Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties

My first experience with the delicious Sugardaddy’s was on a business trip. I visited the Easton Town Center location. The brownies were amazing and the client service was wonderful! The staff makes you feel happy and appreciated. I now have them delivered to my home. Their blondies and brownies are scrumptious! My favorite are the Drunken Chunky, American Beauty, the Auburn and Caramel. I guess I love most of them! They taste like my mom and I make them– homemade! If you love rich, high quality baked goods, you will love them! They even use espresso in one brownie, it really enhances the flavor of the chocolate!
I am so thrilled that I found Sugardaddy’s! Thank you for exceptional brownies!

My sister loves their brownies, so I bought a bunch of the 2 inch size for her baby shower. I’d say if you go here, go for one of the «busier» flavors. I find that the Plain Jane chocolate brownies aren’t as fudgy and chocolate-​y as I like, but some of the other flavors are pretty yummy.

These brownies are exceptionally terrible.
If you’re the type of a person to have a nemesis, you could send these brownies to them. Your nemesis. You send them a package (the packaging is cute enough) filled with a variety of flavors. They decide to try the «campfire» brownie first. It is shaped like a s’more with marshmallow in the middle. Super. S’mores are wonderful.
They take a bite.
«Oh. This is really sweet,» they say. «I can’t taste anything but sugar. And it’s crumbly in a gross way. Swing and a miss, but this is the s’more brownie. I’ll try a normal one.»
They take a bite of a chocolate brownie from Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties.
They chew it.
And as they chew it, they make a face that looks like they are eating a teaspoon of wet beach sand.
Their eyes – hollow, cold – lose focus on this world. Hate fills their veins.
«Who could have done this to me? What walking horror could rob me of any sensation of flavor…»
There are still 4 unopened brownies. They get unwrapped and left for the Nemesis’ dog. The dog licks them for a second, then goes outside, and eats his own feces.

I have been spying on this bakery since October ’14 — I’m so glad today was the perfect occasion to stop in. If you are a fan of the brownie, this is your new place to go! The selection of sweets are deliciously indulgent, the customer service was beyond outstanding & most importantly, the pricing was very reasonable! Great place to visit if your looking to make someone’s day especially «yummy», Can’t wait to go back for myself!

There is a special place in hell for dessert places that close at 4 on Saturday.

I’ve never had a blondie until Sugardaddy’s came around and they are sooo gooood!
They are on the sweeter side (imo) so its’ perfect to have it with a glass of milk.
I’ve tried most of their blondie flavors and the most memorable one is the chai spiced!
They also caters so if you need some sweets at your party this is the place to go! They do a really good job catering!

Found Sugardaddy’s while driving around on our last visit to Columbus. I had just passed my state boards and my sister and I were looking for fun ways to celebrate. Wow what a great find!
We bought a selection of these awesome brownie/​cookies and I was not dissapointed in the least. However, for someone like my sister who does not like things in her brownies they had nothing to offer. Thus why I gave them ⁴⁄₅ stars. I would recommend they at least keep one plain option open for people who just want something simple yet decadent. That said I will certainly still look forward to stopping here when we go thru Columbus. We brought home a selection and I have decided that since they ship overnight I will reward myself every so often by having some shipped in!
The attendant who waited on us was awesome. She took time to explain their products, told us about shipping and was really a pleasure to speak with. The shop itself is beautiful. It has such a great vibe and is laid out beautifully. I could definitely see using them as a place to send special treats from.
Hope you enjoy it as much as I did!

I am from the Columbus area and used Sugardaddy’s for large orders back when it was under prior ownership. I currently live in Pennsylvania and thought their packaged brownies would be nice Christmas Party gifts. To say I am disappointed in what happened with my current order is an understatement. I ordered it a MONTH in advance, on-​line, with everything in writing — the order did not arrive on time for our party and then, when a package from Sugardaddy’s did show up, it was so completely the wrong order I can’t even understand how it could be so mixed up. I have called twice to find out what happened and why my order was so poorly handled — I spoke with Beth who immediately refunded my money — but that didn’t really help me as the money wasn’t the issue — it was the gifts for guests I had arriving at my house the next day that I no longer had. So I spent time that I did not have the evening prior to our party out trying to find replacements. Beth was to call me back either Friday, (¹²⁄₁₁) or Monday, (¹²⁄₁₄) to explain what happened with my order. It is Tuesday, ¹²⁄₁₅ — no call. Exactly what I expected from the trail of poor customer service I have received to date. What a shame — I know lots of large companies in the Columbus area and a few conferences that are coming to town in 2015 — I will be sure and recommend they NOT count on Sugardaddy’s for any gift or welcome bags! How disappointing!

OUTSTANDING costumer service and delicious sweets! Staff couldn’t be any nicer or more accommodating. As well, their products are consistent, delicious, and high quality! Every time I’m in town, I never miss out on a trip to Sugar Daddy’s!

I went and did not expect much from the very pink and blinged out storefront. However, I was pleasantly surprised by the brownie options available and appreciated the fact that you could either get a small or large version of each brownie. I bought several different varieties and liked them all.

Wanted to surprise my sister for V-​Day who is currently a student at Kenyon College. Due to procrastination, I had to find a place that would do a last minute delivery. Thank God that I found this place. They were extremely accommodating and were able to help me out. I was able to place a delivery over the phone and arrange for overnight delivery. Soooo soooo happy!
Can’t wait to taste these brownies myself when I go down there in the Spring… OH YEAH!!!

I dropped in here not too long ago. I had a coupon that was going to expire and, well, who can let free Sweeties go to waste? :) The lady working the counter was super friendly, though, and mentioned that actually they will take coupons even after they are technically expired, so that is awesome news. If you have some left over entertainment books, keep that in mind.
Anyway, the sweeties are still delicious, but my favorites are definitely the blondies, especially that Tahitian.
One note: it might be best to go a bit earlier in the day, especially if you plan to make a large purchase of sweeties. I arrived not too far from closing time, and while every flavor was still available, the quantity was getting limited. Worth the visit, though.

Still delicious and wonderful. Just visited the Easton location where I was treated to the caramel, the s’more, and the tahiti. These delicious little bites could be a meal in themselves, and I had to hold myself back from visiting for a third day in a row.

I stopped into Sugardaddy’s after lunch when I needed to satisfy my sweet tooth. I wasn’t sure what to expect.
The guy working the counter explained how things work, which the other review seem to portray very well. Round brown/​blondies and their trimmings. One of the great things is that all 16 types are baked fresh daily.
I tried a Chai spiced flavored blondie. The blondie was big and perfectly baked — not too soft, not too hard. However, my mom’s pumpkin pie has more spice than that did. The flavor could best be described as a weak spice cake. I went to their website before writing this. They list 9 different spices plus pistachios as ingredients. Not much, apparently. Come on Sugardaddy, don’t be afraid of flavor! It could have been a great little treat. Instead it was just ok.

I am thoroughly impressed! Just hours after I wrote my first review, I received a response from one of the owners apologizing for the less than stellar pumpkin blondie and asking me to please come in and get a few on the house! Who does that? A business owner who really cares about his products AND customer service… a rare breed of entrepreneur that cares about more than the bottom line! Sure, having happy customers eventually helps the bottom line, but have you seen the press these guys have gotten? I’m sure they could make a living on just first time customers alone… anyway, I am impressed with their customer service, attention to detail and of course their DELICIOUS chocolate treats!
Next time I am in Columbus I will be back to get my couple of freebies and will happily pay full price for a bunch more!

With the same amazing concoctions and commitment to service as their downtown location, but more space to take a look around and sample (not to mention the parking is a little easier!), if you want a treat and you’re in the neighborhood this is a no-​brainer.
I especially love the extra mile they’ll go to if you ask for a hand — when I mentioned I was getting a box of brownies for my anniversary, they offered to wrap the box and provide a gorgeous ribbon at no extra charge!

So I thought about giving Sugardaddy’s 1 star.
Why??? because I know that the owners of Sugardaddys are so committed to excellence they would probably bend over backwards trying to correct my completely made up-​bad experience and quite possibly shower me with brownies for life.. .
.. . but that seems like bad dessert karma and, as cream cheese frosting as my witness, I want no part of that.
Truth is.. . Sugardaddys are amazing. Amazing also, that my favorite items aren’t even the brownies. The cheesecake — made with brownie crust is for lack of a better word, heavenly.
My favorite treat is the biscotti paired with a shot of icing (50 cents for a mini cup of deliciousness is by far the best half dollar I have ever spent).
But about the brownies.. . yeah those are good too!
The peanut butter chocolate was tasty — not too sweet. The chocolate with caramel and chocolate raspberry were perfectly balanced and the Drunken Chunky was more like a cookie but taaaaaaasty.
Yeah each brownie costs over 3 bucks but this isn’t something you’re going to splurge on everyday. The price is worth it and if you want to impress someone, especially someone who lives outside of the Columbus area show up with a few of these treats.

Oh my but these things are deadly good! Hubs had forgotten it was the week to acknowledge all of the hard work that admins do and asked me if I had any ideas what to get his admin. With a sly grin and a waggle of the eyebrows I said «Leave it to me!»
I rolled into here and met — again — one of the owners who recognized me as the allergy girl from the elite party. He hooked me up with a lovely tower of brownies and blondies each in their own individual container topped with a bow that said thank you! (and a blondie that I could eat to go for me!) As I have no idea what brownie flavors are good, he picked them out for me.
In conclusion — I saved hubs bacon. His admin is now a fan of Sugardaddy’s. This place is desert nirvana with the best customer service. Hubs owes me — hehehe.

An establishment’s reputation can be completely unknown before an event and clear as day after. My night’s experiences with Sugardaddy’s offerings at our recent YEE were one thing. When those were augmented by glowing reviews from other attendees, wide-​eyed acknowledgment from friends at the Sugardaddy’s name, and covetous glances toward my brownie goodie bag, ignorance gave way to understanding.
You won’t see me review dessert venues or bakeries often. Jeni’s, Pattycake, Pistacia Vera, sure, all great. I just don’t fall over backwards at the thought of going to those establishments. Growing up in a completely sugar free, vegan household, I don’t have the generic American sweet tooth developed through a combination of sugary cereals and a candy bar with every lunch. Dessert just isn’t a normal part of my repertoire (and my waistline is happier for it). While we’re at it, the word blondie was once barely in my vocabulary. A brownie without chocolate may as well be a brick.
Upon hearing Sugardaddy’s name as the venue for February’s Elite event, I felt my interest wane. «What the hell kind of name is that?» I thought. «It’s syrupy, tongue twisting and a bit pretentious at the same time.» I didn’t even know what they offered, yet visions of Elites hopped up to excess on sweets and wine filled my brain, with everyone finding themselves sugar comatose before the event even ended.
These irrationalities dissipated upon trying the bakery’s offerings. Each brownie and blondie is a dense affair with a sweetness better balanced than boxed preparations or even other gourmet attempts to which I’d become accustomed. To my palate, these lovepucks hit the right notes. They’re not schmaltzy, generic ballads but rather sophisticated, delicately planned masterworks. (I’d call them well-​rounded if that weren’t a punny descriptor of the brownies’ unique shape.) Of course, the blondies surprised me most. As previously mentioned, I am no devotee of the genre, yet I found myself gravitating towards them as much as (or perhaps even more than) Sugardaddy’s brownies. A return visit was required.
Four days later I found myself at their Polaris-​area location for another go at those sweeties, grabbing a half dozen. The delicately spicy Fiery didn’t make it two blocks. A Rich Mint was torn limb from limb at dinner later with fellow Unilocalers, its layer of buttercream icing drooling out between the brownie halves sandwiching it. Hey, what makes for a better breakfast than a chocolate chip cookie? A Drunken Chunky blondie, of course! At dinner I split a Cinnamon blondie with a friend and gave a Plain Jane and an American Beauty away to excited recipients. Six sweeties, all annihilated within twenty-​four hours of purchase. All excellent.
Everybody really should want a Sugardaddy.

I’m not sure which is sweeter: the brownies or the service.
Seriously, I felt compelled to write this review because of the amazing service given at Sugardaddy’s. Don’t get me wrong, these are indeed the best brownies I have ever eaten, but the amazing personalities behind Sugardaddy’s will keep you coming back.
So, get this: A few months back, I wrote a review of a Saturday trip to Pistacia Vera where I mentioned that we had first tried to go to Sugardaddy’s, but they were closed. And a while later (maybe a few weeks?), I received a message from Tom and Mark (the owners) to let me know that they were now open on Saturdays. Seriously? How freakin’ nice of them!
And this brings me to yesterday. A friend was in town visiting, and he wanted to try a brownie from Sugardaddy’s. I called before visiting the downtown location, and Tom told me that only the Polaris location was open that day because of the holiday. So, we drove to Polaris. Boy, was the experience worth the drive! The three guys working there (I know one was Mark!) were insanely friendly and genuine. They offered us samples of different kinds of brownies and blondies, and they were just a delight to chat chat with.
If you need a sugar fix or a great gift for someone, go check out Sugardaddy’s. They work really hard to make everything special.