly surprised. It’s definitely a step or two above the likes of a papa johns or little cesears. The garlic bread is fantastic. I know it’s just a French roll with some butter and garlic, but it was darn good.
The staff is friendly and very courteous,