P & R Bagelicious

I always call ahead and order bagel, egg, bacon and cheese sandwich! Best breakfast sandwich ever! Always prompt friendly service! So happy Bagelicious is in my neighborhood! Thank you!

Awful service. Ordered 1 bagel with cream cheese and 1 bagel egg sandwich to go. Waited 27 minutes without any acknowledgement or apology. 4 separate parties came in after us and were served before us, including 1 table of 5 men who all ordered full bagel, egg & meat meals. Once we did receive our food, the plain bagel was barely toasted and more of a fluffy dough ball, smeared with a thin layer of cream cheese. For a business where the kitchen is open, you can see everyone running frantically and rushing, not to mention they are not the most joyous people in food service. I’ve waitressed for 7 years and loved caring for my customers, and I definitely understand a morning breakfast rush. This place is not worth it, better off going to Wegmans.

My husband goes here every Sunday to get fresh bagels. If you go before 8 am some of the bagels are just coming out of the oven. Delicious inexpensive meals if you eat in the resteraunt. Free coffee refills. I wish they would bring back their apple cinnamon cream cheese. There was one lady who knew our bagel order when he walked in. 5 years we have been going here. My husband says the best bagels outside of NYC.

Went to their full service spot today for breakfast. 1^st impression, clean and friendly. A good start. the waitress greeted me right at the door and sat me. She was there with coffee right away. Coffee was good. Nothing special but good. Took my order promptly. Ordered eggs over easy with sausage, ham, everything bagel and home fries. I was surprised the home fries were extra but was fine with it. Got a little worried as people kept coming in, and their were only 2 servers, but my order came out right away and coffee refills were offered without missing a beat. Now to the food. Eggs came out perfect. Sausage was a patty, and only came with one but was tasty. Ham was nice and grilled. The stars were the everything bagel which was old school NY style and the home fries were delicious. Next time I will ask to have them crispier and then they will be through the roof good. So, final impression, clean, friendly spot for a good breakfast at a decent price. I will be back.

Bagelicious is such a great local breakfast place. Their bagels are ALWAYS fresh, and they mix their own cream cheese flavors. They also offer a variety of other breakfast options, such as sandwiches and platters (bacon, eggs, etc.) They also make some fantastic stuffed French toast — I order mine with their homemade cinnamon raisin bread. The staff there is friendly and always gets my order right — if you’re lucky, Rich (the owner) will be there working. Any morning you can find some neighborhood folks there talking sports, politics, or whatever else is news. Prices are reasonable, especially considering the cream cheese they pile on the bagels. The only thing I don’t like there are the homefries because they cook them with ketchup, and I don’t like ketchup. But I can always rely on them for a satisfying breakfast served with a smile.